Integrating Stakeholder Preferences in Comparative Effectiveness - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Integrating Stakeholder Preferences in Comparative Effectiveness Research: Potential Uses of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis Techniques August 27, 2012 Community Forum

Moderator: Penny Mohr  Vice President for Program Development, Cent er for Medical Technology Policy  AHRQ’s Communit y Forum proj ect  Expert ise in st akeholder engagement and comparat ive effect iveness research Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Goals  Underst and different formal st ruct ured approaches t o elicit ing and quant ifying st akeholder preferences  Compare and cont rast Conj oint Analysis and Analyt ic Hierarchy Processes as preference assessment t ools  Describe applicat ions of preference met hods t o inform Comparat ive Effect iveness Research (CER) Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

AHRQ Community Forum  To expand st akeholder involvement in comparat ive effect iveness research in AHRQ’ s Effect ive Healt h Care Program  To advance met hods for gat hering public input on value- based healt hcare quest ions Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Comparative Effectiveness Research “ … The purpose of CER is to assist consumers, clinicians, purchasers and policy makers to make informed decisions that will improve health care at both the individual and population levels.” ~Institute of Medicine, 2009 Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Categories of CER Methods  S ystematic reviews of existing research  Decision modeling, with or without cost information  Retrospective analysis of existing clinical or administrative data  Prospective non-experimental studies, including registries  Experimental studies, including randomized clinical trials (RCTs) Community Forum Community Forum

Activities of CER  Ident ifying maj or gaps in exist ing research  S et t ing research priorit ies  Refining research quest ions  Developing st udy prot ocols  Translat ing research findings  S hared decision making Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Speaker: Maarten IJzerman, PhD  Chair, Depart ment of Healt h Technology & S ervices Research, Universit y of Twent e, Net herlands.  Expert ise in pat ient report ed out comes, elicit at ion of pat ient preferences in HTA, mult iple crit eria decision making and discret e choice met hods.  Dr. IJzerman will provide an int roduct ion t o Mult i-crit eria decision models used for healt hcare decision making. Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Speaker: Jerry Krishnan, MD, PhD  Professor of Medicine & Public Healt h & Associat e Vice President for Populat ion Healt h S ciences, in t he Office of Healt h Affairs at t he Universit y of Illinois Hospit al & Healt h S ciences S yst em.  Chair of t he S t eering Commit t ee for t he COPD Out comes-based Net work for Clinical Effect iveness and Research Translat ion (CONCERT).  Dr. Krishnan will describe t he applicat ion of Analyt ic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to identify patient, clinician & other stakeholder preferences for CER in COPD . Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Speaker: F. Reed Johnson, PhD  Dist inguished Fellow and principal economist at Research Triangle Inst it ut e (RTI).  Chair of t he IS POR Conj oint Analysis (CA) Experiment al Design Task Force.  Dr. Johnson will describe t he applicat ion of CA for elicit ing pat ient preferences about healt h out comes t o guide t he design of a st udy prot ocol. Community Forum Community Forum Community Forum

Agenda Introduction 10:30-10:40 AM (Present er: Penny Mohr, Communit y Forum Team) An introduction to the use of Analytical Hierarchy 10:40-11:00 AM (Last 5 minut es Process and Conjoint Analysis in health research reserved f or Q&A) (Present er: Maart en Ij zerman) The use of AHP to elicit stakeholder input for prioritizing 11:00-11:20 AM (Last 5 minut es research reserved f or Q&A) (Present er: Jerry Krishnan) The use of CA to elicit patient preferences in selecting 11:20-11:40 AM treatment endpoints (Last 5 minut es reserved f or Q&A) (Present er: F . Reed Johnson) General Q&A 11:40 AM- 12:00 PM Community Forum Community Forum