can the stress tests be saved from greenwash
play

Can the stress tests be saved from greenwash? Brussels, 17 January - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Can the stress tests be saved from greenwash? Brussels, 17 January 2012 Public meeting Post-Fukushima stress tests peer review Jan Haverkamp Greenpeace the stress tests general concerns no assessment of off-site emergency response - we


  1. Can the stress tests be saved from greenwash? Brussels, 17 January 2012 Public meeting Post-Fukushima stress tests peer review Jan Haverkamp Greenpeace

  2. the stress tests general concerns no assessment of off-site emergency response - we need a third track! the security track seems inadequate

  3. the peer-reviews general concerns 1. National regulators hijacked the peer-review system and undermined its credibility 2. Can you think the unthinkable? 3. Can you live up to your own standards?

  4. the peer-reviews general concerns 4. Can you raise the next issues? - emergency operation rooms - adequacy of seismic data - autarky of 10 hours - “fore-seeing” events - radioactive water run-off - liquidators - ageing

  5. the peer-reviews general concerns 5. Can you call the bluff? - comparison with earlier assessments 6. Can you clear out the fog? - airplane crashes

  6. the peer-reviews some concrete issues 7. Lack of a true secondary containment. 8. Multi-reactor failure or multi-installation failure 9. Mobile generators and pumps

  7. transparency issues - no national public seminars when it mattered - refusal of access to the operator reports - reports lack proper sourcing of data - no independent NGO or academic experts - no transparency on how suggestions taken up - today: too limited input from the audience - peer-review team lists? - we need better possibilities for NGO and other independent experts' input

  8. conclusions > too much business as usual! > too little information for decision makers > some decision makers already satisfied? IT IS NOT TOO LATE YOU ARE THE LAST CHANGE TO PREVENT GREENWASH

  9. Thank you! jan.haverkamp@greenpeace.org

Recommend


More recommend