Appendix to demonstration paper: Exploring City Structure from Georeferenced Photos Using Graph Centrality Measures Katerina Vrotsou 1 , Natalia Andrienko 1 , Gennady Andrienko 1 , and Piotr Jankowski 2 1 Fraunhofer Institute IAIS 2 San Diego State University submitted to: European Conference on Machine Learning and Principles and Practice of Knowledge Discovery in Databases (ECML PKDD) 2011
Sample of an Exploratory analysis of Seattle Metropolitan Area using Flickr Photos • We consider a Flickr dataset: – From the Puget Sound metropolitan area, Washington State, USA (including the cities of Seattle, Bellevue, Kirkland, Redmond and neighbouring communities) – 577,053 photos – 9,324 photographers – January 1, 2005 - August 31, 2009
Graph of moves between places • We retrieve a directed weighted graph consisting of: – 1,446 vertices (places) – 40,627 edges (moves) – Each edge is weighted by the number of moves between places • and compute centrality scores for each of the vertices (places)
Visual representation of moves between places • Arrows represent the movements between places • They are rendered with 40% transparency • No structure can be detected
Centrality Scores of Places • In-degree • Out-degree • Weighted in-degree • Weighted out-degree • Closeness • Betweenness • Clustering coefficient
In- and out-degree • In and out degree reveal an almost identical picture. In-degree • This can also be seen in their scatter plot out-degree
In- and out-degrees reveal two core clusters of places in Seattle 2 1
1 st core cluster of places Connects the Westlake Center Capitol Hill area and Pike Place Market with the Pacific Science Center and Capitol Hill area around the Broadway Pacific Science Center This cluster of places is no surprise as it contains the main attractions of downtown Westlake Center Seattle which attract most of and Pike Place Market the city visitors.
2 nd core cluster of places Ballard Located along the waterway spanning the urban villages of Freemont Freemont and Ballard With Gas Works Park having the highest in- and out-degree value in this cluster. Gas Works Park This cluster is less obvious and certainly the Gas Works Park area which has the highest value can be considered as being away from the city center. For this reason we analyze the corresponding time series of the area to see whether their high in and out degree stays over time.
In- and out-degrees of Gas Works Park over time In-degree time graph Out-degree time graph Both graphs show high peaks during the summer months
Closeness centrality
Parallel coordinates plot of centrality measures coloured by the closeness classes
High closeness values High closeness values reveal an interesting 2 picture of the core and periphery of well 3 connected 4 1 locations that were photographed. 5
1. The urban core including downtown Seattle along with the Capitol Hill and Queen Anne Hill areas
2. The core is well connected to the areas to the north- west (Ballard and Freemont), north (Green Lake) and north-east (University District) of downtown Seattle
3 4 5 The periphery is comprised of: 3. the areas on the east side of Lake Washington (Bellevue, Kirkland, Redmond) 4. West Seattle with Alki Point and Hamilton View Park 5. the Boeing Fields and Museum of Flight in South Seattle
Clustering w.r.t. centrality scores
Clusters of higher scoring places Parallel coordinates plot of clusters including the most central places.
Clusters with high centrality scores Clusters of high centrality areas include Kirkland (2 water front Parks) and Bellevue town center with the Bellevue shopping mall (upper left map), downtown area of Westlake Center, Freemont and Ballard along the waterway from Lake Union to Eliot Bay, Univ. of Washington campus, Capitol Hill, and the West Seattle’s Hamilton Viewpoint Part (upper right map), Gas Works Parks, Pacific Science Center and Pike Place Market area (lower maps)
Diagrams of parallel bars of centrality scores per area overlaid on the map Places with low degrees are filtered out
Places with high in- and out-degrees and low weighted in- and out- degrees are filtered out… …resulting in areas that were visited frequently but mostly from the same few locations.
Filtering result Bellevue shopping center
Moves to/from Bellevue shopping center To From The movement pattern to and from downtown Bellevue shopping center makes perfect sense as this shopping area is well known for its hip and chic stores.
This appendix presents a sample of a much larger exploratory analysis driven interactively by the analyst The results of such analysis can be used in: • City planning • Transportation research • Tourism planning and development • Marketing and advertising
Recommend
More recommend
