Hillsborough County Vision Zero Coalition Red Light Running - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

A presentation to the Hillsborough County Vision Zero Coalition Red Light Running Violation Considerations February 28, 2019 Tampa, FL Angelo Rao, PE Resident, Seminole Heights, Tampa, FL

Red Light Running Camera Legislation: Legislative Concerns??: ➢ Private operators earning revenue on a per use basis? ➢ Data is not clear on the safety benefits of cameras? ➢ Citation inequities? ❖ 0.1 second Red Light Run = $158.00 citation ❖ 2.1 second (end of ALL RED phase) Red Light Run = $158.00 citation ❖ 5.1 second (well beyond ALL RED phase) Red Light Run = $158.00 citation

Red Light Running Camera Legislation: Keep the Legislation Make the Operation Fairer! 5- Point Plan 1. Citations: Private sector should NOT participate in any citation management, operation, or adjudication steps proceedings. 2. Hardware/software: The Private sector should ONLY be responsible for the sale/maintenance of Red Light Running Camera equipment 3. Operations: ONLY local government law enforcement agencies should be authorized to administer ANY citations

VIO_DTIME DOCUMENT_NUMBER RED_TIME1 Red Light Running 1/21/19 9:02 AM 1241900019356 0.1 1/21/19 10:07 AM 1241900019364 0.1 1/21/19 5:47 PM 1241900020255 0.1 1/22/19 4:03 PM 1241900020768 0.1 “Red Time” – 1/22/19 4:24 PM 1241900020776 0.1 1/23/19 3:52 PM 1241900021279 0.1 1/23/19 10:02 PM 1241900021469 0.1 1/23/19 11:46 PM 1241900021485 0.1 Small Sample 1/24/19 1:00 PM 1241900021683 0.1 1/24/19 3:16 PM 1241900021774 0.1 1/24/19 4:24 PM 1241900021865 0.1 1.1 7.1% 1/21/19 11:27 AM 1241900019406 0.2 1/21/19 2:27 PM 1241900019653 0.2 1/21/19 5:37 PM 1241900020230 0.2 1/21/19 7:51 PM 1241900020305 0.2 1/22/19 12:15 AM 1241900020370 0.2 1/22/19 9:49 AM 1241900020487 0.2 1/22/19 1:33 PM 1241900020651 0.2 1/22/19 3:22 PM 1241900020743 0.2 1/22/19 5:34 PM 1241900022137 0.2 1/24/19 8:39 AM 1241900021568 0.2 2.0 13.0% 1/21/19 11:45 AM 1241900019414 0.3 1/21/19 3:05 PM 1241900019661 0.3 1/21/19 4:22 PM 1241900019687 0.3 1/22/19 4:42 PM 1241900020784 0.3 1/22/19 5:21 PM 1241900020826 0.3 1/23/19 7:39 AM 1241900020974 0.3 1/24/19 7:16 AM 1241900021501 0.3 1/24/19 1:05 PM 1241900021691 0.3 1/24/19 3:31 PM 1241900021816 0.3 1/24/19 3:31 PM 1241900021824 0.3 3.0 19.5% 1/21/19 12:50 PM 1241900019596 0.4 1/22/19 11:59 AM 1241900020602 0.4 1/23/19 4:51 PM 1241900021311 0.4 1/23/19 5:34 PM 1241900021360 0.4 1/24/19 6:59 AM 1241900021493 0.4 1/24/19 11:30 AM 1241900021592 0.4 2.4 15.6% 1/21/19 4:27 PM 1241900019695 0.5 1/22/19 9:57 AM 1241900020495 0.5 1/23/19 8:19 AM 1241900021014 0.5 1.5 9.7% 64.9% 1/24/19 4:47 PM 1241900021915 0.6 0.6 3.9% 1/22/19 4:19 AM 1241900020404 0.7 1/23/19 9:23 AM 1241900021055 0.7 1.4 9.1% 1/23/19 5:46 PM 1241900021378 0.8 1/24/19 4:15 PM 1241900021857 0.8 1.6 10.4% 1/23/19 9:30 AM 1241900022152 0.9 1/23/19 3:17 PM 1241900021246 0.9 1.8 11.7% 35.1% 15.4 100.0% 100.0%

Red Light Running Early Data 4.4 sec. into red 2.0 sec. past all red

Red Light Running Camera Legislation: Keep the Legislation Make the Operation Fairer! 5- Point Plan, Con't 4. Graduated citation rule???: • EXAMPLE: The current Florida (FS 318.18 Amount of penalties) graduated “Speed Limit” profile . For moving violations involving unlawful speed, the fines are as follows, for speed exceeding the limit by: • 1- 5 mph……….Warning • 6- 9 mph……….$25 • 10- 14 mph……….$100 • 15- 19 mph……….$150 • 20- 29 mph……….$175 • 30 m.p.h. and above……….$250

Red Light Running Camera Legislation: Keep the Legislation Make the Operation Fairer! 5- Point Plan, Con't 4. Graduated citation rule (currently $158.00 for all RLR camera violations): • Graduated Red Light Running Camera citation fines based on empirical data would be administered by Local Law Enforcement: • Graduated RLRC citation rates Suggestions only : (Within ALL RED phase) • 0.1-0.5 seconds of RLR: First offence warning letter only; • 0.1-0.5 seconds of RLR: Second and subsequent offences $50.00; • 0.6-1.0 seconds of RLR: $ 75.00; • 1.1-2.0 seconds of RLR: $100.00 (Beyond ALL RED phase) • 2.1- 3.0 seconds of RLR: $200.00 • 3.1- 4.0 seconds of RLR: $500.00 • Over 4.0 seconds of RLR:$900.00

5.0 Intersection Collision Avoidance System Program (iCASP) • Program to avoid Red Light Running (RLR) Crashes • Predict RLR vehicle • Extend “ All-Red ” phase • Partnership study

Red Light Running Camera Legislation: Keep the Legislation Make the Operation Fairer! 5- Point Plan, Con't 5. Intersection Collision Avoidance System Approach : • Example of Intersection Collision Avoidance Safety Program (iCASP) in Lakeland, FL, or similar crash preventative system • Extend the “All - Red” phase upon prediction of a red -light runner. • Currently implemented at RLR camera sites only; • Combination setting serves to prevent any “learning curve” of motorists taking advantage of the red light extension system.

Can iCASP end these Pedestrian safety concern events???

Can iCASP end these Motor Vehicle safety concern events???

Recommendations: ➢ Implement this five-point red light running camera safety plan, through enabling legislation: ▪ Universally for all of Florida’s local jurisdictions; or ▪ By a pilot study for requesting local jurisdictions.