Draft Decision 2014 DAU On 30 January 2015, the Queensland - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Draft Decision – 2014 DAU On 30 January 2015, the Queensland Competition In the 2014 DAU, Aurizon Network has proposed significant changes to the access arrangements for Authority (QCA) released a Draft Decision on Aurizon Network’s 2014 Draft Access Undertaking the Central Queensland Coal Network (CQCN). We (2014 DAU). must assess whether the proposed changes satisfy the requirements of Queensland's access regime. The QCA’s draft decision is to not accept the 2014 DAU proposed by Aurizon Network. The 2014 DAU has been the focus of exhaustive stakeholder consultations since it was first lodged Instead, we have released proposed amendments in April 2013. to Aurizon Network’s 2014 DAU, and our reasons for the draft decision. We welcomed the collaborative approach shown by stakeholders, particularly evident during 2014. Overall, our draft decision reflects our view that the 2014 DAU needs to strike a better balance between All parties have a common interest in enhancing the interests of Aurizon Network and its customers. the efficiency of the industry's supply chain, especially in the current challenging economic Our amendments are intended to make the access conditions. regime more transparent and, wherever possible, simpler. We consider these changes are necessary to improve the overall productivity of the coal supply chain. 2

Themes of the 2014 DAU Draft Decision The overall approach we have taken to meet the requirements of The objective of Part 5 of the the QCA Act in making our Draft Decision has been to: QCA Act is to: • increase transparency and the flow of information between ‘promote the economically Aurizon Network, miners, train operators and other supply chain efficient operation of, use of and participants with the objective of improving the productivity of investment in significant the coal supply chain infrastructure by which services • provide greater confidence to access holders that contracted are provided, with the effect of access rights can be provided, support the development of a promoting effective competition more flexible access rights trading arrangement, and avoid the in upstream and downstream need for unwarranted investment in infrastructure markets’. • provide improved information and confidence to stakeholders that access is being provided on a non-discriminatory basis • enhance the performance reporting arrangements so that access seekers and holders are better informed about CQCN performance, including on major items such as maintenance costs • provide safeguards to balance Aurizon Network's position as a monopoly provider of infrastructure in the expansion of the network so it cannot unreasonably extend the time or request returns for infrastructure provision to gain commercial advantage • wherever possible, make the 2014 DAU access arrangements simpler. 3

Background to Draft Decision: 2014 DAU 4

About the QCA The QCA is an independent statutory authority Our role is to established in 1997 to promote competition as the basis for enhancing efficiency and growth in the Queensland improve the economy. prosperity of Our role is to ensure that monopoly businesses operating Queenslanders by in Queensland, particularly in the provision of key promoting infrastructure, do not abuse their market power through unfair pricing or restrictive access arrangements. competitive markets, Our role has expanded to allow us to be directed to productivity and investigate, and report on, any matter relating to better regulation. competition, industry, productivity or best practice regulation, and review and report on existing legislation. 5

About Aurizon Network and the CQCN Aurizon Network is a wholly owned subsidiary of Aurizon Holdings Limited. Aurizon Network owns and operates the below‐rail network (the CQCN) and is responsible for negotiating access with parties seeking to use this rail network. The CQCN is the largest coal rail network in Australia. The CQCN is made up of five coal systems: Newlands, Goonyella, Blackwater, Moura and Goonyella to Abbot Point (GAP). Aurizon Network is part of the broader coal supply chain in central Queensland, carrying coal from mines either for export or for domestic use Aurizon Network has held 99-year leases of the CQCN assets since July 2010. The term of the leases may be extended for rolling periods of 99 years following 20 years notice. 6

CQCN – third party access regime Access regulation supports competition by Aurizon Network’s access undertaking enabling third parties to access essential establishes the principles that guide infrastructure which cannot be economically negotiations for access to the CQCN. duplicated. This increases certainty and minimises the The CQCN is declared for third-party access potential for access disputes to arise. in accordance with Part 5 of the QCA Act. Parties can agree to other terms and As a result, Aurizon Network (as access conditions on a case by case basis – but if provider) and access seekers are subject to negotiations fail, we resolve disputes in various rights and obligations under the accordance with the access undertaking. access regime. Aurizon Network generates revenue in the Under the access regime, Aurizon Network form of access charges to the network. and an access seeker―who wants to secure Access to the network (including the revenue access to the network―must negotiate in Aurizon Network is entitled to earn) is good faith to reach agreement on the terms regulated in accordance with the QCA Act. and conditions for access. Aurizon Network’s existing undertaking (UT3) If agreement cannot be reached, either is set to expire in 2015. party may refer the dispute to us for resolution under the QCA Act. 7

CQCN regulatory history Rail access regime commenced in 1997. • QCA enacted 1997 The CQCN was declared under Part 5 of the QCA Act for third-party access. • Rail network became a declared service under Part 5 of the QCA Act 1998 The QCA administers the access regime. • UT1 In 2010, ownership of CQCN was separated 2001 from the government owned corporation Queensland Rail, and listed on the ASX. • UT2 2006 In 2011, the Queensland Rail Access Regime was certified under the Competition and • UT3 Consumer Act 2010 (Cwlth) (CCA) as an 2010 effective access regime for 10 years. • Queensland Rail Access Regime was certified under Part IIIA of the CCA as an effective access regime for 10 years 2011 • 2014 Draft Access Undertaking (2014 DAU) which will be known as ‘UT4’ once approved 2015 8

Objectives of an access undertaking An access undertaking sets out the general terms An access and conditions for negotiating access. undertaking Aurizon Network’s access undertaking includes: establishes the • the framework for access negotiations • ring fencing arrangements principles that will • utilisation of network capacity guide negotiations • pricing principles (reference tariffs) and for access. the mechanism for varying those tariffs • reporting. An access undertaking increases certainty and minimises the potential for access disputes to arise. Parties can agree to other terms and conditions on a case by case basis – but if negotiations fail, we resolve any disputes in accordance with the access undertaking. 9

2014 DAU process to date Apr 2013 • Aurizon Network submitted the 2013 DAU May 2013 • QCA commenced an investigation to decide whether or not to approve Aurizon Network's 2013 DAU • Stakeholder consultation (submissions received) • QCA published methodological papers on the cost of capital • Aurizon Network advised of its response to stakeholder concerns Dec 2013 • Cost of capital forum • Consultant’s reports published • Stakeholder consultation (submissions received) • Aurizon Network withdrew the 2013 DAU and submitted the 2014 DAU • QCA commenced an investigation to decide whether or not to approve Aurizon Network's 2014 DAU Aug 2014 Sept 2014 • Release of the Draft Decision on the MAR 10

Governance 11

Intent and scope of the 2014 DAU Part 2 of Aurizon Network’s 2014 DAU We also propose inclusion of: establishes duration, intent and scope of the • a clause similar to UT3 non-discriminatory undertaking. treatment clause―to emphasise the importance of non-discrimination in We propose to accept many elements, provision of the declared service including: • ports, coal mines and third parties with • majority of intent (objective) clause and commercial agreements, in non- scope clause―but have moved the non - discrimination principles―to preclude discrimination principles into Part 2, to favourable treatment of related parties make clear they apply to entire • a process for implementing an incentive undertaking mechanism―recognising benefits of a well • a commitment about the supply and sale developed mechanism for UT4 of electricity―but clarify that dispute • a requirement to notify if AN not owner of resolution applies land―to improve transparency and • not requiring inclusion of Associated efficiency of negotiation. Services―may not be part of declared service • the duration and application of Reference Tariffs― effective for the period 1 July 2013 to 30 June 2017. 12