Cramping Syndromes Sodium Loss and Sickle Cell Trait E. Randy Eichner, MD Team Internist, OU Sooners OU Health Sciences Center
Not All Cramps Are Alike None Below from Salty Sweating • Writer’s cramp • Fiddler’s cramp • Golfer’s yips • Hurdler hamstring • Runner side stitch • Hypervent. tetany • Sleeper calf cramp • Sickler cramping
Heat-Cramping Controversy Muscle fatigue and what else ? • Dehydration? • Low potassium? • Low calcium? • Low magnesium? • Muscle spindle/Golgi organ? • Is it quinine deficiency? • Or the dreaded Cramp-O-Ray?
Heat Cramps: Salty Solutions • Stokers • Miners • Military • Hoover Dam • McCance • Tennis • Football
Hoover Dam Saline Solution Talbott & Michelsen, JCI 1933 • “An important criterion (was) …marked relief after (infusing)… normal saline. All cases…free from symptoms within six hours…”
King of Tennis Mike Bergeron (JSMS 2003) • 17 male players • All crampers, but heat-acclimatized • Hot/humid match • Sweat 2.6 L/hr • Na+ loss/hr 2.7 g • One lost 12 g salt an hour!
Chris Legh in Lab Top Australian Triathlete • 2-hr run; 2-h bike • Mimic Kona clime • Lost 8.8 L sweat • Drank 5.5 L fluid • Lost 3.8% body wt • Lost > 25 g salt!
Cystic Fibrosis? • One gene: 1 in 20 or 25 whites • Mitigates typhoid, cholera • Sweat sodium up to 60-80 mmol? • Cake with salt
Heat-Fit Football Player • 250 lb, 60-65% H2O • 17-18 gal water • 100 gm sodium or 50 tsp salt • In hot game, can sweat 1-2 gal fluid, 5-10 tsp salt
Fluid Turnover in 2-a-Days Stofan JR et al., at ACSM 2005 10.3 ± 2.2 L/d (9 - 14 L/d) Players Crampers 11.2 L/d Non-crampers 9.7 L/d Note that top turnover is 3.5 gallons of fluid a day! No wonder they’re thirsty!
SWEATY SOONER STUDY Two groups (n=5): Crampers vs. Non-Crampers Matched: Age, Weight, Race, Position Measures: Sweat out, fluids in, sweat [Na], [K] Pilot Studies: June, July (Field Skills, Indoor Weights) Final Study: August (2-a-days; 2.5 hr practices)
Crampers Are “Salty Sweaters” Cram p Non-Cram p Sweat sodium levels Sweat Sodium, mEq/L are always higher in 100 1.7 1.4 2.1(P<.01) crampers… 80 Trends similar in all 60 three studies, June, 40 July, August… 20 0 June July August OU Studies
Crampers Dehydrate More ES = 0.98 ES = 0.32 C NC C NC 0 Despite drinking, high -0.2 sweat rates dehydrate -0.4 % -0.6 n tio ra -0.8 d y h e D -1 -1.2 -1.4 -1.6 Morning Evening
Crampers Lose More Salt Grams sodium 6 5 4 3 C N C 2 � Sweat [Na] x � Sweat rate = 1 0 GREATER TOTAL LOSS (P=.01) A M PM ES = 1.8 ES = 1.1
Salt Depletion: NFL 2-a-Days Godek et al, ACSM 2004 • 6 NFL players, age ~ 26, wt. ~ 104k • Serum Na+ fell, 140 to 137 mmol/L, by Day 3 (~ 200 mEq Na+ lost) • Or ~ 12 gm of salt lost by Day 3! • Plasma volume fell ~ 5% by Day 3 • Conclusion: They need more Na+ during early 2-a-days
Clues to Salt Depletion Warning signs for athletes • Salt on your skin • Your sweat – Burns eyes – Stings abrasions – Tastes salty • Heat cramping • Dizzy standing up
Get More Salt in Diet! And in Sports Drinks Onfield • Tomato juice • Salty soups • Baked beans • Pickles • Pretzels • Pizza • GLytes • Endurance formula
The Water Hazard - HS linebacker locks up in 2 nd half - Quaffs 9 L water - Seizure, Na + 120 - College LB locks up in practice - Quaffs 12 L water - Goofy, Na + 121 - College FB player with leg cramps - Given 8 L hypotonic fluid IV and po - Goofy, wet lungs, Na + 121
Cramp-Prone? • Lean and fit • Explosive • Many reps • Intense • Heavy sweater • Cakes in salt • Low salt diet
Methods Methods • Measure • Measure – Body weight change – Body weight change – Fluid intake – Fluid intake – Core temperature – Core temperature • Calculate • Calculate – Sweat rate – Sweat rate – % dehydration – % dehydration
8 subjects 129 +12 kg 190 +3 cm 22% fat Pre-session USG: Pre-session USG: 1.025 +0.007 (1002 mOsm/kg) 1.025 +0.007 (1002 mOsm/kg)
Results - Pre-Season Core Temp, ºC • Heat Stress 40.5 40 WBGT 22.9 +07 ºC 39.5 No radiant contribution 39 38.5 • Sweat rate 38 37.5 1.5 +0.3L/h 37 • Dehydration 36.5 36 0.8 +0.4% 35.5 35 Pre End Peak avg 39.4 +0.6 ºC
DB 23.9 +0.3 25 +0.4 ~24ºC RH 77.5 +1.6 76.8 +1.7 75% WBGT 22.3 +0.4 23.4 +0.5 22.5 ºC 3.5 3.0 Change in Tc from Baseline, °C 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 Field Drills (Vest) Heavy Lifting (Wts) Break, then Sprints -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Time (min)
Lessons Learned Radiopills hold promise in football • Can heat up fast and even cramp up • In a June drill • No football gear • Dehydrated at start • Salt-depleted too? • Cool fast when stop, despite cramping
Features of Heatstroke • Fuzzy thinking - Confused, can’t follow plays, runs wrong way • Bizarre behavior - Blank stare, talks nonsense - Yells in rage, wants to fight • Physical decline - Incoordination, N/V, hyperventilation - Wobbles, staggers, collapses - Seizure, coma
Day One Death in Dallas Eric Brown, 17, Carter High, 8/2/04 • Starting center • 3 ½-hr practice • Heat index 105 • Sprints at end • Collapsed once? • Got through it • Seizure at home
Risky Ways for 2-a-Days High schools; Dallas Morning News; Aug ’04 • “Our first practice the longest” (3.5 h) • Breaks in sun • End with 16 sprints • K+ pills at end • If collapse: “Get fluid in them” • Wrong! Get them in fluid! (Ice bath)
immersion Ice water on-site
Dehydration Curbs Cycling Walsh et al: Int J Sports Med 1994 • Twice, in the heat, 6 cyclists ride for 1 hr at 70% VO2 peak, then closing sprint to exhaustion at 90% • One trial, oral fluids; one, without • Without fluids, dehydrated 1.8% • Without fluids, sprint 7 minutes • With fluids, sprint 10 minutes
Learn Your Sweat Rate And drink to match; don’t overdrink! • Weight lost in drill (in oz) • Plus fluid drunk in drill (in oz) • Equals how much to drink • Example: – If loses 3 pounds (3 pints: 48 oz) – And drinks 16 oz (1 pint) – Drink 48 + 16 = 64 oz (4 pints) next drill
Sickling Forces in Football • Severe hypoxemia • Hyperthermia • Acidosis • Dehydration
12 Deaths, College Football All From Sickling; Some Controversial • 1974 Colo., ran 800 m • 1985 Ark., ran ¾ mile • 1986 Miss., ran 1 mile • 1987 Ind., ran 1200 m • 1989 Utah, ran ¾ mile • 1990 NM, ran 800 m • 1992 Ga., ran 1000 m • 1995 Ariz., ran 900 m • 2000 Tenn., ran 800 m • 2001 Fla., 1 hr. mat drill • 2004 Ohio, ran ~ 10 min. • 2005 Mo., 1 hr. field drill
Sickle Cell Trait Another “Do or Die” Syndrome • 1 in 12 blacks • 1 in 10,000 whites • Generally benign • No anemia • No barrier to top athleticism (e.g., NFL)
Sickling Deaths in Military • All deaths in basic training of 2 M. recruits in 5 yrs. ( NEJM 1987 ) • Risk of puzzling sudden death 28-40 times higher with sickle trait • 12 such deaths; all tied to exertion • Absolute risk: One in ~ 3,000
Air Force Cadets • 3 of 20,000: acute renal failure from rhabdo • All 3 sickle trait; all fit; one set record • 2 the same year, when just 10 had sickle trait
Death at Bowling Green Aaron Richardson, Died 9/15/04 • 3-sport HS athlete • Track champ, 100 to 400 m • Walked on for FB • Day 1, sprints for 10 min: cramps • Died, locker room • Autopsy: Sickling
Risk: All-out exertion for 2-3 minutes without a breather • Windsprints, e.g., 300-m repeats x 3-4 • Timed miles or half-miles • Running repeat hills, steps, ramps • Intense mat or conditioning drills • Accelerated weight lifting • Rarely, even in the game itself
Sickle Trait Precautions • No d. 1 fitness test • No sprints > 500 m • No timed miles • Regular fluids • Stop at 1 st sign of trouble • Report to trainer
Treatment: Presumed Sickling • Lie down • Oxygen by face mask • Vital signs • Immediate cooling • If not improved in 5 min., or if vital signs or alertness decline – Call 911, attach AED, start an IV, to ER fast
Conclusions • Salty sweating: key in heat cramping • Radiopills: can prevent heatstroke? • If you lose weight: Drink more • If you gain weight: Drink less • If in doubt: Ice ’em down! • Mandatory testing and precautions for sickle cell trait!
Recommend
More recommend