A Survey on the Fate of Digital Footprints after Death CARSTEN GRIMM* AND SONIA CHIASSON CARLETON UNIVERSITY, OTTAWA, ONTARIO, CANADA * carsten.grimm@ovgu.de
Digital Footprints and Death Digital Footprints pictures and videos, blog, social media, wikis, game achievements and high scores, chat logs, forums, … When we die … unresolved questions arise inheriting accounts? trusted executors? policies for retiring accounts? privacy of the dead? online mourning? 2
Death Related Online Services “[Our service] will let you stay active online from beyond the grave” “If something were to ... happen ... to you, your switch would then send the emails you wrote to the recipients you specified” “We do the research, investigate, write letters, crack passwords, create archives, and hand the product to you, risk- free” Dying Death Service Dilemma: 8 of 18 vanished since 2010 3
Towards a Solution? Unified Online Service authentication during lifetime inheritance, purging, and curating after death Locasto, Massimi, and De Pasquale (NSPW 2011) Design Challenges business model? deployment method? how to assert death? technical realization? legally binding? features? 4
Research Questions: Asking End-Users 1. Relevancy of preparing for death? 2. Familiarity with death related online services? 3. Preferences for fate of digital footprints after death? 4. Whom to entrust with curating one’s digital footprint? 5. Design challenges for a unified service? 5
Methodology STRUCTURE OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE, RECRUITMENT VIA CROWDFLOWER 6
Online Questionnaire Part 1: Demographics age, gender, education, religion, number accounts, ... Part 2: Preferences Fate of Digital Footprints? Differences by account type? Trusted Executors? Provider for unified service? Features for unified service? Asserting death of a client? Part 3: Experiences (optional) 7
Participants and Recruitment Crowdsourcing Workers as Participants 100 from each of United States, India, Great Britain, and Asia* recruited from NeoBux, CliXSense , …, Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, … Answers collected within 7 days during November / December 2013 CrowdFlower as Recruitment Agency hosting survey, posting announcements, compensating participants safeguards against dishonest participants *Vietnam, Laos, Philippines, Indonesia, and Singapore 8
Results & Analysis DEMOGRAPHICS, PREFERENCES
Demographics: Overview Age, Gender, Education, Occupation, ... ages 18 to 69, mean 34.78, std 10.80 176 female (44%), 215 male (54%), 9 decline (2%) … more details in the paper … Worker Channels 126 NeoBux, 98 ClixSense, 42 Prodege, 42 instaGC, 92 other only 2 from Amazon’s Mechanical Turk 10
Demographics: Religions ASIA GBR IND USA Christian Hindu Atheist Muslim Other* decline 0 50 100 150 200 *Other = {Jewish, Buddhist, other (specify below)} 11
Fate of Digital Footprints Type Option # ASIA GBR IND USA social media delete 167 delete next of kin 68 next of kin decide individually leave as is 68 leave as is blog next of kin 126 website policy delete 91 individual or group leave as is 72 no preference dating delete 284 make public other pictures next of kin 198 delete 59 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 12
Communication and Trust COMMUNICATING PREFERENCES TRUSTED EXECUTORS personal communication next of kin or friends account settings notary or lawyer conventional will no preference prepared messages for-profit service no preference national government blog announcement social network online memorial service no one dedicated service other other 0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200 250 13
Unified Service: Provider 14
Unified Service: Provider 1 (strongly disagree) 2 3 4 5 6 (strongly agree) for-profit company municipal government provincial government national government non-profit organization 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 15
Unified Service: Features ASIA GBR IND USA delete accounts messages social post blog post public memorial schedule other 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 16
Unified Service: Verifying Death of a Client ASIA GBR IND USA death certificate issuing institution alive messages monitor activities other 0 50 100 150 200 250 17
Differences between Countries / Religions Fate of Digital Footprints PREPARING DIGITAL FOOTPRINTS FOR DEATH 1 (very irrelevant) 2 3 4 5 (very relevant) USA, ASIA: delete permanently Christian India: give next of kin Hindu GBR: decide individually Atheist Unified Service: Verify Death Muslim slightly more acceptance for Other issuing institution by Hindus, decline Muslims, and Indians 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 18
Conclusion & Discussion SUMMARY, PARTICIPANTS’ VOICES, NEXT STEPS 19
Summary Fate of Digital Footprints after Death deletion, inheritance, preservation account type specific, deletion of contributions? surprising agreement between countries and religions A Unified Service primarily for deletion, acting when receiving death certificate, non-profit, considered appropriate 20
Participants’ Voices “I need to give it some thought, but “Who cares after you’re dead?” not today —it’s depressing me!” “No idea how such a thing could be “I have never considered using a secure , policed, organized or accurate.” service like this — until today. “Mistakes do happen, but there should be no mistakes with this kind of I don’t want my family to view my service .” social media accounts .” 21
Next Steps … Future Work Explain the patterns by interviewing end-users refine and repeat survey for more countries / cultures Design Challenges for Unified Service privacy concerns , business model, security issues , legal basis, deployment method, usability considerations , ... 22
Thank You What are your thoughts? carsten.grimm@ovgu.de 23
Additional Demographics: Age ASIA GBR IND USA 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 < 20 20 - 29 30 - 39 40 - 49 50 - 59 > 59 decline 24
Additional Demographics: Gender female male decline to answer 100 80 60 40 20 0 ASIA GBR IND USA 25
Additional Demographics: Education ASIA GBR IND USA Bachelor's degree some college Master's degree high school degree Associate's degree trade / technical degree some high school Other decline to answer 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 26
Additional Demographics: Occupation ASIA GBR IND USA Unemployed Science, Engineering, and IT Business / Financial Student Service Skilled Labor Administrative Support Education decline to answer Other 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 27
Recommend
More recommend
