6/9/2016 Forty AIM Attendees 2015 Years Total 350 of Child- • MD 46% birth…. • CNM 34% J T Parer • RN/NP 20% June, 2016 AIM Invited National Speakers 1976: Steven Gabbe 1995: Larry Gilstrap 2006: Alan Peaceman Thomas Moore 1983: Denys Court 2007: Michael Belfort Sturla Eik-Nes 1996: Robert Resnik David Lucchese Michael Socol 1985: Jef Ferguson 2008: Thomas Moore Kent Ueland 1997: Steven Gabbe Ronald Wapner Jack Schneider Michael Divon 2009: Michael Belfort 1986: EJ Quilligan 1998: John Hauth Dena Towner Michael Ross 1987: EJ Quilligan 2010: William Grobman Jon Weiss 1999: Thomas Benedetti Deborah Wing Quantitation of scholarship and Richard Depp 1988: Roger Freeman 2011: Brian Mercer Richard Depp 2000: Thomas Garite David Miller Steven Clark 1990: Frank Boehm 2012: Sean Blackwell academic achievement Tom Garite 2001: Thomas Goodwin Sarah Kilpatrick Tony Vintzileos 1991: Mike Nageotte 2013: Sean Esplin Roy Petrie 2002: Roger Newman Alison Cahill Deborah Wing 1992: Steve Clark 2014: Jeffrey Ecker EJ Quilligan John Morrison Kim Gregory 2003: Gary Hankins 1993: Roger Freeman 2015: George Saade John Huddleston 2004: Gary Dildy Cynthia Gyamfi Sarah Kilpatrick Bannerman 1994: Watson Bowes Manuel Porto 2005: Steve Caritis 2016: Deborah Wing Michael Nageotte Steven Clark Holly Kennedy 1
6/9/2016 Where are they now? • Journal Editors • Book Editors • Division Directors • Chairs • Deans • Chancellors • Presidents 2
6/9/2016 The Gold Standard in academia…. And how do we assess the quality or importance of these ….is publication of research scholarly journals? findings in scholarly journals By name dropping? "I had a patient a number of years ago, in Boston — I wrote about the case in the New England Journal of Medicine. It was a girl the same age as your patient here. She was walking to the university when someone shot her with a crossbow. The arrow entered at the outside edge of her left eyebrow and went straight through her head, exiting from almost the middle of the back of her neck." "And she survived?" 3
6/9/2016 By holding a Press Conference? How do we quantitate the value of the scholarly journals? • Most journals have an IF of 1-5, meaning that if they publish 100 papers in a 2 year Journal Impact Factor period, they are cited 100-500 times IF for 2015 = A/B • Online junk journals, proliferating and profitable, with dodgy peer-review, are A = number of papers published in the about IF 0.3, meaning…. Journal in 2013 & 2014 • Super journals, eg Nature, Science, Cell, B = number of times those papers were have IF ca 30 cited in indexed scholarly journals in • Some Chairs insist their Faculty achieve 2015 8 IFs per year 4
6/9/2016 The online journals, open access, “peer reviewed” with page charges up to $1000 • Titles with variations on the theme of For NEJM, IF is 56 Obstetrics, Gynecology, International, Research, Open, Journal, Review…. (n=5000) So, if NEJM published 100 • Consider “Cogent Medicine” (n=50,000) papers in 2013 & 2014, the Possible synonyms: Compelling, Conclusive, total citations for all of them Convincing, Decisive, Effective, Forceful, Persuasive, Satisfying, Strong, Telling…. was 5,600! • Add country of orign to title: n= 10 mill, or 10 7 N Engl J Med 2015; 373:2642-2653 December 31, 2015 N Engl J Med 2015; 373:2642-2653 December 31, 2015 Aaron B. Caughey, MD, PhD 5
6/9/2016 Mary E. Norton, MD J Midwifery Women's Health. 2007 May-Jun;52(3):308-9. 6
6/9/2016 7
6/9/2016 8
6/9/2016 In the next 40 years.... • The mathematics THANK YOU! • The objective evidence • The subjective evidence • The culture • The poetry • And the beauty…. ….OF THE BIRTH OF INFANTS 9
6/9/2016 N Engl J Med 2015; 373:2642-2653 December 31, 2015 10
Recommend
More recommend