Shared Agency and Motor Representation s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk
Parallel but Individual Agency Shared Agency Two sisters cycling to Two strangers cycling the school together. same route side-by-side. (cf. Gilbert 1990)
Parallel but Individual Agency Shared Agency Two sisters cycling to Two strangers cycling the school together. same route side-by-side. (cf. Gilbert 1990) Members of a flash mob Onlookers simultaneously open simultaneously open their newspapers noisily their newspapers noisily (cf. Searle 1990: 92)
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed?
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed?
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? amuse joint action free act smash alarm
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? amuse joint action free act smash alarm
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free reach act smash grasp alarm scratch
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free coordinates reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free coordinates reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
‘the key property of joint action lies in its internal component [...] in the participants’ having a joint “collective” or “shared” intention.’ What is the relation between a purposive action and the (Alonso 2009, pp. 444-5) goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free coordinates reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
‘the key property of joint action lies in its internal component [...] in the participants’ having a joint “collective” or “shared” intention.’ What is the relation between a purposive action and the (Alonso 2009, pp. 444-5) goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free coordinates reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome.
Parallel but Individual Agency Shared Agency G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome. Two sisters cycling to Two strangers cycling the school together. same route side-by-side. (cf. Gilbert 1990) Members of a flash mob Onlookers simultaneously open simultaneously open their newspapers noisily their newspapers noisily (cf. Searle 1990: 92)
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome.
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome. G is a collective goal (a) it is a distributive goal; (b) the actions are coordinated; and (c) coordination of this type would normally facilitate occurrences of outcomes of this type.
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome. G is a collective goal (a) it is a distributive goal; (b) the actions are coordinated; and (c) coordination of this type would normally facilitate occurrences of outcomes of this type.
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome. G is a collective goal (a) it is a distributive goal; (b) the actions are coordinated; and (c) coordination of this type would normally facilitate occurrences of outcomes of this type.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve action on the part of each agent, where the resulting plans are identical (or similar enough).
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions. where the resulting plans are identical (or similar enough).
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
premise: Some joint actions are facilitated by the agents engaging in reciprocal, parallel agent-neutral motor planning for outcomes whose realisation would normally involve one’s own and another’s (or others’) actions.
Move it from there to here
Move it from there to here get it move it position it hand-1 reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release
Move it from there to here get it move it position it hand-1 reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release
Move it from there to here get it move it position it hand-1 reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release
Move it from there to here get it move it position it hand-1 reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release g n m i t i a r l m i i s m e b l o r p
Move it from there to here get it move it position it s a m e p l hand-1 a n n i n g reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release g n m i t i a r l m i i s m e b l o r p
Move it from there to here get it move it position it s a m e p l hand-1 a n n i n g reach grasp move arrive release hand-2 reach grasp move place release prevention g n m i t i a r l m i i s needed m e b l o r p
G is a distributive goal: it is an outcome to which each agent’s actions are individually directed and it is possible that: all actions succeed relative to this outcome. shared motor action 1. we each have a motor G is a collective goal representation of G; (a) it is a distributive goal; 2. we are each disposed to inhibit some (not all) of the (b) the actions are resulting planning or actions; coordinated; and 3. we each expect that if G (c) coordination of this occurs, we will all be agents type would normally of it; and facilitate occurrences of outcomes of this type. 4. (1) and (2) because (3)
joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the goal or goals to which it is directed? wave amuse joint action free coordinates reach act smash shared intention or social grasp motor representation alarm scratch
< different content >
Head southeast on Rue Take RER B and get out Cujas toward Rue at the Luxembourg Victor Cousin. Turn station, from there it's right onto Rue Saint- less than 5 minutes < different format > Jacques. ... walk. < different content >
Head southeast on Rue = Cujas toward Rue ? Victor Cousin. Turn right onto Rue Saint- Jacques. ...
The Interface Problem:
The Interface Problem: Some joint actions involve both shared intention and shared motor representation
Recommend
More recommend
