City Presentation (0 to 70 points) Judges Name: RUBRIC & - PDF document

discussed.฀Little฀ ing฀facts.฀Little฀ •฀ Supporting฀info •฀ Explains฀how฀the฀theme •฀ Logical฀fmow,฀Transitions •฀ Discusses฀essay฀topic •฀ Major฀elements:฀intro, •฀ Concise,฀relevant •฀ Geography,฀demographics฀or •฀ City฀features,฀benefjts, elements.฀Little฀ •฀ Unique฀infrastructure฀and City Presentation (0 to 70 points) Judge’s Name: RUBRIC & SCORESHEET Future City Name: Students give a 7-minute presentation discussing features Organization/School: of their future city followed by a 5 – 8 minute question and answer period from the judges (overall time will not exceed 15 minutes). The Judging Coordinator will review the format and exact times with you. Mandatory Questions You will be provided a set of mandatory questions to ask during the competition. You are free to add additional questions AFTER all of the mandatory questions have been answered. 0 No Points 1 Poor 2 Fair 3 Good 4 Very Good 5 Excellent SCORE I. CONTENT & DELIVERY (35 POINTS) 1. Presentation content, Poorly or- Poorly organized Fair organiza- Fulfills all Well organized, Extremely organized ganized and and missing tion. Contains requirements creative, well orga- no major some major most major (major elements, and contains nized and body, and conclusion. elements elements. transitions, all major creative. addressed. relevant informa- Some relevant, supporting info elements. Sup- Excellent between elements tion. supporting that could be porting info is variety of information. more relevant, relevant, con- effective (definitions, examples, Some transi- concise). Could cise, but could supporting statistics, quotes, etc.) tions. develop ideas be better. information more thoroughly. providing credibil- ity. Concise, relevant. 2. Overall city design & No Very brief or Fair descrip- Good overall Very good Excellent features description incomplete tion of the city. description of the description description of city. description of the Some distinc- city. Many dis- of city. Many of city. Highly and aesthetics city. Few benefits tive benefits tinctive benefits benefits and innovative or innovations and innova- and innovations innovations technol- distinctive characteristics tions explained. explained. Some- explained. ogy applied explanation or Somewhat what futuristic Futuristic and throughout. services (e.g., transportation, not believable. futuristic and and believable. believable. Explained in energy, waste or pollution believable. detail. Fu- control) turistic and believable. 3. Essay topic: The Age-Friendly Essay theme Refers to essay Briefly dis- Discusses the Discusses the Discusses essay topic the essay City not ad- briefly; little or cusses essay essay topic and dressed. no discussion of topic and solution; some and solution. topic and supporting Good support- solution with other program solution. No influenced the city components. real support- facts. Solution is ing facts. Solu- excellent adequate, some- tion innovative support- design or development explanation what innovative. or futuristic. ing facts. Somewhat Fully explains Excellent of how their city design explains how how their explanation their city design city design of how their incorporates the theme. incorporates the incorporates city design theme. the theme. incorporates the theme. CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE 21 C I T Y P R E S E N TAT I O N R U B R I C & S C O R E S H E E T

and฀Q&A. •฀ Team฀members฀ Q&A. team฀on฀both฀Q฀&฀ •฀ Answers฀questions฀with •฀ All฀aids฀enhance,฀rather฀than •฀ Accurate,฀complete •฀ Delivery฀with฀all฀visual฀aids฀is •฀ Full฀complement฀of฀team฀ Unable฀to฀ •฀ Team฀members฀displayed฀an฀ •฀ Innovations฀in฀technology฀and •฀ Team฀members฀shared฀ •฀ Model฀is฀the฀key •฀ Discusses฀solutions฀to •฀ Overall฀confjdent,฀direct,฀and •฀ Additional฀visual฀aids,฀if฀used •฀ Upright฀posture฀with •฀ Correct฀grammar฀and •฀ Fluent,฀clear,฀audible฀delivery CITY PRESENTATION 0 No Points 1 Poor 2 Fair 3 Good 4 Very Good 5 Excellent SCORE RUBRIC AND SCORESHEET I. CONTENT & DELIVERY (35 POINTS) (CONTINUED) 4. Presentation skills Poor skills A few verbal Fair to good Good verbal and Very good verbal Excellent verbal throughout. and nonverbal skills for the nonverbal skills and nonverbal and nonverbal skills are fairly majority of the for most present- skills by most of skills by the appropriate language use well done but presenters. ers; somewhat team through- entire team needs more confident and out most of the throughout the practiced use of visual aids practice to direct. presentation. presentation. improve in animated delivery most areas. 5. Use of model and other Model not Model is not Model is par- Good use of Model used Extremely cre- demonstration aids referenced. used effec- tially effective at the model as effectively to ative, integrated No other tively. Other enhancing the an illustration illustrate city use of model; element of entire delivery visual aids. demonstration presentation. of city design design, function contributed to aids poor or Other visual aids and function. and innovations. the understand- (posters, props, costumes, non-existent. fair-good. Other visual aids Other visual aids ing of city handouts) are neat, well- effective and very good and design, function prepared generally add to enhanced the and innovations. presentation. presentation. Other visual distract, from presentation aids excellent. well practiced and confident Good collabora- Very good Students fully, 6. Teamwork during No evidence A small Some collabora- presentation and Q&A of team- amount of tion, some sup- tion; support and collaboration, accurately, sharing among support and shar- and confidently work. collaboration port and sharing supported each other among team among some most members. ing among the answer all Full complement questions with members but team members. time equally more support Amount of of three team A and presenta- many support- knowledge ap- members. Some tion. Equivalent ing details. of one another equal amount of knowledge is needed; one pears unequal. team members knowledge level One or two tend have more for most of team. or two tend members (three to dominate to dominate knowledge and Full complement during either dominate. of three team students) during both presentation presentation or members. 7. Questions and answers Answers a Students answer Students answer Answers 95% Students fully, answer few questions at least 50% of 85% of questions of the questions accurately, and confidence questions accurately. the questions with accuracy accurately with confidently coherently. No supporting accurately, few and some sup- supporting detail. answer all answers facts. supporting facts. porting facts. questions with many support- ing details. II. ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY (20 POINTS) 8. Technologies used in city No Little฀discus - Some discussion Good discussion Very good discus- Excellent discussion. sion of of technologies, of technological sion of techno- discussion of futuristic concepts technologies little innovation. solutions to prob- logical solutions technological in city, little lems. Somewhat to problems. solutions to problems: transportation, innovation. innovative. Innovative. problems. utilities, services, etc. Highly innova- tive, plausible. 22 2 0 1 7 – 2 0 1 8 F U T U R E C I T Y J U D G E S M A N U A L