wall street main street your street how investors impact
play

Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Feb 17, 2023 •757 likes •1.08k views

Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the Single-Family Housing Market Sean Brunson, Richard Buttimer Jr. University of North Carolina at Charlotte May 2020 Home Price Indices 140 130 120 CaseShiller 110 Zillow

  1. Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the Single-Family Housing Market Sean Brunson, Richard Buttimer Jr. University of North Carolina at Charlotte May 2020

  2. Home Price Indices 140 130 120 Case−Shiller 110 Zillow 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

  3. Popular Press “Affordable Housing Crisis Spreads Throughout World” – Wall Street Journal (2019) “America’s Housing Affordability Crisis Only Getting Worse” – Forbes (2019) “America’s Housing Affordability Crisis Spreads to the Heartland” – Bloomberg (2019) “Investors Are Buying More of the U.S. Housing Market Than Ever Before” – Wall Street Journal (2019) “1st-Time Homebuyers Are Getting Squeezed Out By Investors” – NPR (2019)

  4. Overview Empirically examine the entrance of institutional investors in the single-family housing market before and after the 2007-2009 recession Using home sale transactions for the Charlotte region between the years 2005-2017, find that institutional investors paid about 8.13%-11.19% less than owner-occupiers per transaction Additionally, find that an increase in investor home purchases had a positive statistical impact on individual home prices but only a moderate economic impact

  5. Economic Policy/Proposals Executive Order Establishing a White House Council on Eliminating Regulatory Barriers to Affordable Housing – Donald Trump (2019) American Housing and Economic Mobility Act – Elizabeth Warren (2019) People First Housing – Julian Castro (2019) Assembly Bill 1482 – California (2019)

  6. Was It Just a Demand Shock? Could be that investors were just consolidating the existing single-family rental market Could be that preferences shifted from owning to renting Could be that investors were actually outbidding owner-occupiers

  7. Data Data comes from Metrostudy, which maintains one of the most comprehensive U.S. housing databases Restrict our study to the detached single-family housing market We identify investors and non-investors in the Charlotte housing market using the names of the seller and purchaser Define investors as non-individuals that are not banks, mortgage/credit lenders, relocation companies, building companies, nor government entities Define an institutional investor as an investor that has filed as a publicly traded company, has filed as a REIT with the SEC, or has filed a Form D with the SEC These institutional investors include companies such as Invitation Homes, American Homes 4 Rent, and Colony Starwood Homes

  8. Investor Purchases (2005)

  9. Investor Purchases (2006)

  10. Investor Purchases (2007)

  11. Investor Purchases (2008)

  12. Investor Purchases (2009)

  13. Investor Purchases (2010)

  14. Investor Purchases (2011)

  15. Investor Purchases (2012)

  16. Investor Purchases (2013)

  17. Investor Purchases (2014)

  18. Investor Purchases (2015)

  19. Investor Purchases (2016)

  20. Investor Purchases (2017)

  21. Percentage of Sold Homes Purchased by Investors Institutional Investor Non−Institutional Investor 8.00% 7.00% 6.00% 5.00% 4.00% 3.00% 2.00% 1.00% 0.00% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

  22. Homes Bought by Investors from Owner-Occupiers Institutional Investor Non−Institutional Investor 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

  23. Rental Units that are Single-Family Units 45.0% 40.0% 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

  24. Was It Just a Demand Shock? Could be that investors were just consolidating the existing single-family rental market – No Could be that preferences shifted from owning to renting Could be that investors were actually outbidding owner-occupiers

  25. Homeownership Rate 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

  26. Was It Just a Demand Shock? Could be that investors were just consolidating the existing single-family rental market – No Could be that preferences shifted from owning to renting – No Could be that investors were actually outbidding owner-occupiers

  27. Examining Institutional Investor Price Effects Use a standard hedonic model to examine the impact institutional investors had on individual home prices Ask how much more or less institutional investors were paying Turns out they were paying less than owner occupiers, so they were not directly raising home prices Also look at their overall activity in the market and ask how did it affect the price at which owner-occupiers paid

  28. Institutional Investor Price Effects Variable Baseline τ = 0 . 25 τ = 0 . 50 τ = 0 . 75 Purchased By Institutional Investor -0.114*** -0.081*** -0.098*** -0.112*** (-30.762) (-26.137) (-37.761) (-49.252) Recent Investor Activity 0.006*** 0.003*** 0.005*** 0.006*** (9.326) (4.36) (9.256) (10.905) Intercept 11.069*** 10.975*** 11.123*** 11.221*** (353) (142.7) (219.482) (285.251) R 2 0.774 0.55 0.585 0.608 N 319,423 319,423 319,423 319,423

  29. Was It Just a Demand Shock? Could be that investors were just consolidating the existing single-family rental market – No Could be that preferences shifted from owning to renting – No Could be that investors were actually outbidding owner-occupiers – No

  30. Conclusion Empirically find that institutional investors paid about 8.13%-11.19% less than owner-occupiers per transaction Results also suggest owner-occupiers paid about 0.32%-0.59% more for single-family homes than what they would have absent institutional investors However, this effect is fairly weak both statistically and economically Overall, find little evidence that the entrance of institutional investors had a significant effect on rising home prices

Recommend

Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the Single-Family Housing Market Sean

Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the Single-Family Housing Market Sean

Wall Street, Main Street, Your Street: How Investors Impact the Single-Family Housing Market Sean Brunson University of North Carolina at Charlotte November 2019 Home Price Indices 140 130 120 CaseShiller 110 Zillow 2005 2006 2007

1.07k views • 42 slides
BEST MAIN STREET IN AMERICA BEST MAIN STREET IN THE USA In 2016, Emporias Commercial Street

BEST MAIN STREET IN AMERICA BEST MAIN STREET IN THE USA In 2016, Emporias Commercial Street

Print Marketing BEST MAIN STREET IN AMERICA BEST MAIN STREET IN THE USA In 2016, Emporias Commercial Street won the USA Todays 10Best Main Street in the USA. Tiis award was given because of the extraordinary hard work local business

184 views • 6 slides
Main St To Wall St: What's Trending and How Will It Impact Hotels in 2018 Wall Street Perspective:

Main St To Wall St: What's Trending and How Will It Impact Hotels in 2018 Wall Street Perspective:

Main St To Wall St: What's Trending and How Will It Impact Hotels in 2018 Wall Street Perspective: Initial 3Q Review and 4Q17/2018 Outlook Vince Ciepiel, CFA Important disclosures may be found in the appendix What We Will Cover Cleveland

534 views • 27 slides
458 BROADWAY, 9TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY A-1 40 WORTH STREET SUITE 814 NEW YORK, NY 10013 TEL:

458 BROADWAY, 9TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY A-1 40 WORTH STREET SUITE 814 NEW YORK, NY 10013 TEL:

BROOME STREET E 8 T H S T R E E T W. HOUSTON STREET T E E 7TH AVENUE R T S N O S D BROADWAY U GRAND STREET 458 BROADWAY H BOWERY STREET WATTS STREET LAFAYETTE STREET MERCER STREET CROSBY STREET CANAL STREET BROADWAY

365 views • 13 slides
Demystifying the Mortgage Meltdown: What It Means for Main Street, Wall Street and the U.S.

Demystifying the Mortgage Meltdown: What It Means for Main Street, Wall Street and the U.S.

Demystifying the Mortgage Meltdown: What It Means for Main Street, Wall Street and the U.S. Financial System James R. Barth James R. Barth Glenn Yago Glenn Yago Senior Fellow Director of Capital Studies Milken Institute October 2, 2008 1

1k views • 84 slides
Internet science: why Wall Street and Main Street should care (a survey of caida activities) kc

Internet science: why Wall Street and Main Street should care (a survey of caida activities) kc

Internet science: why Wall Street and Main Street should care (a survey of caida activities) kc claffy CAIDA 14 Apr 2009 1 recipe for disaster (aka you are here) We now critically depend on the Internet for our professional,

269 views • 22 slides
St. Paul Street Bus Station early years St. Paul Street north of Main Street St. Paul Street

St. Paul Street Bus Station early years St. Paul Street north of Main Street St. Paul Street

Do Downto wntown Bur wn Burlington S lington Sta tation tion Transportation, Energy & Utilities Committee Of the Burlington City Council October 8, 2014 St. Paul Street Bus Station early years St. Paul Street north of Main Street

421 views • 27 slides
WEST MAIN STREET ACTION PLAN C HARLOTTESVILLE , V IRGINIA WHAT IS THE WEST MAIN STREET PROJECT?

WEST MAIN STREET ACTION PLAN C HARLOTTESVILLE , V IRGINIA WHAT IS THE WEST MAIN STREET PROJECT?

WEST MAIN STREET ACTION PLAN C HARLOTTESVILLE , V IRGINIA WHAT IS THE WEST MAIN STREET PROJECT? BUS STOPS LIGHTING BIKE AMENITIES BUMPOUTS PUBLIC ART STREET TREES SIDEWALKS LID/SWM CREATIVE PARKING CONNECTIONS TO STRATEGIES SIGNAGE

851 views • 38 slides
Design History behind Main Street Historically, Main Street was the communitys

Design History behind Main Street Historically, Main Street was the communitys

Design History behind Main Street Historically, Main Street was the communitys primary commercial hub (pre WWII). Suburbanization and marketplace changes created a movement away from traditional commerce centers.

511 views • 38 slides
proposal 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 Proposed

proposal 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 Proposed

WALL SIGNAGE proposal 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 1 Horatio Street New York, NY 10014 Proposed Wall. Current Wall. Location Wall is located on corner of 8th avenue and Horatio 1 Horatio Street street. It is facing 8th Avenue.

82 views • 7 slides
Becoming a Designated Main Street community & establishing a local program What is Main

Becoming a Designated Main Street community & establishing a local program What is Main

Becoming a Designated Main Street community & establishing a local program What is Main Street? A specific strategy for volunteer- supported downtown revitalization in the context of historic preservation Main Street is a nationally

824 views • 32 slides
Community Meeting Main Street Complete Street Design Concepts 6/22/20 Public Works Department

Community Meeting Main Street Complete Street Design Concepts 6/22/20 Public Works Department

Community Meeting Main Street Complete Street Design Concepts 6/22/20 Public Works Department Main Street Complete Street - Community Meeting - City Council Adopted Complete Street Policies and Purpose - Existing site conditions and general

108 views • 10 slides
WIS 89 Main Street Topel Street to Madison Street Construction Kick-off Meeting Craig Hardy, PE

WIS 89 Main Street Topel Street to Madison Street Construction Kick-off Meeting Craig Hardy, PE

WIS 89 Main Street Topel Street to Madison Street Construction Kick-off Meeting Craig Hardy, PE WisDOT Project Manager February 12, 2019 INTRODUCTIONS PROJECT LOCATION MAP SCOPE OF WORK DETOUR ROUTE & CONSTRUCTION

675 views • 34 slides
T001.00 Date 08/03/2017 PROJECT LOCATION Scale AS NOTED Drawn / Checked CH/RB, SP Project

T001.00 Date 08/03/2017 PROJECT LOCATION Scale AS NOTED Drawn / Checked CH/RB, SP Project

Project 60 GREENE STREET 60 GREENE STREET NEW YORK, NY 60 Greene Street Retail AREA OF WORK New York, NY 10012 60 GREENE STREET WOOSTER STREET BOROUGH: MANHATTAN GREENE STREET BLOCK: 485 Architect LOT: 7502 MERCER STREET

312 views • 8 slides
Revitalization Plan BM Ross and Associates Ltd. Bayfield Main Street PAT "Main Street is

Revitalization Plan BM Ross and Associates Ltd. Bayfield Main Street PAT "Main Street is

Bayfield Main Street Revitalization Plan BM Ross and Associates Ltd. Bayfield Main Street PAT "Main Street is the glory of Canada. If a community has no heart, it has no soul; and its heart should beat faster at the core. For here is the

654 views • 16 slides
Analysts and Investors Day June 2017 Main Street Capital Corporation NYSE: MAIN

Analysts and Investors Day June 2017 Main Street Capital Corporation NYSE: MAIN

Analysts and Investors Day June 2017 Main Street Capital Corporation NYSE: MAIN mainstcapital.com Main Street Capital Corporation NYSE: MAIN mainstcapital.com Page 1 Disclaimers Main Street Capital Corporation (MAIN) cautions that

1.49k views • 124 slides
Inspiring Great Downtowns RECOVERY & RESILIENCY ON MAIN STREET Educational Series Main

Inspiring Great Downtowns RECOVERY & RESILIENCY ON MAIN STREET Educational Series Main

Inspiring Great Downtowns RECOVERY & RESILIENCY ON MAIN STREET Educational Series Main Street Forums for the 21 st Century Session Sponsors: Corporate Investors: Founding Sponsors: Growth Partners: State Histor oric Preservation Office

543 views • 42 slides
Functional, Preliminary Design and Detailed Design Main Street (Echo Drive to the Rideau River),

Functional, Preliminary Design and Detailed Design Main Street (Echo Drive to the Rideau River),

Functional, Preliminary Design and Detailed Design Main Street (Echo Drive to the Rideau River), Lees Avenue (Main Street to Chestnut Street), and Rideau River Drive (Main Street to 130m south of Main Street) Working Group Meeting #19 June 11,

336 views • 23 slides
116 PRINCE STREET Painted Wall Sign Application 116 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012 Proposed

116 PRINCE STREET Painted Wall Sign Application 116 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012 Proposed

116 PRINCE STREET Painted Wall Sign Application 116 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012 Proposed West-Facing Painted Wall Sign 10 W x 10 H (100 SF) Archival Information about Prince Street 116 Prince Tax Photo Exterior View of 116 Prince

319 views • 16 slides
LANDMARKS PRESENTATION 03.13.2018 52 THOMAS STREET, NEW YORK, NY THOMAS STREET CHURCH STREET

LANDMARKS PRESENTATION 03.13.2018 52 THOMAS STREET, NEW YORK, NY THOMAS STREET CHURCH STREET

LANDMARKS PRESENTATION 03.13.2018 52 THOMAS STREET, NEW YORK, NY THOMAS STREET CHURCH STREET BLOCK:147 LOT: 7508 COMMUNITY BOARD: 101 52 THOMAS STREET DUANE STREET key plan year built: 1927-1928 photo location: Intersection of Thomas

340 views • 18 slides
Update Regarding Roll Out of the The Main Street Lending Program Green & Sklarz LLC One

Update Regarding Roll Out of the The Main Street Lending Program Green & Sklarz LLC One

Update Regarding Roll Out of the The Main Street Lending Program Green & Sklarz LLC One Audubon Street. Third Floor NewHaven,CT06511 (203) 285-8545 www.gs-lawfirm.com Jeffrey M. Sklarz Kellianne Baranowsky Robert Fleischer Main Street

488 views • 13 slides
Proposed Main Street / Washington Street Tax Increment Financing 7/8/16 (TIF) District Village

Proposed Main Street / Washington Street Tax Increment Financing 7/8/16 (TIF) District Village

Proposed Main Street / Washington Street Tax Increment Financing 7/8/16 (TIF) District Village of Oswego Joint Review Board Meeting Presentation July 8, 2016 1 Agenda I. Redevelopment Project and Plan II. TIF Mechanism 7/8/16 III.

306 views • 29 slides
New IP Financial Models: Innovation, Wall Street, and Patents 10:45 AM Panel The Economic Impact

New IP Financial Models: Innovation, Wall Street, and Patents 10:45 AM Panel The Economic Impact

Flocel New IP Financial Models: Innovation, Wall Street, and Patents 10:45 AM Panel The Economic Impact and Value of Patents in a Volatile Market Patent Policy: A Small Business Perspective October 8, 2015 Inc. Robert N. Schmidt, PE, JD 500

549 views • 13 slides
LOWER MAIN STREET RECONSTRUCTION N B R I D G T O N , M A I N E A U G U S T 2 8 , 2 0 1 8

LOWER MAIN STREET RECONSTRUCTION N B R I D G T O N , M A I N E A U G U S T 2 8 , 2 0 1 8

LOWER MAIN STREET RECONSTRUCTION N B R I D G T O N , M A I N E A U G U S T 2 8 , 2 0 1 8 PROJECT INFORMATION Milone & MacBroom has been tasked with the reconstruction and streetscaping design of Lower Main Street in Bridgton, Maine. The

476 views • 11 slides

More recommend