Decision on Dropping the Dec Bidding Rule Greg Cook Manager, - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jan 12, 2023 •402 likes •473 views

Decision on Dropping the Dec Bidding Rule Greg Cook Manager, Market Design and Regulatory Policy Board of Governors Meeting General Session May 21-23, 2008 Managements proposal addresses concerns regarding the MRTU bidding rule Goal

Decision on Dropping the Dec Bidding Rule Greg Cook Manager, Market Design and Regulatory Policy Board of Governors Meeting General Session May 21-23, 2008
Management’s proposal addresses concerns regarding the MRTU bidding rule Goal Today � Board approval to make filing to amend MRTU tariff to eliminate Decremental Real-Time Energy bidding rule This Proposal � Addresses immediate concerns by eliminating bidding rule � Recognizes that there will be further efforts to enhance volume and competitiveness of decremental Real-Time Energy bids 2
Rule was originally included in MRTU to prevent uncompetitive real-time bidding Perceived Problem: � Generators could exercise market power through knowledge of infeasible schedules resulting from transmission derates. Solution: � Real-Time Market decremental energy bids not allowed to be lower than bids that cleared the Day-Ahead Market. 3
LECG raised concerns in 2005 review of MRTU design Concerns: � Insufficient real-time decremental energy bids to operate the grid � Easily subverted by withholding real-time decremental energy bids Confirmed by: � Stakeholders � Market Surveillance Committee 4
Consensus gained through working with stakeholders Posted Issue Paper February 1 Joint Stakeholder/MSC Meeting February 8 Stakeholder Written Comments February 15 Posted Straw Proposal March 7 Stakeholder Conference Call March 17 Stakeholder Written Comments March 25 Draft Final Proposal Posted April 14 Stakeholder Written Comments April 30 MSC Opinion Issued May 7 5
Board Action Today: Approve elimination of rule for MRTU July Board Meeting: Proposal for enhanced bidding rules � Markets and Performance (MAP) software release 6

Recommend

Decision on Eliminating Convergence Bidding at the Interties Greg Cook Director, Market &

Decision on Eliminating Convergence Bidding at the Interties Greg Cook Director, Market & Infrastructure Policy Board of Governors Meeting General Session August 25-26, 2011 Convergence bidding implemented in February to provide market

445 views • 10 slides

Decision on commitment cost bidding enhancements proposal Greg Cook Director, Market &

Decision on commitment cost bidding enhancements proposal Greg Cook Director, Market & Infrastructure Policy Board of Governors Meeting General Session March 25, 2016 ISO Confidential The commitment cost bidding enhancements proposal

292 views • 11 slides

tree into a rule set Straightforward, but rule set overly complex More effective

Can convert decision tree into a rule set Straightforward, but rule set overly complex More effective conversions are not trivial Instead, can generate rule set directly For each class in turn find rule set that covers all

455 views • 23 slides

Overview Decision Theory Classification and Bayes decision rule Sampling vs diagnostic paradigm

Overview Decision Theory Classification and Bayes decision rule Sampling vs diagnostic paradigm Chris Williams Classification with Gaussians Loss, Utility and Risk School of Informatics, University of Edinburgh Reject option October 2010

150 views • 4 slides

President Truman and Dropping the Atomic Bomb Mark P. Adams, Truman Presidential Library and

Leadership in Times of Crisis: President Truman and Dropping the Atomic Bomb Mark P. Adams, Truman Presidential Library and Museum ICMA Conference Presenter About me Content expert Examine decision making Weighing all options

135 views • 11 slides

Decision on Convergence Bidding Design Greg Cook Manager, Market Design and Regulatory Policy

Decision on Convergence Bidding Design Greg Cook Manager, Market Design and Regulatory Policy Board of Governors Meeting General Session October 29, 2009 Convergence bids are financial bids submitted in the day-ahead market to buy or sell

352 views • 9 slides

Bidding to Win Key tips for winning tenders Introduction Topic for today - bidding to win

Bidding to Win Key tips for winning tenders Introduction Topic for today - bidding to win Format - tips, examples, stories and discussion A good written proposal might not, in itself, win you the business. But a badly conceived and

511 views • 30 slides

Dropping on the Edge: Flexibility and Dropping on the Edge: Flexibility and Trac Conrmation

7/25/2019 PoPET s18 Dropping on the Edge: Flexibility and Dropping on the Edge: Flexibility and Trac Conrmation in Onion Routing Trac Conrmation in Onion Routing Protocols Protocols Florentin Rochet and Olivier Pereira

573 views • 21 slides

Three Theorems About Package Bidding Based largely on Ascending Auctions with Package

Three Theorems About Package Bidding Based largely on Ascending Auctions with Package Bidding Larry Ausubel and Paul Milgrom June 2002 1 Outline Introduction: Complements and the need for package bidding. Understanding the

463 views • 15 slides

Fundamental Equations Bayes decision rule: = arg max { P ( | O ) } = arg max { P ( ) P

Fundamental Equations Bayes decision rule: = arg max { P ( | O ) } = arg max { P ( ) P ( O ) } P ( O ) acoustic model. For word sequence , how likely are features O ? P ( ) language model. How likely is

735 views • 49 slides

USE OF RULE 132 DECLARATIONS IN TRAVERSING REJECTIONS FOLLOWING THE KSR DECISION Abraham J.

USE OF RULE 132 DECLARATIONS IN TRAVERSING REJECTIONS FOLLOWING THE KSR DECISION Abraham J. Rosner Sughrue Mion, PLLC RECAP OF KSR SUPREME COURT HOLDING In the KSR Case, the Supreme Court held that the patent claim at issue was obvious, and

157 views • 11 slides

Module 7 Construction Bidding 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

Module 7 Construction Bidding 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Example File For Unsuccessful BID 24 Bidder did not include bid security Unsuccessful BID 25 26 27 28 29 Bidding

476 views • 37 slides

TOP TIPS AND PRESENTATION LOG IN DETAILS TOP TIPS AS IDENTIFIED BY YOU DAY 1 Bidding, Value

Exploiting the hierarchical structure of rule-based specifications for decision planning Alberto

Exploiting the hierarchical structure of rule-based specifications for decision planning Alberto Lluch Artur Boronat Roberto Bruni Ugo Montanari Generoso Paolillo IFIP International Conference on Formal T echniques for Distributed Systems

1.29k views • 94 slides

Rule #1: Have a takeaway. Rule #2: Keep It Simple. Rule #3: Repetition is Good. Rule #4: Be

The 4 Rules of Public Speaking Rule #1: Have a takeaway. Rule #2: Keep It Simple. Rule #3: Repetition is Good. Rule #4: Be Prepared! But at the end of the day, we can have the most dedicated teachers, the most supportive parents, the best

395 views • 12 slides

Decision on Proposal to Address Potential Load Underscheduling Until Implementation of

Decision on Proposal to Address Potential Load Underscheduling Until Implementation of Convergence Bidding Charles A. King, P.E. Vice President, Market Development and Program Management Board of Governors Meeting General Session September

220 views • 6 slides

Decision Rule-based Algorithm for Ordinal Classification based on Rank Loss Minimization

Decision Rule-based Algorithm for Ordinal Classification based on Rank Loss Minimization Krzysztof Dembczyski 1 , 2 , Wojciech Kotowski 1 , 3 1 Institute of Computing Science, Pozna University of Technology 2 KEBI, Philipps-Universit at

419 views • 30 slides

PSA APIs An overview Attestation API 1.0.1 we are in the process of dropping a new

PSA APIs An overview Attestation API 1.0.1 we are in the process of dropping a new release which allows signing using symmetric attestation keys (using COSE Mac0) Fully documented in ARM IHI 0085 TF-M master is slightly behind the

542 views • 17 slides

Comparison p of Bidding Algorithms f for Simultaneous Auctions Si lt A ti Seong Jae Lee g

Comparison p of Bidding Algorithms f for Simultaneous Auctions Si lt A ti Seong Jae Lee g Introduction Bidding Problem Bidding Problem Simultaneous Auctions Substitutable & Complementary Goods Substitutable &

279 views • 24 slides

BIDDING STRATEGIES FOR FANTASY-SPORT AUCTIONS BY ANAGNOSTOPOULOS ET AL. Alireza Amani Hamedani

BIDDING STRATEGIES FOR FANTASY-SPORT AUCTIONS BY ANAGNOSTOPOULOS ET AL. Alireza Amani Hamedani Sepehr Mousavi Introduction Absence of Nash equilibrium Fair-Price Bidding 2 Type of online game Participants as virtual managers of

955 views • 35 slides

Decision Trees Aarti Singh Machine Learning 10-701/15-781 Oct 6 , 2010 Learning a good

Decision Trees Aarti Singh Machine Learning 10-701/15-781 Oct 6 , 2010 Learning a good prediction rule Learn a mapping Best prediction rule Hypothesis space/Function class Parametric classes (Gaussian, binomial etc.)

635 views • 38 slides

Unsustainable Bidding Costs Unsustainable Bidding Costs A Critical Issue for Public A

Unsustainable Bidding Costs Unsustainable Bidding Costs A Critical Issue for Public A Critical Issue for Public Private Partnerships Private Partnerships Swee-Eng Chen Professor, School of Architecture and Built Environment

441 views • 12 slides

Are your students dropping out because youre reinforcing their insecurities? Dave Paunesku,

Are your students dropping out because youre reinforcing their insecurities? Dave Paunesku, Ph.D. Stanford University January 27, 2017 San Francisco, CA Anxiety Clouded Thinking Bad Decisions St Struc uctur ural & Academ emic

410 views • 13 slides

The Case for Convergence Bidding at All Pricing Points Presented to Joint ISO/MSC Meeting Offered

The Case for Convergence Bidding at All Pricing Points Presented to Joint ISO/MSC Meeting Offered by Western Power Trading Forum August 10, 2007 Outline Resero Consulting Overview: Why Granular Convergence Bidding is Superior to LAP

490 views • 19 slides