Your DNA, Your Say Global public views on sharing genomic data - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Mar 06, 2023 •319 likes •526 views

Your DNA, Your Say Global public views on sharing genomic data Anna Middleton Richard Milne 1 Global public survey To understand attitudes and concerns related to the sharing of DNA and health information 37,000 completed samples,

Your DNA, Your Say Global public views on sharing genomic data Anna Middleton Richard Milne 1
Global public survey To understand attitudes and concerns related to the sharing of DNA and health information 37,000 completed samples, ‘representative’ public recruited via Dynata (global market research company) 22 countries 15 languages 2
Headline findings ● Local data, focus on pulling out UK policy implications ● Global patterns ○ Familiarity ○ Trust ○ Harms
Familiarity with genetics - Familiar - willingness to donate (WTD) overall (global) OR 1.85 [1.71;2.00] - Personal - global WTD OR 2.87 [2.37; 3.09] - - Stated familiarity is low (35.2% in UK, 12.5 - 58% of respondents, highest in Italy and USA) - How are people familiar?
5
7
Donating to whom?
Trust - Trust is important in understanding why people are willing to donate and to whom - Overall trust OR 3.85 [3.34 - 4.44] - Directed trust also important (e.g. trust in companies WTD OR 3.96 [3.29; 4.75] - Who is trusted? - Who trusts? - What might help people have trust?
51.6% 46.5% 39.6% 40.2% 14
Harms - What are people concerned about happening as a result of their DNA/health information being accessed? - Who is concerned about what?
Conclusions - Familiarity with DNA/genetics is important - Most stated familiarity comes from interest in genealogy - Willingness to donate associated with who uses data and who is trusted - UK concerns greatest around company (mis)use of data - Corresponds with lack of trust - Clear focus on who benefits and how would complement existing research ethics principles
Next steps Complete and publish meta-analyses related to trust, harm Extend publication of policy-relevant reports for national/regional groups
It couldn’t have happened without……. PI Collaborators for Each Country/Translation Participant Values Task Team Natasha Bonhomme Anna Middleton Arabic: Haytham Sheerah, Mohamed Almarri Erika Kleiderman Mandarin: Yali Cong Barbara Prainsack Project Management French: Heidi C Howard Heidi Howard Lauren Robarts Australian: Christine Critchley, Dianne Nicol Emilia Niemiec S. African: Shelley Macaulay, Tasha Wainstein, Amanda Krause Erick Scott Data Analysis German: Barbara Prainsack, Torsten Voigt Jason Bobe Richard Milne Natalie Banner Urdu (Pakistan and India): Q Annie Hassan Katherine Littler Kate Morley Icelandic: Vígdis Stefansdottir Nadia Kovalevskaya Italian: Deborah Mascalzoni, Virginia Romano, Maria Gnadl Chiara Garattini Sanger Web team Japanese: Jusaku Minari Laura Rodriguez James Smith Polish: Emilia Niemiec Elissa Levin Paul Bevan Portuguese: Álvaro Mendes, Cláudia de Freitas Christoph Schickhardt Claire Stead Danya Vears Russian: Vera Izhevskaya, Elena Baranova, Alena Fedotova, Cris Woolston Nadia Kovalevskaya Films Spanish: Anne West, Maria Cerezo REWS Tim Pope Swedish: Heidi C Howard, Josephine Fernow Adrian Thorogood Loudcity Ghana: Jerome Atutornu Bartha Knoppers Madeleine Murtagh Funding Wellcome: Audrey Duncanson Connecting Science: Julian Rayner GA4GH: Peter Goodhand

Recommend

Center for Genomic Gastronomy Hacker Culture Creating and sharing with each other Placing

Center for Genomic Gastronomy Hacker Culture Creating and sharing with each other Placing a high value on freedom of inquiry; hostility to secrecy Information-sharing as both an ideal and a practical strategy Upholding the right to

549 views • 15 slides

ACTIVATING THE HUMAN RIGHT TO SCIENCE Big Data and the responsible sharing of genomic and

ACTIVATING THE HUMAN RIGHT TO SCIENCE Big Data and the responsible sharing of genomic and health-related data Professor Bartha Maria Knoppers Director, Centre of Genomics and Policy Canada Research Chair in Law and Medicine McGill University

644 views • 47 slides

Sharing Genomic (and Other) Data: The Perspective of the Kaiser Secretarys Permanente

Sharing Genomic (and Other) Data: The Perspective of the Kaiser Secretarys Permanente Research Program Advisory on Genes, Environment and Committee on Genetics, Health Health and Society February 4, 2010 Catherine Schaefer, PhD

282 views • 12 slides

Existing and Emerging Information Technologies that Affect Genomic Data Sharing Joyce A.

Existing and Emerging Information Technologies that Affect Genomic Data Sharing Joyce A. Mitchell, PhD Associate Vice President, Health Sciences IT Professor and Chair, Dept of Biomedical Informatics University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT

364 views • 25 slides

Public Health and Genomic Medicine: How do we get from here to there? Key Areas Enhancing

Public Health and Genomic Medicine: How do we get from here to there? Key Areas Enhancing genomic literacy for all health care practitioners, and their patients (S. Cox) The promise of genomics in clinical practice: Separating fact from

509 views • 12 slides

1993 Internet & TCP/IP Not yet dreamed of Starting a Genomic Internet Simple, real-time,

1993 Internet & TCP/IP Not yet dreamed of Starting a Genomic Internet Simple, real-time, global network for sharing somatic cancer data and associated clinical information Users Researchers, Clinicians, Pharma, Data Analysts, Citizen

705 views • 25 slides

Genomic Medicine Implementation in Diverse Healthcare Settings and Populations A Public Health

Genomic Medicine Implementation in Diverse Healthcare Settings and Populations A Public Health Perspective Muin J. Khoury MD, PhD CDC Office of Public Health Genomics Outline Exploring the Intersection of Genomic (and Precision) Medicine,

495 views • 26 slides

Implementing clinical genomic sharing, security and governance What is the patients'

Implementing clinical genomic sharing, security and governance What is the patients' perspective? Kate Birch Data & Technology Program Manager @kate__birch Melbourne Genomics Health Alliance 2 Melbourne Genomics Health Alliance

648 views • 32 slides

GM6: International efforts and opportunities in Genomic Medicine Total attendance > 250

GM6: International efforts and opportunities in Genomic Medicine Total attendance > 250 > 30 countries Why this topic? Genomic medicine is global Genome hubs: US, India, China, Japan, Korea, Canada There is

318 views • 13 slides

Genomic Predictors of Clinical Outcome in Gastric Cancer : The Singapore Experience Patrick Tan,

Genomic Predictors of Clinical Outcome in Gastric Cancer : The Singapore Experience Patrick Tan, MD PhD gmstanp@duke-nus.edu.sg Global Leaders in Genomic Medicine Conference Washington DC Jan 2014 Biomedical Sciences (BMS) in Singapore

398 views • 17 slides

Genomic Knowledge Standards (GKS) genomicsandhealth.org Genomic Knowledge Standards GKS aims

Genomic Knowledge Standards (GKS) genomicsandhealth.org Genomic Knowledge Standards GKS aims to develop, adopt, and adapt standards to enable the exchange of genomic knowledge Establish framework of standards that lower barriers to

223 views • 4 slides

Genomic Prediction and Selection for Multi-Environments with Big Data using the BGLR statistical

Genomic Prediction and Selection for Multi-Environments with Big Data using the BGLR statistical package Biometrics and Statistics Unit, Global Maize and Wheat programs June, 2015. CIMMyT Genomic Prediction and Selection for Multi-Environments

471 views • 26 slides

A KENYAN PERSPECTIVE Presentation at the Global Dialogue on Benefit Sharing Out line of the

BENEFIT SHARING SCHEMES: A KENYAN PERSPECTIVE Presentation at the Global Dialogue on Benefit Sharing Out line of the Presentation Policy Context in the country Our understanding of Benefit Sharing Specific examples of Benefit

339 views • 9 slides

Using the genomic relationship matrix to predict the accuracy of genomic selection M.E. Goddard

J. Anim. Breed. Genet. ISSN 0931-2668 ORIGINAL ARTICLE Using the genomic relationship matrix to predict the accuracy of genomic selection M.E. Goddard 1,2 , B.J. Hayes 2 & T.H.E. Meuwissen 3 1 Department of Agriculture and Food Systems,

627 views • 13 slides

Privacy in the Genomic Era XiaoFeng Wang, IUB http://www.informatics.indiana.edu/xw7 Genomic

Privacy in the Genomic Era XiaoFeng Wang, IUB http://www.informatics.indiana.edu/xw7 Genomic Revolution Fast drop in the cost of genome-sequencing 2000: $3 billion Mar. 2014: $1,000 Genotyping 1M variations: below $200

460 views • 15 slides

Recycling of Glass from Construction & Building Demolition Waste Views from the flat glass

Recycling of Glass from Construction & Building Demolition Waste Views from the flat glass industry Niels Schreuder Public Affairs AGC Glass Europe AGC corporate profile AGC Glass Europe AGC Group a global company Global annual

575 views • 25 slides

Benita Matofska Sharing Economy Expert Comparison marketplace for the Sharing Economy What We

Benita Matofska Sharing Economy Expert Comparison marketplace for the Sharing Economy What We Know About the Global Sharing Economy The first comprehensive overview of data on the Sharing Economy from around the world First piece of living

428 views • 15 slides

Views 2 Designing the user interface Roy Scholten hi Views . Views 2 Views 2 have you heard

Views 2 Designing the user interface Roy Scholten hi Views . Views 2 Views 2 have you heard of it? Views 2 have you heard of it? (views 1) Problem: How to avoid the humongous scrolling form of death? ping Huh? Inventory round 1:

952 views • 76 slides

Predicting Cancer Phenotypes from Somatic Genomic Alterations via Genomic Impact Transformer

Predicting Cancer Phenotypes from Somatic Genomic Alterations via Genomic Impact Transformer Yifeng Tao 1 , Chunhui Cai 2 , William W. Cohen 1,* , Xinghua Lu 2,3,* 1 School of Computer Science, Carnegie Mellon University 2 Department of Biomedical

743 views • 19 slides

Next generation genomic analysis for next generation healthcare GENOMIC SEQUENCING | RAPIDLY

Next generation genomic analysis for next generation healthcare GENOMIC SEQUENCING | RAPIDLY FALLING PRICES 2003 2018 In 1990, Congress established funding for the Human Genome Project. The project ended up costing about $2.7 billion in FY

389 views • 27 slides

AICH GROUP OF COMPANIES EXPERIENCE SHARING ON PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND VIEWS ON A

AICH GROUP OF COMPANIES EXPERIENCE SHARING ON PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND VIEWS ON A APPRENTICESHIP TRAINING PRESENTED BY INDRANIL AICH MANAGING DIRECTOR AICH GROUP OF COMPANIES 1 Venue: Thakur College of Engg &

652 views • 32 slides

Finding a Better Way: Genomic Distinctiveness Kyle B. Brothers Genomics and Ethics in Research

Finding a Better Way: Genomic Distinctiveness Kyle B. Brothers Genomics and Ethics in Research and Medical Decision-Making Cincinnati, OH March 13, 2015 Debates over genomic exceptionalism Overview Clinical analogies Genomic

523 views • 39 slides

Cross-Jurisdictional Sharing of Public Health Services: Some Financial Considerations Matt

Cross-Jurisdictional Sharing of Public Health Services: Some Financial Considerations Matt Stefanak Sharing Services Learning Community San Diego, CA January 23, 2014 Key financial questions about services sharing What level of resources are

204 views • 18 slides

GOVERNANCE OF GLOBAL MOON EXPLORATION AND SETTLEMENT: : S SHARING BENEFITS WIT ITH DEVELOPING

GOVERNANCE OF GLOBAL MOON EXPLORATION AND SETTLEMENT: : S SHARING BENEFITS WIT ITH DEVELOPING COUNTRIES. FADAHUNSI-BANJO MOTOLANI DEBORAH NATIONAL SPACE RESEARCH AND DEVLOPMENT AGENCY, NIGERIA. SEPTEMBER 8, 2020. GOVERNANCE OF GLOBAL MOON

352 views • 6 slides