Oregons Pesticide and Water Quality Monitoring and Management - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Oregon’s Pesticide and Water Quality Monitoring and Management Program Presentation to Oregon’s Pesticide Analytical and Response Center (PARC) May 17, 2017 Kirk V. Cook, RG Pesticide Stewardship Partnership Oregon Department of Agriculture

Oregon’s Pesticide and Water Quality Monitoring and Management Program Overview … . — Basic Principles — Program elements — Statewide pesticide-related water quality team — Watershed-based Pesticide Stewardship Partnerships (PSP) — Water Quality Pesticide Management Strategy — Budget Summary/Status Moving Forward and Key Challenges/Issues

Key points in Oregon’s approach to pesticide occurrences in water bodies • It is voluntary and locally driven • It is collaborative both at the state and local level • It is data driven - Water quality data - Pesticide characteristics - Pesticide management • It is based on “adaptive management” principles • It is supported by both state and federal agencies

Oregon’s Pesticide and Water Quality Monitoring and Management Program

How Did Oregon’s Water Quality Pesticide Program Begin ? Began in the Hood River Watershed in the early 2000’s to address Organophosphate (OP) insecticides detected above WQ standards - An alternative to a solely regulatory approach in dealing with pesticides in local water bodies With local support development of a coordinated voluntary program began that included: • State Agencies – DEQ monitoring • Locals - Growers, Extension, SWCD, Watershed Council, • Irrigation Districts & Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs Focused on development and implementation of Best Management Practices (BMPs) • Application Practices, Buffers, etc. • Outreach/Training • Technical expertise, resources & tools in place at local level All based on data collected within the watershed throughout the year

Pes esticide icide Stew ewar ards dship hip Par artner nerships hips (PSPs) Collaborating at the watershed level Key Steps in Partnership Projects Identify streams with elevated pesticide concentrations or high # of detections Implement water quality monitoring and evaluate results Collaborate to implement voluntary management practices to address findings Follow-up monitoring to determine improvements over time

Successes in Fruit Growing Areas along the Columbia Hood River PSP: What Can Be Achieved? Goal: Reduction in concentrations & frequency of detections over time A result of IPM, alternative pesticides, improved application practices, monitoring, etc.

Expansion of the PSP Program — As a result of Hood River success, additional pilot projects added in 2000s — Legislature funded program beginning in 2013 — Program supported by grant funding and in-kind contributions until 2013 - Between 2005 and 2015, nine watershed-based PSP projects were initiated — Formation of State Water Quality Pesticide Management Team (WQPMT) in 2007 provided guidance and consistency to watershed projects

(86%) Only 2 sampling Cherry growers increasing use of events weather stations to reduce wind drift, during 2010 spray using more ground (rather than aerial) season spraying near streams, and rotating chemistry. (19%)

Irrigation District switched to mechanical control of vegetation, along with spot spraying of less toxic and persistent herbicide.

Water er Qualit Quality Monit onitor oring ing

Areas of the State Where Pesticide Monitoring Has Occurred Each of the areas Indicated have petitioned the state to participate in the program known as the Pesticide Stewardship Partnership. Currently there are nine such areas with three Pilots that have been Conducted (or) are being conducted.

Water er Qualit Quality Monit onitor oring ing Currently water quality monitoring activities conducted thru the Pesticide Stewardship Partnership program capture: 78 currently registered pesticides - 57 Herbicides - 46 Insecticides - 9 Fungicides 43 non-regulated pesticides - Not registered in OR - Banned or cancelled by EPA (Legacy Pesticides) 11 pesticide metabolites - Breakdown products of current or legacy pesticides

Maximum Concentration Level Comparison – All PSP’s 16000 14000 12000 10000 ng/L 8000 2013 6000 2016 4000 2000 0

Number of ALB Exceedence Comparison – All PSP’s 25 20 15 10 2013 5 2016 0

Frequency of Detection Comparison – All PSP’s 70 60 50 40 % 30 2013 2016 20 10 0

Water er Qualit Quality Monit onitor oring ing Program expanding to consider groundwater and sediments Evaluating concentration vs loading using flow data Stream Flow Pesticide Pesticide CFS Concentration Loading ug/L ug/sec 2.16 .167 9.91 2.57 .226 16.40 1.81 .241 12.354 .81 .354 9.56 * From 2016 data Amazon Watershed

Water Quality Pesticide Management Team State Water Quality Pesticide Management Team (WQPMT) formed in 2007 to provide guidance and consistency to watershed projects

Oregon’s Water Quality Pesticide Management Team Water Quality Pesticide Management Team (WQPMT) : Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) Oregon State University (OSU) Extension Service Oregon Department of Agriculture (ODA) Oregon Department of Forestry (ODF) Oregon Health Authority (OHA) Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board (OWEB) Local Partners: Watershed and other natural resource groups Local landowners, growers and chemical distributors Soil and water conservation districts Tribal governments

State Collaboration – The Water Quality Pesticide Management Team The WQPMT provides oversight for Oregon Pesticide Stewardship Partnership which fosters the implementation of the Pesticide Management Plan for Water Quality Protection through the: • Identification of potential concerns and improve water quality affected by pesticide use around Oregon. • Combine local expertise in water quality sampling results to encourage voluntary changes in pesticide use and management practices. • Find ways to reduce pesticide levels while measuring improvements in water quality and crop management. • Work toward measurable environmental improvements, making Oregon waters safer for aquatic life and humans.

The Water Quality Pesticide Management Team Pesticide Evaluation Per the Pesticide Management Plan for Water Quality Protection, an evaluation of all pesticides (of interest) in a state must be evaluated to assess whether they merit an action: 1) Further monitoring assessment 2) Additional education and outreach 3) Modifications in use practices 4) Additional restrictions in use 5) Elimination from use due to environmental concerns This is conducted by the WQPMT who designates a Pesticide of Concern or Pesticide of Interest

Decision Matrix Based on Water Monitoring Data Detected concentration relative to a reference concentration, Frequency of detection, and Trend Over Time Detection as % of Reference Concentration 20 - 50% >100% > 50% 0 - 20% (Level 2) (Level 1) (Level 4)* (Level 3)* 2C : Moderate n 4C : Very 3C : Mod-High 1C : Low o >30% Concern i High Concern Concern t c e (Level C) Concern (POC) (POC) t e (POC) D f o 4B : High 1B : Low 2B : Moderate 3B : Moderate 11 - y Concern Concern Concern c Concern n 30% e (POC) - Watch List u (Level B) q e r F 1A : Low 4A: Mod- 3A: 2A: Concern 0 - 10% High Concern Low Concern Moderate (POC) (Level A) Concern * Actions @ levels 3 & 4 if detected 2 out of 3 years of monitoring

2012-2 -2013 U US-EP S-EPA a and Or nd Oregon P on Pestic sticide ides of s of Inte Interest & st & C Conc oncern (7 rn (72) Red = POC; Yellow = Higher Priority POI Under Review ; Green = Evaluated, not a POC; White = Under Review or Not Evaluated 2,4-D Acetochlor Alachlor Aldicarb Atrazine (Aatrex) Azinphosmethyl Benfluralin Bentazon Bifenthrin Bromacil (Guthion) Chlorpyrifos Carbaryl (Sevin) Carbofuran Chlorothalonil Clopyralid (Lorsban) Copper pesticides Cyfluthrin Cypermethrin Dacthal DBCP Deltamethrin Diazinon Dicamba Dicofol Diuron (Karmex, Direx) Endosulfan Esfenvalerate Ethalfluralin Ethoprop (Mocap) Fenbutatin oxide Fipronil Flumetsulam Glyphosate Hexazinone Imazamethabenz Lambda- Imazapyr Imidacloprid Isoxaflutole Lindane cyhalothrin Linuron Malathion Mesotrione Metalaxyl Metolachlor (Parallel) Metsulfuron Metribuzin (Tricor) MSMA Myclobutanil Napropamide methyl Norflurazone Oxyfluorfen PCP Pendimethalin Permethrin Phenoxy Phosmet Picloram Prometon Prometryn herbicides Propiconazole Sulfometuron Propargite Simazine (Princep) Tebuthiuron (Propimax) methyl (Oust) Terbacil Thiamethoxam Tralkoxydim Triadimeton Triallate Triclopyr Trifluralin