A WEEK TO REMEMBER THE IMPACT OF BROWSER WARNING STORAGE POLICIES - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jun 02, 2023 •243 likes •650 views

A WEEK TO REMEMBER THE IMPACT OF BROWSER WARNING STORAGE POLICIES JOEL WEINBERGER & ADRIENNE PORTER FELT When someone clicks through an HTTPS warning, how long should the browser store that decision for? WHY DO WE CARE? REAL FALSE

A WEEK TO REMEMBER THE IMPACT OF BROWSER WARNING STORAGE POLICIES JOEL WEINBERGER & ADRIENNE PORTER FELT
When someone clicks through an HTTPS warning, how long should the browser store that decision for?
WHY DO WE CARE?
REAL FALSE ATTACK: ALARM: forget the save the decision decision as soon as as long as possible possible
REAL FALSE ATTACK: ALARM: forget the save the decision decision as soon as as long as possible possible
REAL FALSE ATTACK: ALARM: forget the save the decision decision as soon as as long as possible possible
WHICH STORAGE POLICY SHOULD CHROME USE?
NO CLEAR CONSENSUS Chrome 44 Windows Browser session Firefox 44 Windows Permanent (or session) Safari 9 Mac Browser session Safari 9 iOS Permanent UC Browser 10 Android Browser session UC Browser 2 iOS Permanent Edge 20 Windows Browser session UC Mini 10 Android Never
a good policy should reduce the cost of a mistake & number of false alarms
a good policy should reduce the cost of a mistake & number of false alarms
a good policy should reduce the cost of a mistake & number of false alarms
HOW DO PEOPLE REACT TO DIFFERENT STORAGE POLICIES?
6 EXPERIMENTAL GROUPS
ADHERENCE RATE Rate at which people heed the warning’s advice
EFFECT ON ADHERENCE
REGRET RATE Rate at which people change their minds about a warning
EFFECT ON REGRET
CORRELATED RATES
CHOOSING A RATE Session 1 Day 3 days 1 week 1 month 3 months Adherence 56.35% 63.96% 66.82% 69.88% 74.38% 75.28% Regret 15.98% 15.67% 17.35% 20.59% 25.56% 25.86% Δ Regret - -0.31 1.37 4.61 9.58 9.88
CHOOSING A RATE Session 1 Day 3 days 1 week 1 month 3 months Adherence 56.35% 63.96% 66.82% 69.88% 74.38% 75.28% Regret 15.98% 15.67% 17.35% 20.59% 25.56% 25.86% Δ Regret - -0.31 1.37 4.61 9.58 9.88
the one-week policy is working well in practice
ALSO CLEAR DECISION IF: 1. User asks to forget 2. User clears browsing history 3. Client sees a valid chain
4 LESSONS LEARNED
1. Storage policies have a large effect on adherence
EFFECT IN CONTEXT
EFFECT IN CONTEXT
EFFECT IN CONTEXT
EFFECT IN CONTEXT
2. Storage policies account for difference between Chrome & Firefox
CHROME & FIREFOX
CHROME & FIREFOX
CHROME & FIREFOX
CHROME & FIREFOX
CHROME & FIREFOX
3. Storage policies are confusing
4. Researchers & browsers should study storage policies
A WEEK TO REMEMBER THE IMPACT OF BROWSER WARNING STORAGE POLICIES JOEL WEINBERGER & ADRIENNE PORTER FELT

Recommend

Red Ribbon Week October 23-31 You may remember the events of this commemorative week from

Red Ribbon Week October 23-31 You may remember the events of this commemorative week from elementary school Red Ribbons that you wore during the week, the bookmark contest, people like me coming to your class to talk. I would like to

320 views • 10 slides

HEALTHCARE WHAT ? REMEMBER WHEN? REMEMBER WHEN HEALTHCARE WAS AFFORDABLE? REMEMBER WHEN

HEALTHCARE WHAT ? REMEMBER WHEN? REMEMBER WHEN HEALTHCARE WAS AFFORDABLE? REMEMBER WHEN GAS WAS .25/GAL RENT WAS $92/MTH ANNUAL WAGES WAS $4,600 AVERAGE HOME COST $12,750 HEALTHCARE PER CAPITA WAS $134 Forbes In 1958 , per

705 views • 36 slides

This week, we are going to look at adding words ending in the suffix al. Can you remember what

This week, we are going to look at adding words ending in the suffix al. Can you remember what a suffix is? A suffix is a letter or group of letters added at the end of a root word that creates a new word with a different meaning. How

453 views • 14 slides

We Remember Holy Week A resource for schools and families in the Parramatta Diocese. 3-6 We

We Remember Holy Week A resource for schools and families in the Parramatta Diocese. 3-6 We gather together to pray Find a quiet space and a quiet place in your heart and in your mind I light a candle, I say a

528 views • 17 slides

COSC 2P91 Lets Python Some More! Week 8a Brock University Brock University (Week 8a)

COSC 2P91 Lets Python Some More! Week 8a Brock University Brock University (Week 8a) Lets Python Some More! 1 / 16 Remember Python? Lets all remember Python for a moment Weve gotten a basic look at the syntax (primarily in the

755 views • 16 slides

Remember (1849) By Christina Rossetti Remember me when I am gone away, Gone far away into the

Remember (1849) By Christina Rossetti Remember me when I am gone away, Gone far away into the silent land; When you can no more hold me by the hand, Nor I half turn to go yet turning stay. Remember me when no more day by day You tell me of

232 views • 6 slides

Administrative notes Labs this week: project time. Remember, you need to pass the project in

Administrative notes Labs this week: project time. Remember, you need to pass the project in order to pass the course! (See course syllabus.) We are still unable to upload clicker grades and are waiting for help from UBC IT on this.

804 views • 49 slides

Public awareness campaigns Remember A Charity week 'Below the line' public facing activity -

Public awareness campaigns Remember A Charity week 'Below the line' public facing activity - digital, social Government Solicitors/professional advisors

1.38k views • 121 slides

Announcements Remember that class is cancelled for Thursday, March 22nd Midterm 2 is a week from

Announcements Remember that class is cancelled for Thursday, March 22nd Midterm 2 is a week from Thursday The midterm will cover everything since the first midterm up to and including todays lecture In terms of the syllabus: sections V, VI

474 views • 30 slides

Flip-Flop One-bit Memory Something to Remember What I Remember D Q Remember Now! What I

Flip-Flop One-bit Memory Something to Remember What I Remember D Q Remember Now! What I Remember Q Chapter 5 Edge-Triggered 1 3 CSc 314 T W Bennet Mississippi College CSc 314 T W Bennet Mississippi College State

660 views • 14 slides

Remember her disobedience. Remember her disobedience. Remember her righteous husband.

Remember her disobedience. Remember her disobedience. Remember her righteous husband. So then each one of us will give an account of himself to God. - Romans 14:12 For we must all appear before the judgment seat of

291 views • 13 slides

This week, we are again looking at synonyms and antonyms. Can you remember what synonyms and

This week, we are again looking at synonyms and antonyms. Can you remember what synonyms and antonyms are? A synonym is a An antonym is a word that has the word that has the synonym antonym same (or nearly opposite meaning the same)

336 views • 11 slides

This week, we are starting to look at synonyms and antonyms. Can you remember what synonyms and

This week, we are starting to look at synonyms and antonyms. Can you remember what synonyms and antonyms are? A synonym is a An antonym is a word that had the word that has the synonym antonym same (or nearly opposite meaning the same)

256 views • 14 slides

to remember your essentials. S W I F T C O. 2 MEET JACKY. EVERYONE DEPENDS ON HER. KIDS WORK

to remember your essentials. S W I F T C O. 2 MEET JACKY. EVERYONE DEPENDS ON HER. KIDS WORK Mother of 3 Accountant Children Under 18 40 hrs/week HOUSEHOLD EVERYTHING Cooking & Cleaning IN BETWEEN 5-Person Family S W I F T C O.

506 views • 25 slides

COSC 2P91 Objects with class Week 8b Brock University Brock University (Week 8b) Objects with

COSC 2P91 Objects with class Week 8b Brock University Brock University (Week 8b) Objects with class 1 / 14 Before we begin Wanna see a neat trick? Remember the conundrum of how to swap the contents of two variables without using a third

422 views • 14 slides

zazen Water Ambassador Program The Secret of Water Week 2 Hydration & Dehydration

zazen Water Ambassador Program The Secret of Water Week 2 Hydration & Dehydration GRADES 3 to 5 Week 2 presentation 1 zazen Water Ambassador Program www.waterambassador.com Lets remember last weeks lesson Week 2

279 views • 17 slides

Fri., 20 Nov. 2015 Projects Remember, progress report due Nov. 30 Remember, your project

Fri., 20 Nov. 2015 Projects Remember, progress report due Nov. 30 Remember, your project requires a formal report in addition to programs Today: some last words about Haskell (particularly aspects of the language that occur in other

361 views • 13 slides

3. Verbal What People Remember About Us What % . . . how we look? a) 22% b) 55% c) 91%

Powerful Presentations Making that 1 st Impression 1. Visual 2. Vocal 3. Verbal What People Remember About Us What % . . . how we look? a) 22% b) 55% c) 91% b) 55% What People Remember About Us What % . . how we sound? a) 8% b)

149 views • 14 slides

Organizational matters Remember to register for final exam in HISPOS Lecture on 27 November

Organizational matters Remember to register for final exam in HISPOS Lecture on 27 November is cancelled Schedule is pushed one week down The DL for Topic IVs essay is still 12 February Essay topics are given two weeks before

762 views • 45 slides

Remember/ Awareness Arrangements Experience Review Remember/ Awareness Arrangements

Remember/ Awareness Arrangements Experience Review Remember/ Awareness Arrangements Experience retell IT and the Business The shake-up is the culmination of weeks of mounting pressure from customers, politicians and investors.

639 views • 36 slides

THE PRESENTAT THE PRESENTATION OF ION OF we remember Trinity Church in Mike Harber, Vestry

Ser erving ing Thi his Week Week EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE EPIPHANY Betty and Jimmy Weldon, Ushers Lavonne Hart, Altar Guild Betty Weldon, Lay Reader Lavonne Hart, Lay Eucharistic Minister Caleb Hart, Pianist Esther Hart, Violinist Amanda

57 views • 3 slides

Time Matters Week 7 Week 6 Prototyping + Needfinding Week 7 Week 8 Implementation Week 9

Time Matters Week 7 Week 6 Prototyping + Needfinding Week 7 Week 8 Implementation Week 9 Week 10 User Testing + Debugging + Final Prep User Experience http://cogs121.ucsd.edu/schedule/ UX: Interaction Cost Interaction cost: any

415 views • 18 slides

8/23/2016 Remember The Cross I know Ive forgotten this before Remember The

8/23/2016 Remember The Cross I know Ive forgotten this before Remember The Cross Remembering God: The Passover meal 1 8/23/2016 Remember The Cross Remembering Gods faithfulness: The Passover Exodus 12:3, 5a

465 views • 8 slides

www. velpaprojects .com Finishing your property the VELPA way Time plan Week 1 - 4 Week 5 - 8

www. velpaprojects .com Finishing your property the VELPA way Time plan Week 1 - 4 Week 5 - 8 Week 9 - 12 Week 13 - 17 Week 18 - 22 Week 23 - 27 Site Preparation Construction and alterations Electrical Plumbing Floor Screeding

426 views • 5 slides