origin of magic angles in twisted bilayer graphene
play

Origin of Magic Angles in Twisted Bilayer Graphene Grisha - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Origin of Magic Angles in Twisted Bilayer Graphene Grisha Tarnopolsky Harvard University Talk at PCTS workshop Critical Phenomena in Statistical Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory Princeton University October 4, 2018 Ashvin


  1. Origin of Magic Angles in Twisted Bilayer Graphene Grisha Tarnopolsky Harvard University Talk at PCTS workshop ”Critical Phenomena in Statistical Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory’’ Princeton University October 4, 2018

  2. Ashvin Vishwanath Alex Kruchkov Harvard Harvard Talk based on: GT, A. Kruchkov, A. Vishwanath arXiv:1808.05250

  3. Plan • Graphene • Twisted Bilayer Graphene (TBG) • Continuum model for TBG and Magic angles • Origin of Magic angles

  4. <latexit sha1_base64="XwnbwzCKWk2JmA7cXuxlCghj3w=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="diJLy8Z9a40Wl0dp8ZAXsYr7NbI=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="RLhGjYiaqH0x9hgpv7DumvL6VEw=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="9lTfi6PI5K+1Pgs1h9ZBvk0Ko=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="JUjTKNb9L589fDtuI2x0Bl/tZ3M=">ACu3icdZHPShxBEMZ7xh1Y+KqRy9DNgEDcZlZBb0IgpcFbIqOMtS01Oz27Gnp+2uEZdh8O7TeNU3ydvY+eQWU1Bw8evqD6+2IthaUg+Nvwlj4sf1xZXWt+Wv/8ZaO1uXVh8Jw7PFc5uYqBotSKOyRIlX2iBkscTL+OZ0r+8Q2NFrn7TWGM/g6ESqeBADg1a36IEJcGg3K+Oo9QAL6Equ9XuXmRvDTn6cy/8MWi1g04wLf+tCOeizeZ1NthsPERJzosMFXEJ1l6HgaZ+CYEl1g1o8KiBn4DQ7x2UkGtl9Ov1P53x1J/DQ37inyp/TfjRIya8dZ7CYzoJFd7E3gu704ex/hw8N6JHg97VzS9SWcp2kdTo7vYZGzm5jcGFQG6FcSqpOCyXILthC6VG/FEoXhIrPXEkL6VPuT4L0E2GQkxw7AdwIZ6zPR+ASJBd30UWLgb0Vlx0O2HQCc8P2ifdeXirbId9ZbsZIfshP1iZ6zHOHtkT+yZvXjHvf+eHI26jXmO9usVl7xCn8c3Xg=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="+t164Qi7ugwD9ERpgdD8zKE/8w=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="fRNnE4OA+5Ts0DCtxzpqSDyk3B0=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="xvPtMp/45MCkC/OsOsMatBIwk=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="t7a0z12pa2avNaudf+gOnc1xm7Y=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="ZV4KHNqHr/IK0l9Ox3dY6xZNlY=">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</latexit> Graphene • Tight Binding Model (ignore spin) • Easy to diagonalize in Fourier space • Dirac Cones at K and K’ points P.R.Wallace, 1946

  5. <latexit sha1_base64="Js+R5ba01bsF1NvF8tgp4QNnIVg=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="cUP5Uz/WR4ge/0kSBfB3eqH10r4=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="6RzC+aQkv5P4r8xrmd3OoEHmOqU=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="lWLiVmUbeN3f6MtG5BWjg5POVQ=">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</latexit> Graphene • Graphene Brillouin Zone (BZ) • Low energy effective Hamiltonian is Dirac Hamiltonian (Dirac see is filled in graphene) • Near K point (K-valley) the wave function obeys 2D Dirac equation G.W.Semenoff, 1984

Recommend


More recommend