22 Public Input – Dane & Knowlton Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges Good access to major Good access to major Possible brownfield issues Possible brownfield issues • • roads & roads & business district – business district – Remote – not Remote – ot large roads large roads • central central accessing it accessing it Site on Site on major cut-thru to major cut-thru to • Not visible Not visible • avoid Hamilton so good avoid Hamilton so good visibility visibility Some demo required Some demo required • Potential for Potential for community community • interaction interaction Easy access Easy access near walkshed near walkshed • & enough room & enough room Most viable Most viable – centrally centrally • located, manageable traffic located, manageable traffic
23 Hamilton Avenue
24 Hamilton Avenue Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 3.875 acres 3.875 acres Temporary location for Temporary location for • • District 5 staff who would District 5 staff who would Access to major Access to major roadways roadways • need to be relocated need to be relocated during construction during construction Multiple access Multiple access points points • Existing building would Existing building would • In high-call In high-call neighborhood neighborhood • need to be demolished need to be demolished Within College Hill NBD Within College Hill NBD • Located in Historic Located in Historic • District (plaza non- District (plaza non- Correct zoning Correct zoning • contributing) contributing) Privately owned Privately owned (City option (City option • Potential relocation costs Potential relocation costs to purchase) to purchase) • Utilities would need Utilities would need to to be be • extended ~2.75 miles extended ~2.75 miles
25 Public Input – Hamilton Avenue Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges Janice will Janice will bake bake for police for police • Too expensive Too expensive to purchase to purchase • Positive Positive • Too far Too far north – north – great great for for • economic/social/crime economic/social/crime College Hill, College Hill, bad for bad for Distri District 5 ct 5 impact on impact on NBD NBD - visible isible Only one main artery Only one main artery Major road access Major road access • • Available for Available for purchase purchase Cannot assume current high- Cannot assume current high- • • call area will always be call area will always be high- high- In high-call In high-call area area • call area call area Clean and flat – Clean and flat – • ingress/egress ingress/egress Tie in with Firehouse 51 Tie in with Firehouse 51 • Great parking Great parking •
26 Police Impound Lot
27 Police Impound Lot Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 14.1 acres, City-leased 14.1 acres, City-leased Police impound lot is at Police impound lot is at • • capacity and would capacity and would Access to major Access to major • need to be relocated need to be relocated roadways roadways Not within Walk Shed Not within Walk Shed • Zoned properly Zoned prope ly • Not City-owned Not City-owned • Geographically central Geographically c ntral • Potential brownfie Potential brownfield ld • Could help revitalize Could help revitalize • (former CSX (former CSX area – area – between two etween two maintenance site) maintenance site) NBDs NBDs Utilities available ilities available •
28 Public Input – Police Impound Lot Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges Community would love Community would love So So much much pollution from 20 pollution from 20 th th • • this lot to go somewhere this lot to go somewhere Century Industrial Century Industrial else else Too costly to move Too costly to move • Plenty of space – Plenty of space – impound mpound impound impound • lot needs more space lot needs more space Floods Floods anyway anyway • Not Not a great location – a great location – not ot • visible – visible – too oo far far from major from major business district business district
29 Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia
30 Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 4.4 acres, State-owned 4.4 acres, State-owned Zone change required Zone change required • • Geographically central Geographically c ntral Potential Ingress/ Potential Ingre s/ • • Egress near a road Egress near a road Access to Access to major roadwa major roadways ys • curve curv Multiple access points Mult access points • Portion of site within Portion of site within • 100-year 100-year flood plain flood plain In medium-call In medium-c all • neighborhood neighborhood This area was planned This area was planned • to be a skate to be a skate park park for for ½ mile Walk Shed mile Walk Shed • the neighborhood the neighborhood Utilities need to be ilities need to be • extended ~1/2 mile extended ~1/2 mile
31 Public Input – Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges Centrally located – great Centrally located – great Hard to Hard to find access? find access? • • location & access to all location & access to all Due to 100 year flood again Due to 100 year flood again neighborhoods neighborhoods • more expense possible more expense possible Good access to major Good access to major • Northside may not want it Northside ay not want it roads & roads & expressways expressways • here – here – could have poor could have poor Potential Northside Potential Northside access and ingress/egress access and ingress/egress • gateway gateway Not walkable Not walkable • 3 of 3 of top 4 top 4 areas for areas for • No skatepark? No skatepark? service calls near here service calls near here • New utilities already New utilities already • coming coming
32 Preliminary Site Matrix 3 ‐ 1 ‐ 18 3 ‐ 1 ‐ 18 3 ‐ 1 ‐ 18 3 ‐ 7 ‐ 18 3 ‐ 7 ‐ 18 3 ‐ 7 ‐ 18 Total Net Id Site Zoning Acres Status Circled Crossed Off Net Score Circled Crossed Off Net Score Score 5 0 5 5 0 5 10 8 Dane & Knowlton MG 3.43 Privately Owned 3 3244 ‐ 3300 Central Parkway CC ‐ A 7.19 City/Privately Owned 5 1 4 5 0 5 9 9 Hamilton Avenue T5N.LS 3.18 Privately Owned 4 1 3 6 0 6 9 16 Rummymede ‐ Colerain & Virginia RM ‐ 2.0 4.40 State Owned 6 0 6 4 2 2 8 6 Colerain Avenue Access SF ‐ 4 7.16 City Owned 5 0 5 4 2 2 7 3 0 3 4 1 3 6 15 Police Impound Lot MG 14.12 City Leased 1 Bethlehem Temple CC ‐ A 10.97 Privately Owned 0 1 ‐ 1 2 1 1 0 4 3917 Colerain Avenue MG 2.64 Privately Owned 0 1 ‐ 1 0 0 0 ‐ 1 5 5088 Colerain Avenue PR 0.65 City Owned 0 1 ‐ 1 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 2 10 1676 Hoffner Street ML 1.45 Privately Owned 0 1 ‐ 1 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 2 0 2 ‐ 2 0 0 0 ‐ 2 12 1805 Larch Avenue PR 3.16 City Owned 13 1012 Ludlow Avenue PR 1.27 City Owned 0 1 ‐ 1 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 2 0 1 ‐ 1 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 2 18 Stock Street SF ‐ 2 3.04 City Owned 20 4981 Winton Road MA 5.37 Privately Owned ‐ Available 0 1 ‐ 1 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 2 0 2 ‐ 2 1 2 ‐ 1 ‐ 3 7 1670 Cooper Street MG/ML 2.79 Privately Owned 11 Kings Run Drive PR 3.49 City Owned 0 2 ‐ 2 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 3 0 2 ‐ 2 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 3 17 1444 Springlawn Avenue ML 2.86 Privately Owned 19 William Dooley Bypass MG 2.38 City Owned 0 2 ‐ 2 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 3 2 Center Hill Ave & Este Ave MG 7.80 City Owned 0 4 ‐ 4 0 1 ‐ 1 ‐ 5 14 Mt. Airy Forest PR 8.98 City Owned 0 5 ‐ 5 0 2 ‐ 2 ‐ 7
33 Additional Comments
34 Additional Comments Excited about this open Excited about this open Describe how police respond to Describe how police respond to • • process – Thanks! process – Thanks! each type of crime each type of crime Ask Fire Department for Ask Fire D artment for UC Police not enough in CUF UC Police not enough in CUF • • their input their input Would CUF be better in District 1? Would CUF be better in District 1? • Colerain Avenue is a Colerain Avenue is a faster faster • Who will pay for the moving cost? Who will pay for the moving cost? north/south corr north/ south corrido idor than than • Hamilton Avenue Hamilton Avenue Has Has to be >3 acres – to be >3 acres – no no • brownfie brownfield, no floodplain! ld, no floodplain! Buffer Buffer map based on travel map based on travel • time from stations time from stations Don’t Don’t take park land take park land • How are substations used? How are substations used? • Break down calls by crime Break down calls by crime • type for next meeting type for next meet ing
35 Additional Comments Potentially build new east/west Potentially build new east/west • connec connector tor arter arterial from north al from north of Bethlehem Temple west to of Bethlehem Temple west to Colerain Avenue/Shepherd Colerain Avenue/Shepherd Road Road No roads running No roads running east/west? east/west?? • It’s a waste of It’s a waste of taxpayer funds taxpayer funds • to pay to pay to relocate another to relocate another government e government entity for this tity for this project project Pick a Pick a site that is site that is city owned or city owned or • readily readily available and available and proper properly ly zoned zoned
36 Additional Sites Suggested
37 17 Additional Sites Suggested Clifton Ave Clifton Ave & & Mill Creek Mill Creek MLK and Clifton MLK and Clifton • • Daily Mart Daily Mart Mt. Airy Forest - Mt. Airy Forest - West Fork Rd est Fork Rd • • Farm near CH Pet Clinic Farm near CH Pet Clinic NE Corner Hamilton & NE Corner Hamilton & North North • • Bend Bend GCWW GCWW • NW Corner Hamilton & North NW Corner Hamilton & North • Kahns - Rhinegeist Kahns hinegeist • Bend Bend Kenard Kenard • Sansolone Sansolone Family Site Family Site • Kroger Kroger • Spring Grove Spring Grove & & Crawford Crawford • Ludlow Ave & Ludlow Ave & Central Central • W North Bend W North Bend • Parkway Parkway William Dooley & William Dooley & Blue Rock Blue Rock • Mercy Mt. Mercy Mt. Airy Airy •
38 Additional Sites Id Site Zoning Acres Status 21 Clifton Ave & Mill Creek CC ‐ A 3.1 Privately owned 22 Daily Mart T5N.LS, RMX 2.53 Privately owned 23 Farm near CH Pet Clinic SF ‐ 6 31.82 Privately owned 24 GCWW MG 13.51 City owned 25 Kahns ‐ Rhinegeist MG 8.01 Privately owned 26 Kenard CC ‐ A 2.96 Privately owned 27 Kroger CC ‐ A 8.65 Privately owned 28 Ludlow Ave & Central Parkway MG 5.2 Privately owned 29 Mercy Mt. Airy IR 45.82 Privately owned 30 MLK and Clifton CN ‐ P 3.30 Privately owned 31 Mt. Airy Forest ‐ West Fork Rd PR 6.44 City owned 32 NE Corner Hamilton & North Bend T5MS 2.29 Privately owned 33 NW Corner Hamilton & North Bend T5N.LS, T5MS, T5N.MF ‐ O 5.29 Privately owned 34 Sauselone Family MG, CC ‐ A 4.08 Privately owned 35 Spring Grove & Crawford MG 9.62 Privately owned ‐ multiple owners 36 W North Bend CC ‐ M, SF ‐ 6 2.96 Privately owned 37 William Dooley & Blue Rock MG 2.93 Privately owned
39 Clifton Ave & Mill Creek
40 Clifton Ave & Mill Creek Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 3.1 acres in medium - 3.1 acres in medium - Demo required Demo required • • call neighborhood call neighborhood Privately owned Privately owned • Direct access to Direct access to • Not within ½ mile Not within mile • primary road primary road walk shed walk shed Correct zoning Correct zoning • Partially in hillside, Partially in hillside, • Utilities available Utilities available which is tight which is tight •
41 Daily Mart
42 Daily Mart Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges In high-call ar In hi gh-call area ea 2.53 acres – too small 2.53 acres – too small • • Located within College Located within College 3 separate 3 separate • • Hill NBD and ¼ mile Hill NBD and mile parcels/owners parcels/owners walk shed walk shed Mult Multiple zoning districts iple zoning districts • Flat Flat • Takes away ½ the Takes away the • park parking from the ing from the existing church existing church Not fully available Not fully available • Utilities woul ilities would need to d need to • be extended ~2.75 miles be extended ~2.75 miles
43 Farm near CH Pet Clinic
44 Farm near CH Pet Clinic Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 31 acres 31 acres Requires zone change Requires zone change • • Located on Located on major east- major east- Priv Private ately owned -not y owned -not • • west arterial west arterial available available Not within Not within ½ mile mile • walkshed walkshed At edge of At edge of city limits city limits • Utilities woul ilities would need to d need to • be extended ~2.75 miles be extended ~2.75 miles
45 GCWW
46 GCWW Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 13.5 acres 13.5 acres GCWW would need GCWW would need • • to be relocated to be relocated Centrally located Centrally located • Not within ½ mile Not within mile • City owned (GCWW) City owned (GCWW) • walkshed walkshed Direct access to Direct access to • primary roads with primary roads with safe access safe access Correct zoning Correct zoning • Utilities available Utilities available •
47 Kahns - Rhinegeist
48 Kahns - Rhinegeist Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges Priv Private ately owned y owned 8 acres 8 acres • • In low-call ar In l w-call area ea Correct zoning Correct zoning • • Could be catalyst for Could be catalyst for Not as Not as visible as visible as other other • • locations locations further further rede redevel velopment pment Within ½ mile walkshed Within mile walkshed • Vacant Vacant • Utilities c ilities close ose • Could potentially Could potentially • incorporate new range incorporate new range
49 Kenard
50 Kenard Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges In medium-call In medium-call Privately owned Privately owned • • neighborhood neighborhood (Woody Sander Ford) (Woody Sander Ford) Not within Not within ½ mile mile Correct zoning Correct zoning • • walkshed walkshed No structures No structures • Just under 3 Just under 3 acres acres • Somewhat centrally Somewhat centrally • located located Not on main road Not on main road • Flat Flat • Utilities close Utilities close •
51 Kroger
52 Kroger Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 8.65 acres 8.65 acres Privately owned Privately owned • • (Kroger) (Kroger) Correct zoning Correct zoning • Not available Not available • Multiple access points Multiple access points • Not within ½ mile Not within mile • In medium-call In medium-call • walkshed walkshed neighborhood neighborhood Flat Flat • Utilities close Utilities close •
53 Ludlow & Central Pkwy
54 Ludlow & Central Pkwy Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 5.2 acres 5.2 acres Multiple parcels with Multiple parcels with • • multiple owners multiple owners Correct zoning Correct zoning • Existing businesses Existing businesses • Across Ludlow from Across Ludlow from • would have to would have to previous District 5 HQ previous District 5 HQ relocate relocate Utilities available Utilities available • Potential brownfield Potential brownfield •
55 Mercy Mt. Airy
56 Mercy Mt. Airy Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 45.8 acres 45.8 acres Far NW part of Distr Far NW part of District ct • • Not in Not in ½ mile walkshed mile walkshed Correct zoning Correct zoning • • Available Available Discussion of new Discussion of new • • residential development sidential development In high-call In hi gh-call • on the on the site site neighborhood neighborhood Utilities almost 4 Utilities almost 4 miles miles • away away
57 MLK and Clifton
58 MLK and Clifton Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 3.3 acre site in high- 3.3 acre site in high- Located in south Located in south • • call neighborhood call neighborhood part of district part of district Correct zoning Correct zoning Surrounded by Surrounded by • • residential zoning on residential zoning on Relatively flat site Relatively flat site • 3 sides 3 sides In ½ mile walk shed In mile walk shed • Potential traffic Potential traffic • issues issues Utilities close Utilities close •
59 Mt. Airy Forest – West Fork
60 Mt. Airy Forest – West Fork Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 6.44 acres 6.44 acres Zone change required Zone change required • • Not in ½ mile Not in mile City owned (Park City owned (Park • • Board) Board) walkshed walkshed Relatively flat Relatively flat This portion of West This portion of West • • Fork Road is Fork Road is within within 100 year flood plain 100 year flood plain Utilities ~ 1 mile away Utilities ~ 1 mile away •
61 NE Hamilton & North Bend
62 NE Hamilton & North Bend Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges City-owned City-owned 2.29 acres 2.29 acres • • Correct zoning Correct zoning Surrounded by Surrounded by • • residential uses residential uses In high-call In high-call • neighborhood neighborhood Not centrally located Not entrally located • In College Hill NBD In College Hill NBD Utilities over 3 miles Utilities over 3 miles • • away away Located at corner of Located at corner of • two major arterials two major arterials Vacant Vacant •
63 NW Hamilton & North Bend
64 NW Hamilton & North Bend Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 5.29 acres 5.29 acres Several development Several development • • proposals proposals City owned City owned • Surrounded by Surrounded by • Correct zoning Correct zoning • residential uses residential uses In high-call In high-call • Not centrally located Not centrally located • neighborhood neighborhood Utilities over 3 miles Utilities over 3 miles • In College Hill NBD In College Hill NBD • away away Located at corner of Located at corner of • two major two major arterials arterials Vacant Vacant •
65 Sansolone Family Property
66 Sansolone Family Property Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 4.07 acres 4.07 acres Private Priv ately owned y owned • • Correct zoning Correct zoning Mult Multiple zoning districts iple zoning districts • • In hi In high-call gh-call Two parcels across a Two parcels across a • • neighborhood neighborhood major arterial major arterial In ½ mile walkshed In mile walkshed Re-aligning the street Re-aligning the street • • would add significant would add significant Potential to re-align Potential to re-align • time and cost time and cost Central Parkway to Central Parkway to make it one make it one parcel to parcel to improv improve safety safety Utilities c ilities close ose •
67 Spring Grove & Crawford
68 Spring Grove & Crawford Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 9.62 acres 9.62 acres Multiple parcels with Multiple parcels with • • multiple owners multiple owners In 1/2 mile walk shed In 1/2 mile walk shed • Lots of demo Lots of demo • Correct zoning Correct zoning • required required Good frontage on Good frontage on • major street major street Utilities available Utilities available •
69 W North Bend
70 W North Bend Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 2.96 acres 2.96 acres Zone change required Zone change required • • for part of site for part of site In high-call In high-call • neighborhood neighborhood Multiple parcels with Multiple parcels with • multiple owners multiple owners Would help solve Would help solve • neighborhood issues neighborhood issues Surrounded by Surrounded by • in this area (truck in this area (truck residential uses residential uses parking, drainage) parking, drainage) Edge of City Edge of City • Utilities ~3.5 miles away Utilities ~3.5 miles away •
71 William Dooley & Blue Rock
72 William Dooley & Blue Rock Strengths Strengths Challenges Challenges 2.93 acres 2.93 acres Requires closure of Mad Requires closure of Mad • • Anthony St in this Anthony St in this Correct zoning Correct zoning • location location In medium-call In medium-call • Multiple parcels with Multiple parcels with • neighborhood neighborhood multiple owners multiple owners Utilities close Utilities close • Partially within 100 year Partially within 100 year • flood plain flood plain
73 17 Additional Sites Suggested Clifton Ave Clifton Ave & & Mill Creek Mill Creek MLK & MLK & Clifton Clifton • • Daily Mart Daily Mart Mt. Mt. Airy Forest - Airy Forest - West Fork Rd est Fork Rd • • Farm near CH Pet Clinic Farm near CH Pet Clinic NE Corner Hamilton & NE Corner Hamilton & North North • • Bend Bend GCWW GCWW • NW Corner NW Corner Hamil Hamilton & & North North • Kahns Kahns - Rhinegeist hinegeist • Bend Bend Kenard Kenard • Sansolone Family Site Sansolone amily Site • Kroger Kroger • Spring Grove Spring Grove & & Crawford Crawford • Ludlow Ave & Ludlow Ave & Central Central • W North Bend W North Bend • Parkway Parkway William William Dooley & Dooley & Blue Rock Blue Rock • Mercy Mt. Airy Mercy Mt. Airy •
74 What do you think? Central Parkway • Colerain Ave Access • Which site do you • Dane & Knowlton think best meets • the overall needs Hamilton Ave • of Police District Kahn's - Rhinegeist • 5? Kenard • Which sites • MLK & Clifton • should we keep NW Corner Hamilton & North Bend • on the short list? Police Impound Lot • Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia • Sansolone Family Site •
75 What do you think? Please keep the following three factors in mind: Please keep the following three factors in mind: Constructability Constructability • - Engineering feasibility (hi Engineering feasibility (hillsides, soil c lsides, soil conditions, fl onditions, flood ood plain, etc.), Real estate costs, brownfield mitigat plain, etc.), Real estate costs, brownfield mitigation on Operations Operations • - Pr Proximity to oximity to maj major thor r thoroughfares, ac oughfares, access to ss to utilities utilities Community Development Impact Community Development Impact •
76
77 3244-3300 Central Parkway
78 Colerain Avenue Access
79 Dane & Knowlton
80 Hamilton Avenue
81 Kahns - Rhinegeist
82 Kenard
83 MLK and Clifton
84 NW Hamilton & North Bend
85 Police Impound Lot
86 Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia
87 Sansolone Family Property
88 Voting Results Central Parkway - 19 • Colerain Ave Access - 23 • Dane & Knowlton - 29 • Hamilton Ave - 20 • Kahn's – Rhinegeist - 11 • Kenard - 5 • MLK & Clifton - 3 • NW Corner Hamilton & North Bend - 7 • Police Impound Lot - 4 • Runnymede – Colerain & Virginia - 32 • Sansolone Family Site – 8 • **This vote does not determine the location of the new District 5 HQ. The purpose of the vote was to gauge community support for each site and to see if any site above was completely unacceptable.**
89 Future Building Design Jamie Accurso, City Facilities Management Nestor Melnyk, MSA Architects
90 Overall Building Objectives • Up-to-Date, Functional & Operationally Up-to-Date, Functional & Operationally Efficient Efficient • Flexible to Address Future Needs & Flexible to Address Future Needs & Changes Changes • Respectful of the Budget & Sustainable in Respectful of the Budget & Sustainable in Practice Practice • Visitor-Friendly with Public Interface Visitor-Friendly with Public Interface • Reinforce Safety & Community Oriented Reinforce Safety & Community Oriented Policing Policing
91 Measureable Criteria
92 Program and Use Areas Building program and use areas +/- 200 officers, multiple shifts, staff, parking, & maintenance
93 Functional Needs Spatial relationships, adjacencies and flow
94 Professional Standards Credentialing agencies, standards, technical reviews
95 Sustainability LEED Silver certification goal – payback & simplicity
96 Qualitative Criteria
97 Public Image Character and stature of the building, landmark
98 Engagement with the Neighborhood Contextual, accessible, connected
99 Community Asset Public spaces, public art, resources
100 Physically Secure CPTED: passive and unimposing
Recommend
More recommend
