Ultraefficient superconducting RF cavities for FCC Alexander Romanenko FCC Week 2015, Washington, DC 24 Mar 2015
Summary • Recent breakthroughs at Fermilab allow record Qs at gradients of interest to FCC in bulk Nb cavities – Nitrogen doping => record low BCS surface resistance, reduced non-flux residual – Tuning Meissner effect => no/low contribution from trapped magnetic flux => record low residual resistance • Cryo cost savings (capital and operating) is the main advantage • Thanks to LCLS-II at SLAC nitrogen doping has received a strong technological push to make it production-ready – Q and Eacc statistics on 9-cells • Doping of lower frequencies cavities shows a proof-or- principle for FCC – 650 MHz for PIP-II 2 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Nitrogen doping: a breakthrough in Q Record after nitrogen doping – up to 4 times higher Q! 11 10 This was the highest Q possible up to 2012 Since the discovery -> Q 0 10 10 Standard state-of-the art developed to production- preparation ready for LCLS-II within the context of high Q collaboration 1.3 GHz T= 2K (FNAL/Cornell/Jlab) 9 10 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 A. Grassellino et al, 2013 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 26 E acc (MV/m) 102001 (Rapid Communication) – highlights of 2013 3 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
N Doping – small deviation from standard ILC treatment A. Grassellino et al, 2013 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 26 102001 (Rapid Example from FNAL 2/6 doping process: Communication) • Bulk EP Ship to DESY Cavity after Equator Welding • 800 C anneal for 2 hours in vacuum HOM Tuning • 2 minutes @ 800C nitrogen diffusion EP 140 um X • 800 C for 6 minutes in vacuum 120C bake • Vacuum cooling Short HPR Leak Check • 5 microns EP XFEL External 20 um BCP Final Assembly Long HPR Ethanol Rinse VT Assembly 800C HT Bake Helium Tank Welding RF Tuning Procedure EP 40 um Long HPR Ethanol Rinse HPR 4 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
“Production” recipe for LCLS -II – 9-cells for prototype cryomodule(s) A. Crawford et al, IPAC’14, WEPRI062 Work in collaboration with Jlab and Cornell to demonstrate transfer and validation of best recipe 5 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Statistics for two doping recipes on 1.3 GHz 9-cells Recipe 2/6 16 MV/m 2.7e10 Data from FNAL/JLab <Q>=3.6e10 <E max >=22.2 MV/m E max median=22.8MV/m Recipe 20/30 Data from Cornell/Jlab/FNAL <Q>=3.24e10 <E max >=16.3 MV/m E max median=16.5MV/m 6 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Minimizing residual resistance (maximize Q) by avoiding the ambient magnetic flux to be trapped Same cavity, just cooled differently through 9.2K 10 4.0x10 10 3.8x10 10 Flux expelled 3.6x10 10 3.4x10 efficiently 10 3.2x10 10 3.0x10 10 2.8x10 10 2.6x10 Q 0 #1: First fast from 300K 10 2.4x10 #2: Slow from 15K 10 2.2x10 #3: Fast from 15K 10 2.0x10 10 1.8x10 Flux mostly 10 1.6x10 trapped 10 1.4x10 10 1.2x10 2K, 1.3 GHz 10 1.0x10 0 5 10 15 20 25 E acc (MV/m) 7 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Magnetic probes reveal the new physics Full expulsion of the It turns out the expulsion efficiency can be magnetic field should controlled by the cooldown procedure give ~2x higher field at (fast/slow, uniform or not) the equator in superconducting state Efficient flux expulsion Poor flux expulsion H Fluxgate magnetometers A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, O. Melnychuk, D. A. Sergatskov, J. Appl. Phys. 115 , 184903 (2014) 8 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Experimental proof that thermogradient at NC/SC interface is key parameter for flux expulsion A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, A. C. Crawford, D. A. Sergatskov, and O. Melnychuk, Appl. Phys. Lett. 105 , 234103 (2014) Temperature difference at the phase front (dT/dx) 9 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Differences between fast/slow Difference in geometry of transition A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, O. Melnychuk, D. A. Sergatskov, J. Appl. Phys. 115 , 184903 (2014) 10 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Observing fast and slow cooldown dynamics 11 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Fast and slow cooldown dynamics captured Slow from 12K Fast from 300K Top Bottom M. Martinello, M. Checchin - PhD work 12 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
• Fast cooldown 13 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 14
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 15
Equator Iris Sx Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 16
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 17
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 18
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 19
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 10.03 10.80 11.57 8 12.35 13.13 13.90 Board Number 15 14.68 15.45 16.23 22 17.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 20
Equator Iris Sx Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.825 10.40 10.98 8 11.55 12.13 12.70 Board Number 15 13.27 13.85 14.43 22 15.00 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer Number 21
• Slow cooldown – encircling normal areas 22 Alexander Romanenko | FCC Week 2015 3/24/15
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 23
Equator Iris Sx Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 24
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 25
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 26
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 27
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 28
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 29
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 30
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 31
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 32
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 33
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 6 9.415 9.470 11 9.525 9.580 Board Number 16 9.635 9.690 21 9.745 9.800 26 31 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 34
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 35
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 36
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 37
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 38
Iris Sx Equator Iris Dx 9.250 1 9.305 9.360 9.415 8 9.470 9.525 9.580 Board Number 15 9.635 9.690 9.745 22 9.800 29 36 1 4 7 10 13 16 Thermometer number 39
Recommend
More recommend