will my patch make it and how fast
play

Will My Patch Make It? And How Fast? Yujuan Jiang, Bram Adams - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 08, 2022 •478 likes •1.05k views

Will My Patch Make It? And How Fast? Yujuan Jiang, Bram Adams (MCIS, Polytechnique Montral) Daniel M. German (University of Victoria ) 1 Monday, 3 June, 13 I do hold out hope that Google does come around and works to fix their codebase to

  1. Will My Patch Make It? And How Fast? Yujuan Jiang, Bram Adams (MCIS, Polytechnique Montréal) Daniel M. German (University of Victoria ) 1 Monday, 3 June, 13

  2. I do hold out hope that Google does come around and works to fix their codebase to get it merged upstream to stop the huge blockage that they have now caused in a large number of embedded Linux hardware companies […] But I need the help of the Google developers to make it happen, without them, nothing can change. Greg Kroah-Hartman http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/android-kernel-problems.html 2 Monday, 3 June, 13

  3. Integration Process 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  4. Integration Process Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  5. Integration Process Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  6. Integration Process contributor 1 contributor 2 contributor 3 Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  7. Integration Process contributor 1 contributor 2 contributor 3 Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  8. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb contributor 2 lkml contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  9. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb contributor 2 lkml contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  10. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb contributor 2 lkml contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  11. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb contributor 2 lkml contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  12. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  13. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  14. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  15. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  16. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml maintainer subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  17. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml maintainer subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  18. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml Linus Torvalds maintainer subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  19. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml Linus Torvalds maintainer subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  20. Integration Process contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml Linus Torvalds maintainer linux 3.5 subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 3 Monday, 3 June, 13

  21. Research Questions RQ 3: RQ1: RQ2: What kind of How many What kind of patch is patches are patch is merged accepted faster? merged? more likely? 4 Monday, 3 June, 13

  22. Setup Of Case Study contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml Linus Torvalds maintainer linux 3.5 subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  23. Setup Of Case Study contributor 1 linux-usb subsystem maintainer1 contributor 2 lkml Linus Torvalds maintainer linux 3.5 subsystem maintainer1 contributor 3 linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  24. Setup Of Case Study linux-usb lkml Linus Torvalds linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  25. Setup Of Case Study linux-usb lkml Linus Torvalds linux-scsi Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  26. Setup Of Case Study Linus Torvalds Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  27. email1 email3 email2 email patch2 email patch1 email patch3 Setup Of Case Study Linus Torvalds ... Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  28. email3 email1 email2 email patch2 email patch1 email patch3 Setup Of Case Study ... Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  29. email patch3 commit3 commit patch3 commit patch2 commit patch1 email1 email3 email2 email patch2 email patch1 commit1 commit2 Setup Of Case Study ... ... Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  30. commit3 commit patch1 checksum2 checksum3 checksum1 email1 email3 email2 email patch2 email patch1 email patch3 commit patch3 commit patch2 commit2 commit1 Setup Of Case Study ... ... ... Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  31. commit3 commit patch1 checksum2 checksum3 checksum1 email1 email3 email2 email patch2 email patch1 email patch3 commit patch3 commit patch2 commit2 commit1 Setup Of Case Study ... ... ... Reviewing Integration Staging 5 Monday, 3 June, 13

  32. Experience 5 Dimensions of Commit Email 29 Patch Metrics Review Patch Experi 6 ence Monday, 3 June, 13

  33. Building Decision Trees size: LOC > 50 Is this first patch in thread? Number of reviewers > 3 ? not accepted Number of review messages > 3 ? not accepted accepted Decision Tree 7 Monday, 3 June, 13

  34. RQ 3: RQ1: RQ2: What kind of How many What kind of patch is patches are patch is merged accepted faster? merged? more likely? 8 Monday, 3 June, 13

  35. RQ 3: RQ1: RQ2: What kind of How many What kind of patch is patches are patch is merged accepted faster? merged? more likely? 9 Monday, 3 June, 13

  36. RQ1: 33% of patches make it! 69.26% 69.26 R 120000 E % accepted by linus 66.45% 66.45 % rejected by linus J E 100000 66.13% 66.13 67.21% 67.21 C s 67.17% percentage of patches 67.17 e T h 80000 c t 72.97% a 72.97 p 60000 f o A # C 40000 30.74% 30.74 33.55% 33.55 71.3% C 71.3 33.87% 33.87 32.79% 32.79 32.83% 32.83 E 20000 P 27.03% 27.03 71.73% 71.37 28.7% T 28.7 28.63% 28.63 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 10 Monday, 3 June, 13

  37. RQ1: Requiring 1~6months! 80 instantly within_week within_half_year within_hour within_month within_year within_day within_quarter took_ages percentage of accepted patches of each year 60 % T accepted e 40 x t patches 20 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 11 Monday, 3 June, 13

  38. RQ1: reviewing time speeds up & integration slows down integration time reviewing time 12 Monday, 3 June, 13

  39. RQ1: RQ 3: RQ2: How many What kind of What kind of patches are patch is patch is merged merged? accepted faster? more likely? 13 Monday, 3 June, 13

  40. RQ2: What kind of patch is merged more likely? precision:73% recall:68.47% 14 Monday, 3 June, 13

  41. RQ2: What kind of patch is merged more likely? precision:73% recall:68.47% 14 Monday, 3 June, 13

  42. RQ2: What kind of patch is merged more likely? precision:73% recall:68.47% 14 Monday, 3 June, 13

  43. RQ2: What kind of patch is merged more likely? precision:73% recall:68.47% 14 Monday, 3 June, 13

  44. RQ2: What kind of patch is merged more likely? precision:73% recall:68.47% 14 Monday, 3 June, 13

  45. RQ 3: RQ2: RQ1: What kind of What kind of How many patch is patch is merged patches are accepted faster? more likely? merged? 15 Monday, 3 June, 13

  46. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  47. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  48. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  49. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  50. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  51. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  52. RQ3: What kind of patch is accepted faster? Acceptance is determined by integration phase 16 Monday, 3 June, 13

  53. 17 Monday, 3 June, 13

  54. 17 Monday, 3 June, 13

  55. 120000 % accepted by linus 66.45% 66.45 % rejected by linus 100000 66.13% 66.13 67.21% 67.21 percentage of patches 67.17% 67.17 80000 72.97% 72.97 60000 40000 30.74 30.74% 33.55% 33.55 71.3% 71.3 33.87 33.87% 32.79% 32.79 32.83 32.83% 20000 27.03% 27.03 71.73% 71.37 28.7% 28.7 28.63% 28.63 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 17 Monday, 3 June, 13

Recommend

A Fast Spatial Patch Blending Algorithm for Artefact Reduction in Pattern-based Image Inpainting

A Fast Spatial Patch Blending Algorithm for Artefact Reduction in Pattern-based Image Inpainting

A Fast Spatial Patch Blending Algorithm for Artefact Reduction in Pattern-based Image Inpainting Maxime Daisy, David Tschumperl e, Olivier L ezoray GREYC - UMR 6072 CNRS, ENSICAEN, University of Caen Image team SIGGRAPH Asia 21

542 views • 42 slides
An Analysis of Patch Plausibility and Correctness of

An Analysis of Patch Plausibility and Correctness of

An Analysis of Patch Plausibility and Correctness of Generate-And- Validate Patch Genera8on System Zichao Qi , Fan Long, Sara Achour, and Mar8n Rinard MIT

323 views • 29 slides
La Larg rge-Scal Scale Patch Patch Reco comme mmendati ation at at Alibab aba Xindong

La Larg rge-Scal Scale Patch Patch Reco comme mmendati ation at at Alibab aba Xindong

La Larg rge-Scal Scale Patch Patch Reco comme mmendati ation at at Alibab aba Xindong Zhang 1 , Chenguang Zhu 2 , Yi Li 3 , Jianmei Guo 1 , Lihua Liu 1 , and Haobo Gu 1 1. Alibaba Group 2. University of Texas at Austin 3. Nanyang

462 views • 7 slides
Utter Command Fast, hands-free computer control by speech Redstart Report Method Fast,

Utter Command Fast, hands-free computer control by speech Redstart Report Method Fast,

Utter Command Fast, hands-free computer control by speech Redstart Report Method Fast, efficient, consistent reports by speech Kimberly Patch kim@redstartsystems.com www.redstartsystems.com Disabled Users as Speech Testbed Many people in

389 views • 6 slides
Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion and and

Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion and and

5/21/2015 Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion Non-Inferiority Assessment of Patch Adhesion and and Dermatology Irritation of Post-Market Dermatology Irritation Evaluation Change and Generic Drug Evaluation Presented by Mark Liu,

529 views • 22 slides
How to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS Steps to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS 1. Login to

How to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS Steps to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS 1. Login to

How to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS Steps to install Patch Manager Plus at AWS 1. Login to Aws console 2. Select launch instance 3. Select your OS 4. Choose instance type 5. Select VPC 6. Add storage 7. Tag your instance 8. Configure security

185 views • 14 slides
Know Your Engines How to Make Your JavaScript Fast Dave Mandelin 8 November 2011 OReilly

Know Your Engines How to Make Your JavaScript Fast Dave Mandelin 8 November 2011 OReilly

Know Your Engines How to Make Your JavaScript Fast Dave Mandelin 8 November 2011 OReilly Velocity Europe Tuesday, November 8, 2011 JavaScript is getting really fast and programs are getting crazy Bullet physics engine (ammo.js) H.264

2.15k views • 184 slides
Garbage Patch What is it and why is it occuring? -600,000 Square Miles (twice the size of Texas)

Garbage Patch What is it and why is it occuring? -600,000 Square Miles (twice the size of Texas)

Great Pacific Garbage Patch What is it and why is it occuring? -600,000 Square Miles (twice the size of Texas) -1.8 Trillion pieces of microplastic (not biodegradable) -88,000 Tons -Comprised of the Western Garbage Patch (near Japan) and

388 views • 6 slides
SPDY, err... HTTP 2.0 WebRTC what is it, how, why, and when? Make the Web Fast, Google Improve

SPDY, err... HTTP 2.0 WebRTC what is it, how, why, and when? Make the Web Fast, Google Improve

SPDY, err... HTTP 2.0 WebRTC what is it, how, why, and when? Make the Web Fast, Google Improve end-user perceived latency Address the "head of line blocking" Not require multiple connections Retain the semantics of

1.16k views • 47 slides
Collaborative Project Call ID FP7-SST-2008-RTD-1 Proposal N 233969 Acronym:

Collaborative Project Call ID FP7-SST-2008-RTD-1 Proposal N 233969 Acronym:

COMPOSITE MPOSITE PATCH PATCH REPAIR REPAIR CO OF METALLIC MARINE STRUCTURES OF METALLIC MARINE STRUCTURES Collaborative Project Call ID FP7-SST-2008-RTD-1 Proposal N 233969 Acronym: "Co-Patch www.co-patch.com Duration: 36

663 views • 21 slides
DIY Patch Management F L O R I A N J U N G E ( @ S H A N T YC O D E ) I N G O B E N T E ( @

DIY Patch Management F L O R I A N J U N G E ( @ S H A N T YC O D E ) I N G O B E N T E ( @

DIY Patch Management F L O R I A N J U N G E ( @ S H A N T YC O D E ) I N G O B E N T E ( @ I N G O B E N T E ) B S I D E S M U N I C H 2 0 1 8 Patching Isnt that solved? Nope, its not. R E M E M B E R T H O S E R A N S O M

635 views • 48 slides
Welcome to Part 3: Memory Systems and I/O Weve already seen how to make a fast processor.

Welcome to Part 3: Memory Systems and I/O Weve already seen how to make a fast processor.

Welcome to Part 3: Memory Systems and I/O Weve already seen how to make a fast processor. How can we supply the CPU with enough data to keep it busy? We will now focus on memory issues, which are frequently bottlenecks that limit the

513 views • 27 slides
Life in the Fast Lane: the confluence lens George Varghese, Microsoft Research I drive fast

Life in the Fast Lane: the confluence lens George Varghese, Microsoft Research I drive fast

Life in the Fast Lane: the confluence lens George Varghese, Microsoft Research I drive fast only when . . Only drug I use is . . . But I do like to make things run fast Algorithmics to speed abstractions Example 1: Virtual

667 views • 50 slides
How Julia Goes Fast Leah Hanson Main Points 1. Design choices make Julia fast. 2. Design and

How Julia Goes Fast Leah Hanson Main Points 1. Design choices make Julia fast. 2. Design and

How Julia Goes Fast Leah Hanson Main Points 1. Design choices make Julia fast. 2. Design and implementation choices work together. 3. You should try using Julia. 1. What problem is Julia solving? 2. What design choices does that lead to? 3.

972 views • 74 slides
Building Faster Websites WebRTC crash course on web performance Ilya Grigorik - @igrigorik Make

Building Faster Websites WebRTC crash course on web performance Ilya Grigorik - @igrigorik Make

Building Faster Websites WebRTC crash course on web performance Ilya Grigorik - @igrigorik Make The Web Fast Google Make the Web Fast team at Google: Kernel, Networking, Infrastructure, Chrome, Mobile... Research & drive performance

2.1k views • 130 slides
Mobile Reporting that Works Inspections, Incidents & Safety Observations to Make Us Better

Mobile Reporting that Works Inspections, Incidents & Safety Observations to Make Us Better

Mobile Reporting that Works Inspections, Incidents & Safety Observations to Make Us Better Presentation Prepared for Scott Brothers Sospes, VP Channels Started career in the oil patch Helped build small software companies

361 views • 9 slides
PATCH PLANER EX Series UNIVERSAL CUTTER ES Series by Chris Goebel 11/2012 PATCH PLANER EX

PATCH PLANER EX Series UNIVERSAL CUTTER ES Series by Chris Goebel 11/2012 PATCH PLANER EX

PATCH PLANER EX Series UNIVERSAL CUTTER ES Series by Chris Goebel 11/2012 PATCH PLANER EX Series UNIVERSAL CUTTER ES Series by Chris Goebel 03/2013 EX Patch Planer for Excavators EX Patch Planer for Excavators EX Patch Planer for

1.27k views • 80 slides
Versions all the way down Versioning commits and patches with git-series Josh Triplett

Versions all the way down Versioning commits and patches with git-series Josh Triplett

Versions all the way down Versioning commits and patches with git-series Josh Triplett josh@joshtriplett.org LinuxCon North America 2016 RFC: feature RFC: feature Development git commit git format-patch -3 git format-patch -3 [PATCH 1/3]

1.19k views • 105 slides
Marathon Mandarin Enters FAST TRACK 1 Revised FAST TRACK Model There are no longer any Tiers

Marathon Mandarin Enters FAST TRACK 1 Revised FAST TRACK Model There are no longer any Tiers

Marathon Mandarin Enters FAST TRACK 1 Revised FAST TRACK Model There are no longer any Tiers There is no longer any head start Registration Fee is now $150.00 Offset patent costs Growers make their own determination how much

171 views • 6 slides
Community Update MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts

Community Update MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts

Monter nterey-Sali Salinas nas Transit ansit Community Update MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast st Facts cts MST T Fast ast Facts acts 231,706 miles between preventable accidents 89% on time

198 views • 19 slides
0-Day Patch Exposing vendors (in)security performance BlackHat Europe 2008 Amsterdam Stefan

0-Day Patch Exposing vendors (in)security performance BlackHat Europe 2008 Amsterdam Stefan

BLACKHAT Europe 2008 0-Day Patch 0-Day Patch Exposing vendors (in)security performance BlackHat Europe 2008 Amsterdam Stefan Frei + Bernhard Tellenbach Communication Systems Group ETH Zurich Switzerland http://www.csg.ethz.ch

414 views • 17 slides
A Plan 9 Approach to Hierarchical Patch Dynamics John (EBo) David IWP9 2010 Seattle, WA Many

A Plan 9 Approach to Hierarchical Patch Dynamics John (EBo) David IWP9 2010 Seattle, WA Many

A Plan 9 Approach to Hierarchical Patch Dynamics John (EBo) David IWP9 2010 Seattle, WA Many Problems are Inherently Multiscale Wu & David (2001) Hierarchical Patch Dynamics (HPD) ( Wu and Loucks 1995) HPD explicitly integrates

188 views • 15 slides
Bruin Patch & Big Wave C ate ring Recipe for Success: Community Partnerships Recipe for

Bruin Patch & Big Wave C ate ring Recipe for Success: Community Partnerships Recipe for

Brookings-Harbor School District 17C School-based Businesses Bruin Patch & Big Wave C ate ring Recipe for Success: Community Partnerships Recipe for success OSU Extension Office Local School District 4H Youth Bruin Patch &

612 views • 12 slides
Trees Make Money Fast! Stock Ponzi Bank Robbery Fraud Scheme 02/06/2006 Trees 1 Outline

Trees Make Money Fast! Stock Ponzi Bank Robbery Fraud Scheme 02/06/2006 Trees 1 Outline

Trees Make Money Fast! Stock Ponzi Bank Robbery Fraud Scheme 02/06/2006 Trees 1 Outline and Reading Tree ADT (7.1.2) Preorder and postorder traversals (7.2.2-3) BinaryTree ADT (7.3.1) Inorder traversal (7.3.6) Euler Tour

347 views • 22 slides

More recommend