UNDERSTANDING DEJA REVIEWERS Eric Gilbert & Karrie Karahalios - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 27, 2022 •318 likes •487 views

UNDERSTANDING DEJA REVIEWERS Eric Gilbert & Karrie Karahalios University of Illinois WHATS IN IT FOR DEJA REVIEWERS? THE REVIEWS overview 98,191 Amazon.com reviews from 200 bestselling products belonging to 15 product categories

UNDERSTANDING DEJA REVIEWERS Eric Gilbert & Karrie Karahalios University of Illinois
WHAT’S IN IT FOR DEJA REVIEWERS?
THE REVIEWS overview 98,191 Amazon.com reviews from 200 bestselling products belonging to 15 product categories
COMPUTATIONAL METHOD n-gram & sentiment centrality “Our family loves the Wii Fit, but my son loves it most.” deja score = similarity to centroid & similarity to running sentiment centroid = statistically representative n-grams normalized to Google 1T corpus
THE INTERVIEWS overview 20 interviews from 200 invitations extended conducted via email, phone & IM
THE PROBLEM OF SCALE a common refrain If there's 5, 10, I'll read those. If there's 50 or 60, I'll skim some titles. If a title looks like it has some wit or humor, I might read that one. That’s about it. — P13
AMATEUR DEJA REVIEWERS catharsis I was so moved by this documentary, and as a wolf advocate, I wanted a few others to know about it … I don't care if I write the fi rst review or the 5,000 th . It's cathartic for me. — P3
AMATEUR DEJA REVIEWERS why be unique? I'm sure that other reviewers noted the same features that appealed to me and my kids. A completely unique review wouldn't serve any real purpose, would it? — P5
PRO DEJA REVIEWERS hate mail One said we were trying to “sti fl e dissent.” Another warned us that she does not write “just to see my own words on the internet.”
PRO DEJA REVIEWERS above the din [Do you read other reviews?] Absolutely not … I do not condone plagiarism and would never base my opinion on another reviewer’s thoughts. I believe this alone has led me to be rated highly. — P7
PRO DEJA REVIEWERS building a brand I am trying to build a name for myself … If every other person on earth has said something similar that is fi ne, it in no way diminishes the value of my personal opinion. — P19
RESULTS summary universal problem of scale amateurs: ok as a brick in the wall; visceral reactions pros: special bricks in the wall; cerebral reviews
NUDGEMENTAL COMMUNITIES early sketch
UNDERSTANDING DEJA REVIEWERS Eric Gilbert & Karrie Karahalios University of Illinois

Recommend

RTP Reviewers Workshop By Mary Pons, FAR Administrative Analyst Agenda Understanding the Role

RTP Reviewers Workshop By Mary Pons, FAR Administrative Analyst Agenda Understanding the Role of being a Reviewer in the RTP process Reviewers and their Departmental Standards Levels of Reviewers within the RTP cycle The Faculty

792 views • 20 slides

CS 134: Operating Systems Disk Deja-vu 1 / 29 Overview CS34 Overview 2013-05-17 Working

CS34 2013-05-17 CS 134: Operating Systems Disk Deja-vu CS 134: Operating Systems Disk Deja-vu 1 / 29 Overview CS34 Overview 2013-05-17 Working Sets Allocation Policies Thrashing Overview Secondary Storage Allocation Methods

391 views • 36 slides

DEJA-VU : DOUBLE FEATURE PRESENTATION AND ITERATED LOSS IN DEEP TRANSFORMER NETWORKS Andros

DEJA-VU : DOUBLE FEATURE PRESENTATION AND ITERATED LOSS IN DEEP TRANSFORMER NETWORKS Andros Tjandra 1* , Chunxi Liu 2 , Frank Zhang 2 , Xiaohui Zhang 2 , Yongqiang Wang 2 , Gabriel Synnaeve 2 , Satoshi Nakamura 1 , Goeffrey Zweig 2 1) NAIST,

414 views • 17 slides

DEJA-VU: DOUBLE FEATURE PRESENTATION IN DEEP TRANSFORMER NETWORKS Andros Tjandra 1 , Chunxi Liu

DEJA-VU: DOUBLE FEATURE PRESENTATION IN DEEP TRANSFORMER NETWORKS Andros Tjandra 1 , Chunxi Liu 2 , Frank Zhang 2 , Xiaohui Zhang 2 , Yongqiang Wang 2 , Gabriel Synnaeve 2 , Satoshi Nakamura 1 , Geoffrey Zweig 2 1 Nara Institute of Science and

443 views • 5 slides

Re Reviewers Pe Perspective: PMA Analysis Must Haves Enough

Re Reviewers Pe Perspective: PMA Analysis Must Haves Enough evidence to convince reader Particulars specific to subject site Clear maps and boundaries,

260 views • 11 slides

CVPR is a contemporary art exhibition -- Garbage is a source for impact -- 3D Scene Understanding

CVPR is a contemporary art exhibition -- Garbage is a source for impact -- 3D Scene Understanding for Vision, Graphics, and Robotics Workshop @ CVPR2020 Yasutaka Furukawa We are scared of reviewers HARSH REVIEWER CVPR is a contemporary art

733 views • 48 slides

Scoring Criteria: What (NIH) Grant Reviewers Look For in a Proposal Jason Shepherd , Ph.D.

Scoring Criteria: What (NIH) Grant Reviewers Look For in a Proposal Jason Shepherd , Ph.D. Department of Neurobiology and Anatomy Jason.Shepherd@neuro.Utah.edu July 17th, 2019 NIH Funding Decisions The NIH utilizes 2 stages of review when

1.65k views • 27 slides

Motivations for peer reviewers to perform pre- publication review of manuscripts: a systematic

14th EASE Conference, Bucharest , Romania, 8th-10th June, 2018 Motivations for peer reviewers to perform pre- publication review of manuscripts: a systematic review Mersiha Mahmi-Kaknjo 1 *, Mario Maliki 2 , Ana Utrobii 3 , Dario

260 views • 13 slides

Thank You! Reviewers Moss Drake Roslyn Lindquist

10/17/2011 Designing Process Improvement PNSQC 2011 John Ruberto Thank You! Reviewers Moss Drake Roslyn Lindquist ________________________________________________________________ Excerpt from PNSQC 2011 PNSQC.ORG Copies may not be

446 views • 12 slides

Chile PC R-PP Review Reviewers: Switzerland, U.S., Colombia Washington DC, March 19 2013 Summary

Chile PC R-PP Review Reviewers: Switzerland, U.S., Colombia Washington DC, March 19 2013 Summary This is a well conceptualized, prepared, and presented R-PP. The approach to readiness captured here appears to be appropriate to addressing the

59 views • 5 slides

R graph ics Can R Draw Graphs? My first peer review experience ... Paul Murrell Reviewers

R graph ics Can R Draw Graphs? My first peer review experience ... Paul Murrell Reviewers comments The University of Auckland An obvious reject, trivial, with no research component. June 17 2006 The article was accepted! R graph ics

95 views • 6 slides

Reviewers Training Session o Who we are? MusiQuE Board members MusiQuE Team MusiQuE

Introduction to the MusiQuE Peer- Reviewers Training Session o Who we are? MusiQuE Board members MusiQuE Team MusiQuE Trainers o Who are you? Introduction to the MusiQuE Peer- Reviewers Training Session o Why this workshop?

627 views • 50 slides

Troubleshooting Conversations with Program Reviewers September 19, 2017 1 New/Revised UG,

Program Proposal Troubleshooting Conversations with Program Reviewers September 19, 2017 1 New/Revised UG, Graduate and Certificate Forms 2A, 2B, 2C and 3A Section 1 - General Information Program title is just the title no award e.g.

475 views • 26 slides

Responses to reviewers ques/ons DAQ design team CERN, 4 th November 2016 1. Produce an orgchart

Responses to reviewers ques/ons DAQ design team CERN, 4 th November 2016 1. Produce an orgchart with leadership & person power in each box -is there a steering group? [ See next slides DUNE Organization 3 10.18.16 Eric James | NP04

1.13k views • 22 slides

Reviews, Responses, and Panels John A Clark So who decides who gets a grant? Reviewers and

Reviews, Responses, and Panels John A Clark So who decides who gets a grant? Reviewers and Panels In most cases your proposal goes out to peer review from experts in your proposals field. They will examine your proposal and write reports

548 views • 12 slides

Q&A with Project Competition Peer Reviewers January 31, 2019 Slide de Summar ary

Q&A with Project Competition Peer Reviewers January 31, 2019 Slide de Summar ary Angela McCormick, Research Facilitator Dr. Jaynie Yang Professor, Department of Physical Therapy Dr. Joe Casey Professor, Department of

936 views • 40 slides

Linda Gregg NP, Janet Isabell NP, Sue Montei NP Clinical Reviewers Reproductive Health Unit What

Linda Gregg NP, Janet Isabell NP, Sue Montei NP Clinical Reviewers Reproductive Health Unit What We Plan To Do Describe the U.S. Medical Eligibility Criteria for Contraceptive Use, 2016 (U.S. MEC) Explain how to use the U.S. MEC

505 views • 47 slides

Forest Carbon Partnership Facility 17th FCPF Participants Committee Meeting Belize PC Reviewers:

Forest Carbon Partnership Facility 17th FCPF Participants Committee Meeting Belize PC Reviewers: Indigenous Peoples Representative and El Salvador, Lima, Peru July 2-4, 2014 General comments Latest version of R-PP has much improved from

113 views • 7 slides

resource development Authors Reviewers Safe Communication Users IV Meds Admin Suturing Chest

Health board engagement during resource development Authors Reviewers Safe Communication Users IV Meds Admin Suturing Chest Drains IO Cannulation IM Injections Lumbar Puncture LP April 2018 1. What is your profession? 100% 90% 80%

472 views • 15 slides

Introduction to the MusiQuE Peer- Reviewers Training Session o Why this workshop? offering

Introduction to the MusiQuE Peer- Reviewers Training Session o Why this workshop? offering elements of training and professional development provide further information about MusiQuE o For whom is it? potential and confirmed MusiQuE

754 views • 46 slides

Liberia R-PP Draft 30 May 2011 PC review Reviewers: European Commission, Nepal, Norway, Uganda

Liberia R-PP Draft 30 May 2011 PC review Reviewers: European Commission, Nepal, Norway, Uganda 1a National Readiness Management Arrangements Strengths: Commitment of other sectors in planning and implementation of REDD readiness shown

1.41k views • 12 slides

Learning from Applicants and Reviewers about Engagement Resources Sana N. Vieux, MPH Program

Learning from Applicants and Reviewers about Engagement Resources Sana N. Vieux, MPH Program Associate, Research Integration and Evaluation Applicant and Reviewer Surveys Spring 2014 Fall 2014 Spring 2014 Pragmatic Trials (May 2014)

313 views • 15 slides

Tips from the reviewers' point of view (personal) Masao Saito (NAOJ: TMT-J Project Office)

Tips from the reviewers' point of view (personal) Masao Saito (NAOJ: TMT-J Project Office) Reference Updated ALMA Principles of the ALMA Proposal Review Process https://almascience.nao.ac.jp/documents-and-tools/cycle5/alma-

449 views • 18 slides

Forest Carbon Partnership Facility 17th FCPF Participants Committee Meeting URUGUAY PC Reviewers:

Forest Carbon Partnership Facility 17th FCPF Participants Committee Meeting URUGUAY PC Reviewers: United States, Indigenous Peoples Representative, and El Salvador Lima, Peru July 2-4, 2014 R-PP Version June 9, 2014 Standard "Mesa

254 views • 6 slides