kyiv arbitration days 2016 think big
play

KYIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2016: THINK BIG! The Confidence Complex - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Oct 14, 2022 •231 likes •325 views

KYIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2016: THINK BIG! The Confidence Complex Closed Lists or Freedom of Choice? Brussels / Dsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley /

  1. KYIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2016: THINK BIG! The Confidence Complex Closed Lists or Freedom of Choice? Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  2. The Confidence Complex 2 Confidence in whom? - the arbitrator? - the tribunal? - the institution? - the arbitration process? 2 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  3. Closed Lists -vs- Freedom of Choice The best way to avoid incidents of moral hazard is “… to forbid, or at least rigorously police, the practice of unilateral appointments …” “ The only decent solution … is thus that any arbitrator, no matter the size of the tribunal, should be chosen jointly or selected by a neutral body. ” “… a n institutional requirement that appointments be made from a pre-existing list of qualified arbitrators. …such a restricted list may have undeniable advantages…” 3 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  4. The call for closed lists Unilateral appointments are wrong : Appointing a nominee to help win the case is wrong No evidence that three heads are better than one Irrational for parties to have more confidence in arbitrator appointed for a special skill ‘Cultural’ appointments exacerbate moral hazard and are unnecessary Unanimity in awards is less likely to be achieved 4 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  5. The institutions 5 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  6. Freedom of choice • To arbitrate? • To choose system of law? • To choose seat of arbitration? • To choose the/its arbitrator 6 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  7. Against closed lists’ arguments • Perpetuates the very moral hazard argued against • Limits breadth of experienced arbitrators rather than broadening it • Wrongly assumes all participants appointments are ‘hired-guns’ • Ignores party autonomy – bedrock of arbitration’s credibility • Wrongly assumes closed list arbitrators will not be biased or poor judges • Wrongly assumes institutions’ knowledge is greater than their sum • Increases likelihood of repeat appointments due to limited pool • Disparaging of less-established institutions • Asserts that unilateral appointments increase dissenting judgements – but are dissenting judgements such a bad thing? 7 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

  8. Simon Sloane Partner - London E: Simon.Sloane@fieldfisher.com T: +44 (0)20 7861 4934 M: +44 (0)7341 566 854 8 Brussels / Düsseldorf / Hamburg / London / Manchester / Milan / Munich / Paris / Rome / Shanghai / Silicon Valley / fieldfisher.com

Recommend

Mandatory Rules of Law in International Arbitration: Ukrainian perspectives KYIV ARBITRATION

Mandatory Rules of Law in International Arbitration: Ukrainian perspectives KYIV ARBITRATION

Mandatory Rules of Law in International Arbitration: Ukrainian perspectives KYIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2015: Think Big! 5-6 November 2015, Kyiv Pavlo I. Byelousov Introduction What are mandatory rules? To provide a better understanding

400 views • 15 slides
or other illegality : Whats a tribunal (or counsel) to do? Scott Vesel Kyiv Arbitration Days

or other illegality : Whats a tribunal (or counsel) to do? Scott Vesel Kyiv Arbitration Days

Evidence obtained through corruption or other illegality : Whats a tribunal (or counsel) to do? Scott Vesel Kyiv Arbitration Days Kyiv, 5 November 2015 Overview Tribunals and evidence obtained unlawfully Tribunals discretion to

855 views • 13 slides
HACKED EVIDENCE - NOW WHAT? Kyiv Arbitration Days, 13 September 2019 Veronika Korom Solicitor,

HACKED EVIDENCE - NOW WHAT? Kyiv Arbitration Days, 13 September 2019 Veronika Korom Solicitor,

HACKED EVIDENCE - NOW WHAT? Kyiv Arbitration Days, 13 September 2019 Veronika Korom Solicitor, England & Wales Avocat au Barreau de Paris ESSEC Business School This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order

457 views • 8 slides
LOST IN IN C C ONFID IDENTIA IALIT ITY: How muc uch can you ou keep p un unde der the

LOST IN IN C C ONFID IDENTIA IALIT ITY: How muc uch can you ou keep p un unde der the

LOST IN IN C C ONFID IDENTIA IALIT ITY: How muc uch can you ou keep p un unde der the carpe pet? Kyiv Arbitration Days 2017: Think Big! Kyiv, 3 November 2017 Pa Pavlo Byelous ousov ov AEQUO Law Firm W hat all the confidentiality

815 views • 15 slides
KIEV ARBITRATION DAYS SHOW ME THE MONEY COLLECTION AND ENFORCEMENT TOM PRICE, PARTNER,

KIEV ARBITRATION DAYS SHOW ME THE MONEY COLLECTION AND ENFORCEMENT TOM PRICE, PARTNER,

KIEV ARBITRATION DAYS SHOW ME THE MONEY COLLECTION AND ENFORCEMENT TOM PRICE, PARTNER, GOWLING WLG, LONDON 3 NOVEMBER 2016 ENFORCEMENT OF AN INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION AWARD IN THE ENGLISH COURTS Enforcement is possible under the New

128 views • 10 slides
Party Autonomy and Choice of Law Vsevolod Volkov WWW.INTEGRITES.COM ROADMAP . Choice of Law.

Party Autonomy and Choice of Law Vsevolod Volkov WWW.INTEGRITES.COM ROADMAP . Choice of Law.

2015 Kyiv Arbitration Days Party Autonomy and Choice of Law Vsevolod Volkov WWW.INTEGRITES.COM ROADMAP . Choice of Law. International arbitration v. National courts. II. Party autonomy in light of choice of law. Vsevolod Volkov, Party

517 views • 23 slides
Preliminary issue hearings: Saving or wasting time and cash? Kiev Arbitration Days Boris

Preliminary issue hearings: Saving or wasting time and cash? Kiev Arbitration Days Boris

Preliminary issue hearings: Saving or wasting time and cash? Kiev Arbitration Days Boris Kasolowsky 3 November 2017 Vetting Procedure under ICC Rules Governed by the ICC Arbitration Rules . Articles 6(3) and 6(4) permit the Secretary

560 views • 7 slides
Astronomical observatory of National Taras Shevchenko university Kyiv, Ukraine

Astronomical observatory of National Taras Shevchenko university Kyiv, Ukraine

V. Danylevsky Astronomical observatory of National Taras Shevchenko university Kyiv, Ukraine vdanylevsky@gmail.com Astronomy and space physics in Kyiv university conference May 24 27, 2016 Kyiv, Ukraine Kyiv AERONET / PHOTONS site

397 views • 20 slides
Arbitration Clause Perth - 18 May 2016 Peter McQueen FCIArb www.amtac.org Overview What is

Arbitration Clause Perth - 18 May 2016 Peter McQueen FCIArb www.amtac.org Overview What is

Drafting an Effective Maritime Arbitration Clause Perth - 18 May 2016 Peter McQueen FCIArb www.amtac.org Overview What is international arbitration? What is an arbitration agreement? What are the essentials of an arbitration

354 views • 12 slides
What and whom can you trust in and why? 3 November 2016 Kiev Alexandre Khrapoutski Sysouev,

What and whom can you trust in and why? 3 November 2016 Kiev Alexandre Khrapoutski Sysouev,

KIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2016: THINK BIG! What and whom can you trust in and why? 3 November 2016 Kiev Alexandre Khrapoutski Sysouev, Bondar, Khrapoutski Law Office www.sbh--partners.com The confidence complex Trust in arbitration as a mechanism for

470 views • 30 slides
Struggle Against Secrecy Circumstantial Evidence and Presumptions Kiev Arbitration Days 2015:

Struggle Against Secrecy Circumstantial Evidence and Presumptions Kiev Arbitration Days 2015:

Struggle Against Secrecy Circumstantial Evidence and Presumptions Kiev Arbitration Days 2015: Think Big! Carol M. Welu Partner, London Corruption Definition * * Transparency International squirepattonboggs.com 2 "Safe Harbour for

370 views • 8 slides
The Emergency and its Arbitrator Efficient or Illusion? Kiev Arbitration Days 3 November

The Emergency and its Arbitrator Efficient or Illusion? Kiev Arbitration Days 3 November

The Emergency and its Arbitrator Efficient or Illusion? Kiev Arbitration Days 3 November 2017 James Castello Emergency Arbitrators Just a Fad? Emergency arbitrators appeared on the scene with remarkable swiftness: First

505 views • 26 slides
KIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2017: THINK BIG! Second Session : Where is your/my evidence? Disclosure

KIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2017: THINK BIG! Second Session : Where is your/my evidence? Disclosure

KIV ARBITRATION DAYS 2017: THINK BIG! Second Session : Where is your/my evidence? Disclosure and how not to put your cards on the table Carita Wallgren - Lindholm 3 November 2017 Disclosure and how not to put your cards on the table 1. Topic

330 views • 6 slides
Federal Labor Relations Authority 1 Comprehensive Arbitration Training August 3, 2016 Segment

Federal Labor Relations Authority 1 Comprehensive Arbitration Training August 3, 2016 Segment

Federal Labor Relations Authority 1 Comprehensive Arbitration Training August 3, 2016 Segment 1: 2 Introduction to Federal-Sector Arbitration & The Negotiated Grievance Procedure Private-Sector Arbitration 3 Submit unresolved

1.45k views • 127 slides
An Effective & Attractive Arbitration Seat Natalie L. Reid Fifth Annual Arbitration and

An Effective & Attractive Arbitration Seat Natalie L. Reid Fifth Annual Arbitration and

An Effective & Attractive Arbitration Seat Natalie L. Reid Fifth Annual Arbitration and Investment Summit Caribbean, Latin America, and Other Emerging Markets 30 January 2017 What is an arbitration seat? Legal home of

258 views • 6 slides
Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration The Asia-Pacific Regional Arbitration Group

Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration The Asia-Pacific Regional Arbitration Group

Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration The Asia-Pacific Regional Arbitration Group Conference 2016 Smrithi Ramesh Deputy Head of Legal Services Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration What is the KLRCA? The Kuala Lumpur

503 views • 23 slides
Use and abuse of anti-arbitration injunctions: strategies in dealing with anti-arbitration

Use and abuse of anti-arbitration injunctions: strategies in dealing with anti-arbitration

Use and abuse of anti-arbitration injunctions: strategies in dealing with anti-arbitration injunctions ASA Below 40 Seminar: Court assistance in international arbitration how to use it wisely and efficiently Anti-suit and anti-arbitration

359 views • 10 slides
Dr. Wolfgang Khn, Dsseldorf Full Recovery of Alternative Funding Costs, to be or not to be?

Dr. Wolfgang Khn, Dsseldorf Full Recovery of Alternative Funding Costs, to be or not to be?

Dr. Wolfgang Khn, Dsseldorf Full Recovery of Alternative Funding Costs, to be or not to be? Kiev Arbitration Days 2017 Kyiv, Ukraine 3 November 2017 Full Recovery of Alternative Funding Costs, to be or not to be? 1. The Issue 2. A Brief

131 views • 10 slides
ARBITRATION PRESENTATION QUESTIONS 1. TO COMPEL OR NOT TO COMPEL ARBITRATION The plaintiff

ARBITRATION PRESENTATION QUESTIONS 1. TO COMPEL OR NOT TO COMPEL ARBITRATION The plaintiff

ARBITRATION PRESENTATION QUESTIONS 1. TO COMPEL OR NOT TO COMPEL ARBITRATION The plaintiff church filed a complaint alleging claims for breach of contract arising from the purchase of a prefabricated steel building from the defendant. The

72 views • 6 slides
Webinar Presentation Tuesday 4 th August 2020 Arbitration: Principles and Practicalities The

Webinar Presentation Tuesday 4 th August 2020 Arbitration: Principles and Practicalities The

Webinar Presentation Tuesday 4 th August 2020 Arbitration: Principles and Practicalities The webinar today aims to provide an insight into the world of arbitration and, particularly, London maritime arbitration. Arbitration is the chosen method

436 views • 15 slides
PRACTICE PERSPECTIVES: InTERnATIonAl ARbITRATIon And lITIgATIon In THIS ISSUE Arbitration:

PRACTICE PERSPECTIVES: InTERnATIonAl ARbITRATIon And lITIgATIon In THIS ISSUE Arbitration:

PRACTICE PERSPECTIVES: InTERnATIonAl ARbITRATIon And lITIgATIon In THIS ISSUE Arbitration: Rapid, Inexpensive Resolution of International disputes Arbitration and Civil litigation in the Peoples Republic of China International litigation

471 views • 20 slides
Finnish Arbitration Act in light of the Model Law UN framework for international arbitration

Finnish Arbitration Act in light of the Model Law UN framework for international arbitration

UNCITRAL United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Finnish Arbitration Act in light of the Model Law UN framework for international arbitration Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards ("New

374 views • 15 slides
Settlement of China-Related M&A Disputes by Arbitration CEAC as an Alternative Arbitration

Settlement of China-Related M&A Disputes by Arbitration CEAC as an Alternative Arbitration

Chinese European Arbitration Centre Settlement of China-Related M&A Disputes by Arbitration CEAC as an Alternative Arbitration Institution? Dr Dominik Ziegenhahn Member of the Advisory Board of CEAC Vice President of the Chinese European

389 views • 19 slides
Arbitration Agreements in Employment Contracts After the Epic Decision Should You Require a

Arbitration Agreements in Employment Contracts After the Epic Decision Should You Require a

Arbitration Agreements in Employment Contracts After the Epic Decision Should You Require a Mandatory Arbitration Clause? September 12, 2018 Richard Moon Benjamin Ford Chris Lockman Background Federal Arbitration Act of 1925

660 views • 20 slides

More recommend