Transcript of the Hearing of Date: June 10, 2014 Volume: I Case: 2013-2015 C&LM Plan Printed On: June 25, 2014 UNITED REPORTERS, INC. Phone:(866) 534-3383 Fax: (877) 534-3383 Email: info@unitedreporters.com Internet: www.unitedreporters.com
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 1 THIS TRANSCRIPT CONTAINS 77 PAGES NUMBERED 1 THROUGH 77 STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION BUREAU OF ENERGY AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY 2013 - 2015 Conservation and Load Management Plan - SBEA Impact Evaluation Technical Meeting held at the Department of Energy and Environmental Protection, 79 Elm Street, Hartford, Connecticut, on June 10, 2014, beginning at 10:00 a.m. H e l d B e f o r e: DIANE W. DUVA, Hearing Officer UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 2 1 A p p e a r a n c e s: 2 For DNV GL: 3 THOMAS LEDYARD 4 *THOMAS FRANKS 5 *KENNETH AGNEW 6 7 For Northeast Utilities: 8 GEOFFREY EMBREE 9 10 For UIL Holdings: 11 PATRICK MCDONNELL 12 ROY HALLER 13 *DENNIS O'CONNOR 14 *MICHAEL GHILANI 15 *DICK OSWALD 16 17 For PURA: 18 SERA EVALUATION CONSULTANT TEAM 19 *LORI LEWIS 20 21 For Greater New Haven Chamber of 22 Commerce: 23 *AMY THOMPSON 24 25 UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 3 1 A p p e a r a n c e s: (Cont'd.) 2 For the Connecticut Energy Efficiency 3 Board: 4 LES TUMIDAJ 5 6 For CBIA: 7 ERIC BROWN 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 * Present by telephone. UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 4 1 MS. DUVA: Yes, let's start 2 the record. So we're recording and 3 transcribing this meeting because it is an 4 evaluation effect meeting. 5 Are we good? Okay. 6 So today is June 10, 2014. 7 And here in Hartford, in the Ensign Room, we 8 have an evaluation report being presented by 9 Tom Ledyard. 10 And we have other people who 11 are in the room in Hartford and people on the 12 telephone. 13 I am Diane Duva of the 14 Department of Energy and Environmental 15 Protection. 16 We have Tom Ledyard of -- 17 MR. LEDYARD: DNV GL. 18 MS. DUVA: Thank you. 19 And we also have -- go ahead 20 and identify your name and your affiliation. 21 MR. EMBREE: Geoff Embree with 22 Northeast Utilities. 23 MS. DUVA: And also? 24 MR. HALLER: Roy Haller, 25 H-a-l-l-e-r, UIL Holdings. UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 5 1 MS. DUVA: And we also have a 2 consultant for the committee? 3 MR. TUMIDAJ: Les Tumidaj with 4 the Energy Efficiency Board, the C and I 5 consultants. 6 MS. DUVA: And on the 7 telephone, go ahead, Amy. 8 MS. THOMPSON: Amy Thompson, 9 Greater New Haven Chamber of Commerce. 10 MS. DUVA: Okay. 11 And we also have Mike? 12 MR. GHILANI: Yeah, Mike 13 Ghilani with UI, United Illuminating. 14 MS. DUVA: We also have Tom 15 Franks. 16 Go ahead, Tom. 17 MR. FRANKS: Tom Franks, DNV 18 GL. 19 MS. DUVA: And then -- 20 THE COURT REPORTER: Can you 21 give me one moment. I'm having a small 22 technical difficulty. 23 MS. DUVA: Sure. We're going 24 to pause to let the court reporter get the 25 computer operational. UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 6 1 THE COURT REPORTER: Please 2 excuse me. 3 MS. DUVA: That's okay. But 4 I'll take the opportunity just to say there's 5 a couple of other people who called in but we 6 don't know your names. 7 (Pause.) 8 THE COURT REPORTER: I got it. 9 Thank you. 10 MS. DUVA: Okay. We're good. 11 So I think where we left off 12 was Mike Ghilani was identifying himself and 13 his affiliation. Okay. 14 So Mike Ghilani of United 15 Illuminating. 16 We also have Tom Franks. Go 17 ahead and say your name. This is because 18 we're just getting back to putting this on 19 the record. Go ahead and say your name, Tom 20 Franks, again. 21 MR. FRANKS: Tom Franks, DNV 22 GL. 23 MS. DUVA: Okay. Go ahead, 24 Lori. 25 MS. LEWIS: Lori Lewis on UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 7 1 behalf of the PURA, SERA Evaluation 2 Consultants. 3 MS. DUVA: Okay. 4 And go ahead, Ken. 5 MR. AGNEW: Ken -- Ken Agnew, 6 DNV GL. 7 MS. DUVA: Okay. Go ahead, 8 Dennis. 9 MR. O'CONNOR: Dennis 10 O'Connor, small business administrator, UI 11 Company. 12 MS. DUVA: Who else has joined 13 us on the telephone? 14 MR. OSWALD: Dick Oswald from 15 United -- UI Planning. 16 MS. DUVA: Great. Thank you. 17 Mike, tell where you're from. 18 MR. EMBREE: He's from UI as 19 well. 20 MS. DUVA: UI? Okay. 21 And then also in the room, we 22 have -- go ahead, Eric. 23 MR. BROWN: Eric Brown, with 24 the Connecticut Business and Industry 25 Association. UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 8 1 MS. DUVA: Okay. We can 2 begin. 3 Go ahead, Tom. 4 MR. LEDYARD: Okay. 5 Thank you, everyone for -- for 6 calling in or joining us here in Hartford. I 7 appreciate the opportunity. I always enjoy 8 the opportunity to present the impact 9 findings, especially in my home state. 10 I work out of Middletown, 11 Connecticut. I have two colleagues on the 12 phone, Ken Agnew from Wisconsin, who was 13 instrumental in -- in helping me piece 14 together the billing analysis work that we'll 15 discuss, and Tom Franks who's involved in a 16 great deal of other Connecticut evaluation 17 work and had interest in understanding this 18 process and -- and hearing the presentation. 19 One of the other people I 20 wanted to call out is Jeff Zinda. He is 21 in -- also in the Middletown office, and he 22 was instrumental in coordinating and 23 overseeing a lot of the metering and 24 verification work that we did, which was a 25 big part of the evaluation. UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 9 1 The evaluation we did was on 2 the 2011 program year of the small business, 3 or SBEA Program. The evaluation began in the 4 summer of 2012. The metering occurred 5 between October of 2012 and October of 2013. 6 And the final report has been completed and 7 filed. We received comments from both UI and 8 CL&P on that document. We addressed those 9 comments, and that report is now considered 10 final. 11 The presentation itself will 12 largely mimic the report. I'll go over the 13 study goals and objectives that were laid out 14 at the outset. I'll go over the activity or 15 what the program tracked in savings for the 16 2011 program year. I'll review the 17 methodologies that we employed to evaluate 18 the study, and then I'll go over the study 19 results. 20 And there's really three 21 sections of this that I'll go over. The 22 first one will be the on-site with the 23 metering that we performed. The second will 24 be review of the PSD that we performed, or 25 the document that -- that drives the energy UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
2013-2015 C&LM Plan June 10, 2014 Page 10 1 savings estimates. And then the third one 2 will be will be the billing analysis. And 3 then I'll, at the conclusion, I'll talk about 4 our final conclusions and recommendations. 5 And there are -- they're 25 6 slides, so if you want to keep track of how 7 far along we're going, I don't anticipate 8 this being more than 30 to 40 minutes. 9 The studies and objectives, 10 there were two primary studies -- objectives 11 of the studies. The first one is to estimate 12 a program level electric gross savings 13 estimates, plus or minus 10 percent precision 14 at that 90 percent level of confidence. 15 That's sort of a standard target, a precision 16 target for evaluation studies in the 17 industry. The second was around energy 18 savings. The second goal was to estimate 19 SBEA electric demand savings or peak demand 20 savings coincidental for summer on peak and 21 seasonal peak, at plus or minus 10 percent at 22 the 80 percent confidence -- level of 23 confidence. 24 This is more -- this goal 25 drives from essentially ISO New England FCM UNITED REPORTERS, INC. info@unitedreporters.com (866) 534-3383 www.unitedreporters.com 6cf28920-5e73-4d12-8ec4-3bfee4a4b89c
Recommend
More recommend
