Lack of independence in the EUs cancer assessment of glyphosate - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Lack of independence in the EU‘s cancer assessment of glyphosate Helmut Burtscher-Schaden, GLOBAL 2000 - Friends of the Earth, Austria

„The best pesticide law in the world“ (Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009)

„The best pesticide law in the world“ (Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009) 1. Hazard-based cut-off criteria for active substances of very high concern

„The best pesticide law in the world“ (Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009) 1. Hazard-based cut-off criteria for active substances of very high concern 2. Mandatory assessment of the scientific literature

„The best pesticide law in the world“ (Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009) 1. Hazard-based cut-off criteria for active substances of very high concern 2. Mandatory assessment of the scientific literature independent, objective and transparent assessment (Article 11)

example no.1 Evaluation of long- term carcinogenicity studies with mice

Cancer Sufficient evidence limited evidence inade- quate evidence

GTF submitted it‘s dossier ... In May 2012, Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

.. and stated that... Monsanto 1983 Cheminova 1993 Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

… „glyphosate is not carcinogenic“ ... Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Cheminova → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Adama → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2001 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

… „glyphosate is not carcinogenic“ ... Malignant Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Cheminova → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Adama slightly elevated → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2001 but incidental carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

BfR agreed with GTF ... in Dec 2013 Malignant Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Cheminova → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Adama slightly elevated → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2001 but incidental carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

BfR agreed with GTF ... in Dec 2013 Malignant ✓ Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Cheminova → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Adama slightly elevated → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2001 but incidental ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

BfR agreed with GTF ... in Dec 2013 Malignant ✓ Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Cheminova → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Adama „ „.. only very limited evidence .. only very limited evidence slightly elevated of carcinogenic potential“ of carcinogenic potential“ 2001 but incidental ✓ Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

BfR agreed with GTF ... in Dec 2013 Malignant ✓ Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice “ [t]he weak increase in Cheminova malignant lymphoma [..] → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice was clearly confined to this single study and [..] Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not not reproducible in four 1997 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice other studies ..“ Adama „ „.. only very limited evidence .. only very limited evidence slightly elevated of carcinogenic potential“ of carcinogenic potential“ 2001 but incidental ✓ Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

BfR agreed with GTF ... in Dec 2013 Malignant ✓ Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice “ [t]he weak increase in Cheminova malignant lymphoma [..] → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice was clearly confined to this single study and [..] Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not not reproducible in four 1997 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice other studies ..“ Adama „ „.. only very limited evidence .. only very limited evidence slightly elevated of carcinogenic potential“ of carcinogenic potential“ 2001 but incidental ✓ Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Feb 2015 MS and EFSA agreed with BfR in Malignant ✓ Lymphoma Monsanto → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1983 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice “ [t]he weak increase in Cheminova malignant lymphoma [..] → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 1993 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice was clearly confined to this single study and [..] Arysta → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not not reproducible in four 1997 ✓ carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice other studies ..“ Adama „ „.. only very limited evidence .. only very limited evidence slightly elevated of carcinogenic potential“ of carcinogenic potential“ 2001 but incidental ✓ Nufarm → → Glyphosate is not Glyphosate is not 2009 carcinogenic in mice carcinogenic in mice Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Mar 2015 In , IARC found „sufficient evidence“ ... Malignant Kidney Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto 1983 Cheminova 1993 Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Mar 2015 In , IARC found „sufficient evidence“ ... Malignant Kidney Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto Statistically significant 1983 increase Cheminova Statistically significant 1993 increase Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Aug 2015 In , BfR agreed with IARC Malignant Kidney Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto Statistically significant 1983 increase Cheminova Statistically significant 1993 increase Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Aug 2015 In , BfR agreed with IARC Malignant Kidney ✓ ✓ Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto Statistically significant 1983 increase Cheminova Statistically significant 1993 increase Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

Aug 2015 In , BfR agreed with IARC Malignant Kidney ✓ Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto Statistically significant 1983 ✓ increase Cheminova Statistically significant 1993 increase Arysta 1997 Adama 2001 Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322)

… and confirmed 8 significant tumor findings Malignant Kidney ✓ ✓ Haemangio- Lymphoma tumors sarcoma Monsanto Statistically significant 1983 increase Cheminova Statistically significant 1993 ✓ increase Arysta Statistically significant 1997 ✓ increase Adama Statistically significant 2001 increase Nufarm 2009 Source: RAR, Dec. 2013 (Vol 1, Page 74 of 4322

Lack of independence in the EUs cancer assessment of glyphosate - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Lack of independence in the EUs cancer assessment of glyphosate Helmut Burtscher-Schaden, GLOBAL 2000 - Friends of the Earth, Austria The best pesticide law in the world (Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009) The best pesticide law in the

1. Car transfer EasyRide for wheelchair users Experience a lack of independence

1 Risk assessment Risk assessment Lack of assessment of semi-automatic methods has

Social Relationships and Mortality Social relationships, or the relative lack thereof,

Maine Cancer Foundation Cancer Transportation Needs Assessment September 2017 Patrick Madden,

SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCE INDEPENDENCE ASSESSMENT Presenta5on for State SELPA May 2016 Purpose of

Improving the Survivorship of Older Adults with Cancer Using Geriatric Assessment Deborah Bacon,

[ | ] independence Two events E and F are independent if P(EF) = P(E) P(F) equivalently:

Comprehensive,Geriatric,Assessment, Achieving)pa,ent.centered)cancer)care ) Pierre,Soubeyran,

THE ASSESSMENT OF HYDRATION IN ADVANCED CANCER USING NOVEL TECHNOLOGY: THE USE OF BIOELECTRICAL

Categorical data Modelling and Independence R.W. Oldford Eikosograms - Dependence/independence

A Repair for Non-Cancer Assessment: Introducing the Truly Adverse Dose (the TAD) Lawrence

Assessment: Importance of Using the Best Science Joyce S. Tsuji, Ph.D., DABT, Fellow ATS

QA Quality Assurance review the QA Cycle Every year Firms complete QA self-assessment

Usi Using New New Re Resources to to Determ Determine ine and and De Defend nd Lack Lack of of

Lecture 3 Conditional Independence CS 886 Sept 21, 2010 Testing Independence Given BN, how

Resources for Preclinical Resources for Preclinical Assessment of Nanomaterial Assessment of

Regional versus Centralised HTA: Implications for the assessment of cancer drugs Belen Corbacho,

TSWF Breast Cancer Ris isk Assessment September Sep-Dec 2019 Form Version These slides were not

Radiological assessment of neoadjuvent chemotherapy for breast cancer V. Belagi Clinic of

Nationwide evaluation of breast cancer biomarker assessment in daily practice Carmen van

Judicial Independence Judicial Independence is not a privilege or prerogative of judicial office.

Diabetes Manager www.eclipsesolutions.org.uk Julian Brown Currently the NHS is Struggling with:

Order Independence Krzysztof R. Apt CWI and University of Amsterdam Order Independence p.

Revolution grievances against British policies and actions in the Declaration of Independence .