monitoring medical devices
play

Monitoring Medical Devices: Missed Warning Signs Within Existing - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 12, 2023 •25 likes •395 views

Monitoring Medical Devices: Missed Warning Signs Within Existing Data Andrew M. Ibrahim MD, MSc House Officer IV | Department of Surgery Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholar INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE POLICY University of Michigan &

  1. Monitoring Medical Devices: Missed Warning Signs Within Existing Data Andrew M. Ibrahim MD, MSc House Officer IV | Department of Surgery Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholar INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE POLICY University of Michigan & INNOVATION Academy Health Surgical & Perioperative Care Interest Group June 24 th , 2017 | New Orleans, Louisiana

  2. MONITORING MEDICAL DEVICES Limitations of FDA How HSR Can Rise & Fall of the Device Monitoring Support FDA Gastric Band Device INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  3. MONITORING MEDICAL DEVICES Limitations of FDA How HSR Can Rise & Fall of the Device Monitoring Support FDA Gastric Band Device INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  4. MONITORING MEDICAL DEVICES Limitations of FDA How HSR Can Rise & Fall of the Device Monitoring Support FDA Gastric Band Device INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  5. The Rise of Gastric Band Device… FDA Approval 2001 80,000 Devices Annually INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  6. Gastric-band Complications Requiring Reoperation Slippage Causing Obstruction Erosion into the Stomach Slipped band Myur et al. Obesity Surgery, 2005;(15)207-215 Kumar & Thompson. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2013;11(4):343-353 INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  7. INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  8. Gastric Band Device Reoperations of Medicare Payments 47 % for the Gastric Band Device were for REOPERATIONS INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  9. Restrict (or even Eliminate) Gastric- Band Use…. INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  10. Why Didn’t Our FDA Monitoring System Detect These Concerns Sooner? INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  11. Limitations of FDA Pre-Market Trials SMALL LIMITED “REAL” SAMPLE SIZE FOLLOW-UP PRACTICE INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  12. FDA Efforts to Improve Post-Market Surveillance INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  13. INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  14. FDA Post-Market Surveillance Limitations 1. Voluntary 2. Time Delays 3. Unknown Frequency INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  15. FDA Post-Market Surveillance Limitations 1. Voluntary 2. Time Delays 3. Unknown Frequency INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  16. FDA Post-Market Surveillance Limitations 1. Voluntary 2. Time Delays 3. Unknown Frequency INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  17. FDA Post-Market Surveillance Limitations 1. Voluntary 2. Time Delays 3. Unknown Frequency Solution? “…require unique device identifiers to be included in insurance claims.” INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  18. Device Specific Reoperation Codes Lap Band Related Reoperations (CPT Codes) Port Removal 43887 Port Revision 43886 Port Replacement 43888 Band Removal 43772, 43774 Band Revision 43771 Band Replacement 43659, 43773 Conversion to RNYGB (Lap) 43644, 43645, 43844 Conversion to RNGYB (Open) 43848 Conversion to Sleeve (Lap) 43775 INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  19. Gastric Band & Administrative Data • Free • Publically Available INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  20. Gastric Band & Administrative Data • National Inpatient Sample, 2006-2014 • 216,781 Gastric Band Procedures • $1.3 Billion – placement of device • $820 Million – revise or remove device INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  21. Annual Number of Gastric Band Device Procedures 40,000 35,000 Number of Procedures 30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 GASTRIC BAND PLACED 5,000 TOTAL 151,766 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year Gastric Band Placement INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  22. Annual Number of Gastric Band Device Procedures 40,000 35,000 Number of Procedures 30,000 25,000 DEVICE 20,000 REOPERATIONS TOTAL 15,000 70,932 10,000 GASTRIC BAND PLACED 5,000 TOTAL 151,766 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year Gastric Band Placement Device Reoperation INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  23. Annual Number of Gastric Band Device Procedures 40,000 FDA Expands Indications for Device Use 35,000 Number of Procedures 30,000 25,000 DEVICE 20,000 REOPERATIONS TOTAL 15,000 70,932 10,000 GASTRIC BAND PLACED 5,000 TOTAL 151,766 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year Ibrahim & Dimick. JAMA . June 2017 Gastric Band Placement Device Reoperation INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  24. Annual Number of Gastric Band Device Procedures 40,000 FDA Expands Indications for Device Use 35,000 Number of Procedures 30,000 Reoperations rates as low as 4%... 25,000 DEVICE “provide reasonable assurance of 20,000 REOPERATIONS TOTAL 15,000 safety and effectiveness.” 70,932 10,000 – FDA, Summary of Safety and Effectiveness Report, 2011 GASTRIC BAND PLACED 5,000 TOTAL 151,766 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year Ibrahim & Dimick. JAMA . June 2017 Gastric Band Placement Device Reoperation INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  25. Annual Payments for Gastric Band Device Procedures $350,000,000 $300,000,000 $250,000,000 Payments (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE REOPERATION $150,000,000 TOTAL $820 million $100,000,000 GASTRIC BAND $50,000,000 PLACEMENT TOTAL $1.3 billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device Reoperation Gastric Band Placement

  26. Annual Payments for Gastric Band Device Procedures Reoperations >30% of $350,000,000 Annual Payments $300,000,000 $250,000,000 Payments (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE REOPERATION $150,000,000 TOTAL $820 million $100,000,000 GASTRIC BAND $50,000,000 PLACEMENT TOTAL $1.3 billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device Reoperation Gastric Band Placement

  27. Annual Payments for Gastric Band Device Procedures Reoperations >30% of $350,000,000 Annual Payments Reoperations >50% of Annual Payments $300,000,000 $250,000,000 Payments (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE REOPERATION $150,000,000 TOTAL $820 million $100,000,000 GASTRIC BAND $50,000,000 PLACEMENT TOTAL $1.3 billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device Reoperation Gastric Band Placement

  28. Annual Payments for Gastric Band Device Procedures Reoperations >30% of $350,000,000 Annual Payments Reoperations >50% of Annual Payments Reoperations >90% of $300,000,000 Annual Payments $250,000,000 Payments (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE REOPERATION $150,000,000 TOTAL $820 million $100,000,000 GASTRIC BAND $50,000,000 PLACEMENT TOTAL $1.3 billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device Reoperation Gastric Band Placement

  29. Annual Payments for Gastric Band Device Procedures Reoperations >30% of $350,000,000 Annual Payments $300,000,000 Placement of 104,000 Devices $250,000,000 Payments (USD) ~$1 billion $200,000,000 DEVICE REOPERATION $150,000,000 TOTAL $820 million $100,000,000 GASTRIC BAND $50,000,000 PLACEMENT TOTAL $1.3 billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device Reoperation Gastric Band Placement

  30. Why not track Reoperations� >30%� of� $350,000,000 Annual� Payments Reoperations� >50%� of� Annual� Payments Reoperations� >90%� of� $300,000,000 Annual� Payments every devices in $250,000,000 (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE� Payments� REOPERATION� $150,000,000 TOTAL administrative $945� million $100,000,000 GASTRIC� BAND� $50,000,000 PLACEMENT� TOTAL claims? $1.3� billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device� Reoperation Gastric� Band� Placement INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  31. Why not track Reoperations� >30%� of� $350,000,000 Annual� Payments Reoperations� >50%� of� Annual� Payments Reoperations� >90%� of� $300,000,000 Annual� Payments every devices in $250,000,000 (USD) $200,000,000 DEVICE� Payments� REOPERATION� $150,000,000 TOTAL administrative $945� million $100,000,000 GASTRIC� BAND� $50,000,000 PLACEMENT� TOTAL claims? $1.3� billion $0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Device� Reoperation Gastric� Band� Placement The Codes Don’t Exist INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  32. Health Services Researchers and Monitoring Medical Devices INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  33. INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

  34. Acknowledgements Justin Dimick & the CHOP community. INSTITUTE FOR HEALTHCARE @andrewmibrahim POLICY & INNOVATION

Recommend

Regulation of software as medical devices When is software a medical device? Patrick L OMeley

Regulation of software as medical devices When is software a medical device? Patrick L OMeley

Regulation of software as medical devices When is software a medical device? Patrick L OMeley Devices Vigilance and Monitoring Post-market Surveillance Branch Monitoring and Compliance Division, TGA ARCS Scientific Congress 2015 7 May 2015

322 views • 16 slides
Increasing Post-Market Vigilance Requirements for Medical Devices Pam Carter Director Devices

Increasing Post-Market Vigilance Requirements for Medical Devices Pam Carter Director Devices

Increasing Post-Market Vigilance Requirements for Medical Devices Pam Carter Director Devices Vigilance and Monitoring, Medical Devices Branch Medical Devices and Product Quality Division, TGA 2017 ARCS Annual Conference August 2017

368 views • 33 slides
NEXUS Medical Devices USC I nitial Market Projections Definition of Medical Devices NEXUS

NEXUS Medical Devices USC I nitial Market Projections Definition of Medical Devices NEXUS

NEXUS NEXUS Medical Devices USC I nitial Market Projections Definition of Medical Devices NEXUS Diagnosis, prevention, monitoring, treatment or alleviation of a disease, an injury or a handicap. Investigation, replacement or

636 views • 22 slides
Towards Resiliency in Medical Monitoring Devices Homa Alemzadeh, Catello Di Martino, Zhanpeng

Towards Resiliency in Medical Monitoring Devices Homa Alemzadeh, Catello Di Martino, Zhanpeng

Towards Resiliency in Medical Monitoring Devices Homa Alemzadeh, Catello Di Martino, Zhanpeng Jin* Zbigniew T. Kalbarczyk, Ravishankar K. Iyer Coordinated Science Laboratory, University of Illinois at Urbana-Chgampaign *Department of

485 views • 23 slides
Revision of the EU legislation on medical devices and in vitro diagnostic medical devices IMDRF-4

Revision of the EU legislation on medical devices and in vitro diagnostic medical devices IMDRF-4

Revision of the EU legislation on medical devices and in vitro diagnostic medical devices IMDRF-4 Update on the revision of the MD regulatory framework in the European Union 20 March 2013 Nice Health and Consumers 26/9/2012: Medical devices

647 views • 18 slides
Medical Devices: how to stay included Annual Reports Catherine Looram Post-Market Investigator

Medical Devices: how to stay included Annual Reports Catherine Looram Post-Market Investigator

Medical Devices: how to stay included Annual Reports Catherine Looram Post-Market Investigator Device Vigilance and Monitoring Section Medical Devices Branch Therapeutic Goods Administration Learning outcomes At the end of this session it is

297 views • 26 slides
Roundtable Discussion on Clinical Evidence Reports Requirements For Medical Devices Dr Amanda

Roundtable Discussion on Clinical Evidence Reports Requirements For Medical Devices Dr Amanda

Roundtable Discussion on Clinical Evidence Reports Requirements For Medical Devices Dr Amanda Cuss Senior Medical Advisor Devices Clinical Section, Medical Devices Branch Medical Devices and Product Quality Division, TGA 2018 ARCS Annual

270 views • 8 slides
Potential reforms for the regulation of system and procedure pack medical devices Stakeholder

Potential reforms for the regulation of system and procedure pack medical devices Stakeholder

Potential reforms for the regulation of system and procedure pack medical devices Stakeholder Workshop Dr. Tania Ahmed Devices Conformity Assessment Section Medical Devices Branch Medical Devices & Product Quality Division 8 February 2019

614 views • 29 slides
Update from the Medical Devices Branch Use of market authorisation evidence from comparable

Update from the Medical Devices Branch Use of market authorisation evidence from comparable

Update from the Medical Devices Branch Use of market authorisation evidence from comparable overseas regulators / assessment bodies for medical devices Irina Tsyganova Director, Devices Applications and Verification Medical Devices Branch

398 views • 25 slides
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA Medical Devices Single Audit Program MDSAP -

zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA Medical Devices Single Audit Program MDSAP -

zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA Medical Devices Single Audit Program MDSAP - Overview and Update Keith M Smith Senior Adviser and MDSAP Assessor Quality Audits and Assessments Section Medical Devices Branch Medical Devices

576 views • 43 slides
General Information Medical devices are regulated by the FDAs Center for Devices and

General Information Medical devices are regulated by the FDAs Center for Devices and

11/5/2015 General Information Medical devices are regulated by the FDAs Center for Devices and Radiologic Health FDA resources for reporting on (CDRH). Oversight breaks into two general medical devices categories: premarket review and

388 views • 3 slides
Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Dr Elizabeth McGrath

Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Dr Elizabeth McGrath

Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Dr Elizabeth McGrath Director, Medical Devices Emerging Technologies Unit, Medical Devices Branch Mimi Chu-Gourlay Assistant Director, Medical Devices Reforms Unit, Medical

491 views • 11 slides
Investing in medical device safety: The importance of a functional Quality Management System Dr

Investing in medical device safety: The importance of a functional Quality Management System Dr

Investing in medical device safety: The importance of a functional Quality Management System Dr Kelly Tsang Devices Vigilance and Monitoring Section Medical Devices Branch Therapeutic Goods Administration 3 April 2018 ASBTE conference

111 views • 10 slides
Update on software as a medical device (SaMD) The TGA and IMDRF perspectives Patrick L OMeley

Update on software as a medical device (SaMD) The TGA and IMDRF perspectives Patrick L OMeley

Update on software as a medical device (SaMD) The TGA and IMDRF perspectives Patrick L OMeley Biomedical and Software Engineer Device Vigilance and Monitoring Section, Medical Devices Branch Medical Devices and Product Quality Division, TGA

1.29k views • 21 slides
Regulation of Medical Devices: a Regional approach IMDRF Meeting Working Group on Medical

Regulation of Medical Devices: a Regional approach IMDRF Meeting Working Group on Medical

Regulation of Medical Devices: a Regional approach IMDRF Meeting Working Group on Medical Devices Established in July, 2012 with 12 countries; currently with 14 OBJECTIVE: To strengthen the regulatory capacity for medical devices in

626 views • 13 slides
Interface between medicinal product and medical devices development - Update on EMA

Interface between medicinal product and medical devices development - Update on EMA

Interface between medicinal product and medical devices development - Update on EMA implementation of the new medical devices legislation Combined medicines and devices developments SME info day, 26 October 2018 Presented by Armin Ritzhaupt

592 views • 27 slides
Medical Devices Manufacturer Evidence and applications for inclusion in the ARTG Susan Barker

Medical Devices Manufacturer Evidence and applications for inclusion in the ARTG Susan Barker

Medical Devices Manufacturer Evidence and applications for inclusion in the ARTG Susan Barker Devices Application and Verification Section Medical Devices Branch Devices Sponsor Information Day 11 October 2017 Purpose Facilitate better

449 views • 43 slides
Custom-made medical devices Information for the dental industry Valerie Mercer Director Medical

Custom-made medical devices Information for the dental industry Valerie Mercer Director Medical

Custom-made medical devices Information for the dental industry Valerie Mercer Director Medical Devices Information and Education Medical Devices Branch Therapeutic Goods Administration ADIA industry briefing 12-13 July 2016 Discussion topics

534 views • 28 slides
Medical devices vs 6 Cardinal Health 12.4 6 Broadcom 15.5 6 Philips HealthTech 12.4 7

Medical devices vs 6 Cardinal Health 12.4 6 Broadcom 15.5 6 Philips HealthTech 12.4 7

2019/2/26 Context Challenges in the Design of Integrated Circuits for Wireless Power Delivery Medical devices vs Semiconductors industries and Information Transfer in How to develop a medical instrument, equipment, or device Implantable

287 views • 16 slides
Devices in the German Hospital Sector Oliver Martini Director Government Affairs & Policy

Devices in the German Hospital Sector Oliver Martini Director Government Affairs & Policy

Market Access Pathways for Medical Devices in the German Hospital Sector Oliver Martini Director Government Affairs & Policy Germany Medical Devices, Pharmaceuticals and Consumer Funding Pathways for Medical Devices Medical Devices

478 views • 13 slides
Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Part 2 Dr Elizabeth

Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Part 2 Dr Elizabeth

Session B19: Regulatory updates from the TGA Medical Devices Branch Part 2 Dr Elizabeth McGrath Director, Medical Device Emerging Tech | Medical Device Reform Program Mimi Chu-Gourlay Assistant Director, Medical Devices Reforms Unit,

413 views • 22 slides
J ob Monitoring MIB Need for monitoring print jobs in devices and servers Proposal for a new

J ob Monitoring MIB Need for monitoring print jobs in devices and servers Proposal for a new

Problem Statement J ob Monitoring MIB Need for monitoring print jobs in devices and servers Proposal for a new standards track status of print jobs project progress of print jobs Developed by Printer MIB participants accounting

187 views • 4 slides
Regulation of Personalised, including 3D Printed, Medical Devices Dr Elizabeth McGrath Acting

Regulation of Personalised, including 3D Printed, Medical Devices Dr Elizabeth McGrath Acting

Regulation of Personalised, including 3D Printed, Medical Devices Dr Elizabeth McGrath Acting Assistant Secretary Medical Devices Branch Therapeutic Goods Administration ARCS 22 August 2018 Australian Context Personalised devices currently

297 views • 27 slides
Medical Devices 101 An Educational Forum 26 August 2019 John Criscione, Ph.D. - Texas A&M

Medical Devices 101 An Educational Forum 26 August 2019 John Criscione, Ph.D. - Texas A&M

FDA Medical Device Industry Coalition Medical Devices 101 An Educational Forum 26 August 2019 John Criscione, Ph.D. - Texas A&M University Beckie Ellis - VP, RA/QA - Argon Medical Devices, Inc. William Shackelford, Supervisory CSO, ORA -

1.13k views • 102 slides

More recommend