growth enhancing effect of openness to trade and
play

Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Dec 31, 2023 •9 likes •1.14k views

Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the effective transmission channel for Africa? Dramane Coulibaly a Blaise Gnimassoun a Valrie Mignon a a EconomiX-CNRS, University Paris Nanterre WIDER Development Conference:

  1. Motivation Trade, migration and income Ortega and Peri (2014): issue in the identification strategy of Frankel and Romer (1999) ◮ Theory: openness to migration may promote growth through an increase in total factor productivity reflecting growing diversity in productive skills caused by immigration. ⋆ The mobility of goods (trade) is not the sole vehicle of globalization through which geographic characteristics may impact income, there is also the mobility of people (migration) ◮ Empirical evidence on world sample: once geographic characteristics are used to instrument both trade and migration, there is no significant impact of trade, while a strong positive effect of migration. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 4/19

  2. Motivation Trade, migration and income Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 5/19

  3. Motivation Trade, migration and income The empirical study of Ortega and Peri (2014) does not account for the heterogeneity of countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 5/19

  4. Motivation Trade, migration and income The empirical study of Ortega and Peri (2014) does not account for the heterogeneity of countries This paper focuses on the specific case of Africa Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 5/19

  5. Motivation Trade, migration and income The empirical study of Ortega and Peri (2014) does not account for the heterogeneity of countries This paper focuses on the specific case of Africa ◮ Africa’s trade is mainly realized with developed countries, intra-continental trade is low Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 5/19

  6. Motivation Trade, migration and income The empirical study of Ortega and Peri (2014) does not account for the heterogeneity of countries This paper focuses on the specific case of Africa ◮ Africa’s trade is mainly realized with developed countries, intra-continental trade is low ◮ Strong intra-continental migration and emigration to industrialized countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 5/19

  7. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  8. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  9. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  10. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  11. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. ⋆ Africa can receive more benefit from trade with developed countries. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  12. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. ⋆ Africa can receive more benefit from trade with developed countries. Partner-varying impact of openness to migration Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  13. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. ⋆ Africa can receive more benefit from trade with developed countries. Partner-varying impact of openness to migration ◮ The theoretical channel (growing diversity in productive skills) of Ortega and Peri (2014) is not very relevant in the case of Africa: Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  14. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. ⋆ Africa can receive more benefit from trade with developed countries. Partner-varying impact of openness to migration ◮ The theoretical channel (growing diversity in productive skills) of Ortega and Peri (2014) is not very relevant in the case of Africa: ⋆ South-South perspective (intra-African migration): relative homogeneity of skill between immigrants and natives Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  15. Motivation Partner-varying impact of openness on African economies The impact of openness on African growth may depend on the type of partner Partner-varying impact of trade openness ◮ New trade theory = a country can obtain advanced technology from its trading partners through trade. ⋆ Africa can receive more benefit from trade with developed countries. Partner-varying impact of openness to migration ◮ The theoretical channel (growing diversity in productive skills) of Ortega and Peri (2014) is not very relevant in the case of Africa: ⋆ South-South perspective (intra-African migration): relative homogeneity of skill between immigrants and natives ⋆ North-South perspective (emigration to developed countries): two ambivalent effects on African economies, adverse effect of brain drain and positive effect of “diaspora transfers” (remittances, human capital of returning migrants, transfer of knowledge, transfer of norms in improving institutions) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 6/19

  16. Empirical strategy Model specification Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  17. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  18. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  19. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i ◮ T i and M i represent openness to trade and openness to migration with the world, respectively Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  20. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i ◮ T i and M i represent openness to trade and openness to migration with the world, respectively ◮ Pop i and Area i stand for population and area which capture the impact of country size Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  21. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i ◮ T i and M i represent openness to trade and openness to migration with the world, respectively ◮ Pop i and Area i stand for population and area which capture the impact of country size ◮ DistEqua i = distance from the equator to proxy for institutions’ quality (Hall and Jones, 1999; Rodriguez and Rodrik, 2000) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  22. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i ◮ T i and M i represent openness to trade and openness to migration with the world, respectively ◮ Pop i and Area i stand for population and area which capture the impact of country size ◮ DistEqua i = distance from the equator to proxy for institutions’ quality (Hall and Jones, 1999; Rodriguez and Rodrik, 2000) ◮ X i = set of control variables Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  23. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of total openness (with the world) lnY i = α 0 + α T T i + α M M i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ Y i =per capita income in country i ◮ T i and M i represent openness to trade and openness to migration with the world, respectively ◮ Pop i and Area i stand for population and area which capture the impact of country size ◮ DistEqua i = distance from the equator to proxy for institutions’ quality (Hall and Jones, 1999; Rodriguez and Rodrik, 2000) ◮ X i = set of control variables ◮ u i is the error term. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 7/19

  24. Empirical strategy Model specification Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  25. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  26. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  27. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries ◮ T S =trade openness with the subset S of partners Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  28. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries ◮ T S =trade openness with the subset S of partners ◮ M S = migration with the subset S of partners Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  29. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries ◮ T S =trade openness with the subset S of partners ◮ M S = migration with the subset S of partners ⋆ Intra-African=Immigration received by a African country from other African countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  30. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries ◮ T S =trade openness with the subset S of partners ◮ M S = migration with the subset S of partners ⋆ Intra-African=Immigration received by a African country from other African countries ⋆ Africa with non-industrialized countries: Immigration received by an African country from non-industrialized countries (including African countries) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  31. Empirical strategy Model specification Impact of openness with a subset of partners lnY i = α 0 + α S T T S i + α S M M S i + α P lnPop i + α A lnArea i + DistEqua i + β ′ X i + u i ◮ S may be the subset of African partners, the subset of partners among developing countries, or the subset of partners among industrialized countries ◮ T S =trade openness with the subset S of partners ◮ M S = migration with the subset S of partners ⋆ Intra-African=Immigration received by a African country from other African countries ⋆ Africa with non-industrialized countries: Immigration received by an African country from non-industrialized countries (including African countries) ⋆ Africa with industrialized countries: Emigration from an African country to industrialized countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 8/19

  32. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  33. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  34. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  35. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  36. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  37. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  38. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries ◮ Border = dummy variable to indicate whether countries i and j share a common border Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  39. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries ◮ Border = dummy variable to indicate whether countries i and j share a common border ◮ Colony = dummy for colonial relationship Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  40. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries ◮ Border = dummy variable to indicate whether countries i and j share a common border ◮ Colony = dummy for colonial relationship ◮ ComLang = dummy for sharing a common official language Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  41. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries ◮ Border = dummy variable to indicate whether countries i and j share a common border ◮ Colony = dummy for colonial relationship ◮ ComLang = dummy for sharing a common official language ◮ Comcur = dummy capturing the sharing of a common currency Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  42. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity regression lnW ij = γ 0 + γ 1 lnDist ij + γ 2 lnPop i + γ 3 lnPop j + γ 4 lnArea i + γ 5 lnArea j + γ 6 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) + γ 7 Border ij + γ 8 Colony ij + γ 9 ComLang ij + γ 10 Comcur ij + γ 11 Time ij + γ 12 lnDist ij × Border ij + γ 13 lnPop i × Border ij + γ 14 lnPop j × Border ij + γ 15 lnArea i × Border ij + γ 16 lnArea j × Border ij + γ 17 ( Landlocked i + Landlocked j ) × Border ij + e ij ◮ W ij = bilateral trade (exports + imports) between countries i and j divided by the GDP of origin country i , or bilateral immigration (emigration) the stock of migrants born in country j ( i ) and living in country i ( j ) as share of country i ’s population ◮ Dist ij = distance between country i and country j ◮ Pop and Area = population and area and are included to account for country size ◮ Landlocked = dummy variable for landlocked countries ◮ Border = dummy variable to indicate whether countries i and j share a common border ◮ Colony = dummy for colonial relationship ◮ ComLang = dummy for sharing a common official language ◮ Comcur = dummy capturing the sharing of a common currency ◮ Time ij =time zone differences between the two countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 9/19

  43. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  44. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  45. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  46. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  47. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  48. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade ◮ Instrument for Migration: ˆ exp (ˆ M i = � Γ M Z ij ) j � = i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  49. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade ◮ Instrument for Migration: ˆ exp (ˆ M i = � Γ M Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ ˆ Γ M =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for migration Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  50. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade ◮ Instrument for Migration: ˆ exp (ˆ M i = � Γ M Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ ˆ Γ M =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for migration Gravity-based predictor as instrument for openness with a subset of partners Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  51. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade ◮ Instrument for Migration: ˆ exp (ˆ M i = � Γ M Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ ˆ Γ M =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for migration Gravity-based predictor as instrument for openness with a subset of partners ◮ Instrument for Trade with a subset of partners: ˆ exp (ˆ T S i = � Γ T Z ij ) j ∈ S Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  52. Empirical strategy Gravity-based instruments Gravity-based predictor as instrument for total openness ◮ Instrument for Trade: ˆ exp (ˆ T i = � Γ T Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ Z =vector of explanatory variables in gravity regression ⋆ ˆ Γ T =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for trade ◮ Instrument for Migration: ˆ exp (ˆ M i = � Γ M Z ij ) j � = i ⋆ ˆ Γ M =vector of estimated coefficients in gravity regression for migration Gravity-based predictor as instrument for openness with a subset of partners ◮ Instrument for Trade with a subset of partners: ˆ exp (ˆ T S i = � Γ T Z ij ) j ∈ S ◮ Instrument for Migration with a subset of partners: ˆ exp (ˆ M S i = � Γ M Z ij ) j ∈ S Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 10/19

  53. Empirical strategy Estimation methods for gravity Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 11/19

  54. Empirical strategy Estimation methods for gravity Linear OLS estimator ☞ Linear Predicted (LP) gravity-based instrument Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 11/19

  55. Empirical strategy Estimation methods for gravity Linear OLS estimator ☞ Linear Predicted (LP) gravity-based instrument Non-linear Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) (Silva and Tenreyro, 2006) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 11/19

  56. Empirical strategy Estimation methods for gravity Linear OLS estimator ☞ Linear Predicted (LP) gravity-based instrument Non-linear Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) (Silva and Tenreyro, 2006) ◮ it allows to deal with observations of the dependent variable with zero value Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 11/19

  57. Empirical strategy Estimation methods for gravity Linear OLS estimator ☞ Linear Predicted (LP) gravity-based instrument Non-linear Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) (Silva and Tenreyro, 2006) ◮ it allows to deal with observations of the dependent variable with zero value ◮ heteroskedasticity-related issues. ☞ Non-Linear Predicted (NLP) gravity-based instrument Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 11/19

  58. Empirical strategy Data Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  59. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  60. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  61. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Bilateral migration from Docquier et al. (2010) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  62. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Bilateral migration from Docquier et al. (2010) Geographic variables from CEPII’s gravity database Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  63. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Bilateral migration from Docquier et al. (2010) Geographic variables from CEPII’s gravity database Dependent variable: Real PPP-adjusted GDP per person from Penn World Tables Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  64. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Bilateral migration from Docquier et al. (2010) Geographic variables from CEPII’s gravity database Dependent variable: Real PPP-adjusted GDP per person from Penn World Tables Population (World bank) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  65. Empirical strategy Data 200 countries in the world, including 52 African countries, year=2000 Bilateral trade from IMF Direction of Trade Statistics (DOTS) Bilateral migration from Docquier et al. (2010) Geographic variables from CEPII’s gravity database Dependent variable: Real PPP-adjusted GDP per person from Penn World Tables Population (World bank) Colonial controls from Acemoglu et al. (2001) Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 12/19

  66. Empirical results Impact of total openness (with the world) Dependent variable=log (income per capita) African openness with the world LP LP NLP NLP (1) (2) (3) (4) Trade 2.80** 0.45 3.89* 2.82 (1.37) (0.73) (2.00) (4.48) Immig. 1.13 9.16*** -4.14 18.62 (7.72) (2.87) (11.61) (16.83) Ln pop. -0.24 -0.23** -0.26 -0.15 (0.18) (0.11) (0.22) (0.22) Ln area 0.05 0.27** 0.06 0.44 (0.11) (0.12) (0.14) (0.45) Dist. equator 0.05*** -0.01 0.05*** 0.01 (0.01) (0.02) (0.02) (0.04) Constant 5.53*** 7.57*** 5.27*** 6.37*** (0.49) (0.60) (0.81) (1.91) Observations 52 44 52 44 Colonial controls No Yes No Yes Geo/climate controls No Yes No Yes K-P F-stat 0.81 4.30 0.77 0.13 SW F-stat for Trade 8.58 11.92 3.28 0.34 SW F-stat for Mig. 3.18 4.47 2.41 0.35 SY 10% max IV size 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 SY 25% max IV size 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 Notes: LP (NLP) = linear (non-linear) predicted trade and migration based on the OLS (PPML) gravity estimates. *, **, and *** denote significance at the 10%, 5% and 1% confidence level, respectively. K-P F- stat= Kleibergen and Paap (2006) rk Wald F-stat test of jointly weak identification. SW F-stat = Sanderson and Windmeijer (2015) F-stat test of weak identification for each endogenous regressor separately. SY 10% max IV size and SY 10% max IV size are the Stock and Yogo (2005) critical values. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 13/19

  67. Empirical results Identifying partner-varying impact of openness Dependent variable=log (income per capita) Intra-African Africa with non-industrialized countries LP LP NLP NLP LP LP NLP NLP (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) Trade 8.28 13.97 0.86 4.86 4.44 3.50 5.15 6.68*** (10.26) (13.00) (2.85) (3.90) (2.87) (3.40) (4.60) (2.92) Immig. 0.10 3.40 4.94 6.14 5.36 12.33** 6.80 6.21 (4.69) (4.56) (5.20) (4.03) (6.00) (5.22) (16.22) (10.34) Ln pop. -0.45** -0.39* -0.34** -0.27** -0.30* -0.15 -0.27 -0.24 (0.21) (0.22) (0.14) (0.13) (0.16) (0.14) (0.22) (0.19) Ln area 0.15 0.27 0.07 0.17 0.09 0.16 0.09 0.21* (0.16) (0.19) (0.10) (0.11) (0.11) (0.10) (0.14) (0.12) Dist. equator 0.05*** 0.06*** 0.05*** 0.06*** 0.06*** 0.07*** 0.06*** 0.07*** (0.02) (0.02) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) Constant 6.08*** 5.14*** 6.65*** 5.73*** 5.63*** 4.93*** 5.39*** 4.55*** (1.24) (1.25) (0.64) (0.62) (0.71) (0.95) (0.81) (1.06) Observations 52 50 52 50 52 50 52 50 Colonial/geo controls No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes K-P F-stat 0.953 0.847 6.171 4.468 1.814 2.123 0.225 3.337 SW F-stat for Trade 1.905 1.751 9.866 8.120 7.467 7.938 1.088 13.35 SW F-stat for Mig. 8.659 15.56 5.727 7.168 2.139 3.164 0.604 2.382 SY 10% max IV size 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 SY 25% max IV size 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 Notes: LP (NLP) = linear (non-linear) predicted trade and migration based on the OLS (PPML) gravity estimates. *, **, and *** denote significance at the 10%, 5% and 1% confidence level, respectively. K-P F- stat= Kleibergen and Paap (2006) rk Wald F-stat test of jointly weak identification. SW F-stat = Sanderson and Windmeijer (2015) F-stat test of weak identification for each endogenous regressor separately. SY 10% max IV size and SY 10% max IV size are the Stock and Yogo (2005) critical values. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 14/19

  68. Empirical results Identifying partner-varying impact of openness Dependent variable=log (income per capita) Africa with industrialized countries LP LP NLP NLP (1) (2) (3) (4) Trade 2.08** 3.42** 3.05*** 4.51*** (0.89) (1.38) (0.93) (1.43) Emig. 34.52** -2.21 16.16 -9.01 (16.45) (18.41) (11.04) (6.72) Ln pop. -0.26* -0.30** -0.25* -0.30** (0.15) (0.12) (0.15) (0.14) Ln area 0.29 0.12 0.15 0.08 (0.19) (0.13) (0.11) (0.10) Dist. equator 0.03* 0.04*** 0.04*** 0.05*** (0.02) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) Constant 4.86*** 5.79*** 5.46*** 5.85*** (1.10) (0.84) (0.52) (0.45) Observations 52 50 52 50 Colonial/geo controls No Yes No Yes K-P F-stat 3.738 1.695 9.923 4.850 SW F-stat for Trade 19.40 11.32 24.52 10.92 SW F-stat for Mig. 9.958 3.580 20.74 7.414 SY 10% max IV size 7.03 7.03 7.03 7.03 SY 25% max IV size 3.63 3.63 3.63 3.63 Notes: LP (NLP) = linear (non-linear) predicted trade and migration based on the OLS (PPML) gravity estimates. *, **, and *** denote significance at the 10%, 5% and 1% confidence level, respectively. K-P F-stat= Kleibergen and Paap (2006) rk Wald F-stat test of jointly weak identification. SW F-stat = Sanderson and Windmeijer (2015) F-stat test of weak identification for each endogenous regressor separately. SY 10% max IV size and SY 10% max IV size are the Stock and Yogo (2005) critical values. Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 15/19

  69. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  70. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  71. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  72. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  73. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  74. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  75. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital ⋆ A i = productivity term ; α =labor share in income Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  76. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital ⋆ A i = productivity term ; α =labor share in income � K i � α ◮ Production per worker lny i = + lnh i + ln ( A i ) ( 1 − α ) ln Y i Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  77. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital ⋆ A i = productivity term ; α =labor share in income � K i � α ◮ Production per worker lny i = + lnh i + ln ( A i ) ( 1 − α ) ln Y i ⋆ y i = Y i / L i = output per worker; h i = H i / L i =human capital per worker Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  78. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital ⋆ A i = productivity term ; α =labor share in income � K i � α ◮ Production per worker lny i = + lnh i + ln ( A i ) ( 1 − α ) ln Y i ⋆ y i = Y i / L i = output per worker; h i = H i / L i =human capital per worker ⋆ Human capital is assumed to be a function of returns to schooling as estimated in a Mincerian wage regression Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

  79. Empirical results The channels of growth-enhancing impact of trade with developed countries How trade with industrialized countries promote growth in Africa ? ◮ Transfer of technologies ? The Hall and Jones, 1999 output decomposition ◮ Production function Y i = K α i ( H i A i ) 1 − α ⋆ Y i =output in country i ; K i =physical capital; H i = human capital ⋆ A i = productivity term ; α =labor share in income � K i � α ◮ Production per worker lny i = + lnh i + ln ( A i ) ( 1 − α ) ln Y i ⋆ y i = Y i / L i = output per worker; h i = H i / L i =human capital per worker ⋆ Human capital is assumed to be a function of returns to schooling as estimated in a Mincerian wage regression ⋆ α = 1 / 3 in line with standard neoclassical approach Dramane Coulibaly - Growth-enhancing effect of openness to trade and migrations: What is the channel for Africa ? 16/19

Recommend

Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs NRC Headquarters

Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs NRC Headquarters

Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs NRC Headquarters Rockville, MD Sept 4, 2008; 9:30 a.m. 12 noon 1 AGENDA Welcome Patricia Trish Holahan, Director Division of Security Operations (DSO)

479 views • 14 slides
The role of trade openness and labour market institutions during global economic downturns Elisa

The role of trade openness and labour market institutions during global economic downturns Elisa

The role of trade openness and labour market institutions during global economic downturns Elisa Gamberoni (World Bank) Erik von Uexkull (ILO, Trade and Employment Programme) Sebastian Weber (HEID) presentation for the joint ILO GTFA

528 views • 13 slides
Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs Holly Springs Culture

Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs Holly Springs Culture

Enhancing Openness and Transparency in NRC Security Inspection Programs Holly Springs Culture Center Holly Springs, NC July 30, 2008; 5 pm 9 pm 1 AGENDA Welcome Paul W. Harris, Senior Program Manager Division Reactor Security

172 views • 14 slides
Trade without Borders Trade Effect of the 2004 EU Enlargement Cecilia Hornok Central European

Trade without Borders Trade Effect of the 2004 EU Enlargement Cecilia Hornok Central European

Trade without Borders Trade Effect of the 2004 EU Enlargement Cecilia Hornok Central European University 3rd FIW Research Conference, Vienna, 11 Dec 2009 Motivation The unexplained border effect trade barriers are large even among

406 views • 26 slides
G G Green growth and trade: Green growth and trade: th th d t d t d d the knowledge gap the

G G Green growth and trade: Green growth and trade: th th d t d t d d the knowledge gap the

G G Green growth and trade: Green growth and trade: th th d t d t d d the knowledge gap the knowledge gap Ronald Steenblik OECD Trade and Agriculture Green Growth Knowledge Platform, 12 13 January 2012 Green growth and trade Green growth

317 views • 14 slides
Enhancing Customs collaboration to Enhancing Customs collaboration to combat the trade in illegal

Enhancing Customs collaboration to Enhancing Customs collaboration to combat the trade in illegal

Enhancing Customs collaboration to Enhancing Customs collaboration to combat the trade in illegal timber Conference on Transnational Environmental Crime: f l l Illicit networks and enforcement networks, Australia National University, 15

416 views • 17 slides
Trade openness effects through price channels on firms informal employment: The case of

Trade openness effects through price channels on firms informal employment: The case of

Trade openness effects through price channels on firms informal employment: The case of Peru Trade openness effects through price channels on firms informal employment: The case of Peru Symposium: TRADE AND EMPLOYMENT IN

718 views • 60 slides
PubPol 201 Introduction to Trade and Trade Policy Module 3: International Growth of world

PubPol 201 Introduction to Trade and Trade Policy Module 3: International Growth of world

Class 1 Outline PubPol 201 Introduction to Trade and Trade Policy Module 3: International Growth of world and US trade Trade Policy The World Trade Organization (WTO) Regional trade agreements Class 1 US trade policies and

252 views • 7 slides
NIAGARA TRADE AND THE COVID-19 EFFECT MCMASTER FORUM EVENT #1 JUNE 17, 2020 NIAGARA TRADE

NIAGARA TRADE AND THE COVID-19 EFFECT MCMASTER FORUM EVENT #1 JUNE 17, 2020 NIAGARA TRADE

NIAGARA TRADE AND THE COVID-19 EFFECT MCMASTER FORUM EVENT #1 JUNE 17, 2020 NIAGARA TRADE CHARACTERISTICS Export values by destination: Total: $4.7B North America: $4.48B Europe: $82.3M Asia: $70.3M Oceania:

411 views • 9 slides
The Discriminatory Effect of Domestic Regulations on International Trade in Services: Evidence

The Discriminatory Effect of Domestic Regulations on International Trade in Services: Evidence

The Discriminatory Effect of Domestic Regulations on International Trade in Services: Evidence from Firm-Level Data Matthieu Crozet Emmanuel Milet Daniel Mirza December 16, 2013 Abstract In order to promote international trade in

710 views • 31 slides
Mare Geneticum and an EcoSystem Approach: Power, Openness and Sharing UNCLOS IGC2 GA 72/249

Mare Geneticum and an EcoSystem Approach: Power, Openness and Sharing UNCLOS IGC2 GA 72/249

Mare Geneticum and an EcoSystem Approach: Power, Openness and Sharing UNCLOS IGC2 GA 72/249 Profes essor A Abbe E e E. L. B Brown 28 March 2019 IP and trade secrets Confers exclusive right to control specific activities, for a

536 views • 7 slides
Enhancing research on trade in the CEFTA region 29 th and 30 th June 2018 Faculty of

Enhancing research on trade in the CEFTA region 29 th and 30 th June 2018 Faculty of

Policy options for liberalization of legal framework that regulates recognition of academic qualifications in CEFTA countries Nina Brankovic, University of Zagreb Enhancing research on trade in the CEFTA region 29 th and 30 th June 2018

442 views • 28 slides
Enhancing the Capacity of the Trade Policy Analysis and Development Agency (TREDA) TPSA

Enhancing the Capacity of the Trade Policy Analysis and Development Agency (TREDA) TPSA

Presentation by Rahayu Ningsih Trade Policy Analysis and Development Agency on Enhancing the Capacity of the Trade Policy Analysis and Development Agency (TREDA) TPSA Project Final Conference - June 26, 2019 Focus: Knowledge, Skills

377 views • 12 slides
Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 1 Bielefeld Graduate School of

Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 1 Bielefeld Graduate School of

Gains from Openness Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 1 Bielefeld Graduate School of Economics and Management, Germany June 1, 2016 Gains from Openness Overview Introduction Motivation Research Question

1.06k views • 28 slides
An Overview of British Trade Statistics, 1700-1899 David S. Jacks (Simon Fraser University and

An Overview of British Trade Statistics, 1700-1899 David S. Jacks (Simon Fraser University and

An Overview of British Trade Statistics, 1700-1899 David S. Jacks (Simon Fraser University and NBER) March 2011 In effect, this talk serves as a progress report for the NSF- funded project: Globalization and Growth: Lessons from British Trade

538 views • 25 slides
Openness Forum May 23-25, 2017 Kyiv, Ukraine UNCITRAL Perspective on Curbing Corruption

Openness Forum May 23-25, 2017 Kyiv, Ukraine UNCITRAL Perspective on Curbing Corruption

UNCITRAL United Nations Commission on International Trade Law 13 th Procurement Integrity Management and Openness Forum May 23-25, 2017 Kyiv, Ukraine UNCITRAL Perspective on Curbing Corruption Caroline Nicholas UNCITRAL Secretariat May 2017

435 views • 19 slides
CREATING GROWTH, ENHANCING LIVES 1 ABOUT SINGAPORE AN OVERVIEW OF SINGAPORE 2017 GDP (286 B)

CREATING GROWTH, ENHANCING LIVES 1 ABOUT SINGAPORE AN OVERVIEW OF SINGAPORE 2017 GDP (286 B)

OVERVIEW CREATING GROWTH, ENHANCING LIVES 1 ABOUT SINGAPORE AN OVERVIEW OF SINGAPORE 2017 GDP (286 B) Population S$447.3 Billion Mobile phone 5.6 penetration rate Million 3.6% S$79,697 105% 151% Real growth Capita GDP (

429 views • 27 slides
Pedro Noyola July 2015 Index A. Openness B. Integration and Competitiveness C. Competition

Pedro Noyola July 2015 Index A. Openness B. Integration and Competitiveness C. Competition

Beyond NAFTA: Framing the Future Landscape of the North American Economy Pedro Noyola July 2015 Index A. Openness B. Integration and Competitiveness C. Competition and Transparency D. The Future: Framing the Paradigm 2 Trade

183 views • 16 slides
TRADE, SERVICES AND DEVELOPMENT Enhancing productive capacity through services Geneva, 12 May

TRADE, SERVICES AND DEVELOPMENT Enhancing productive capacity through services Geneva, 12 May

UNCTAD Multi-year Expert Meeting on TRADE, SERVICES AND DEVELOPMENT Enhancing productive capacity through services Geneva, 12 May 2019 What determines productive capacity and export in developing countries: the services linkage by Mr.

1.14k views • 29 slides
Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 Gerald Willmann 2 1 Bielefeld

Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 Gerald Willmann 2 1 Bielefeld

Gains from Openness Gains from Openness with Heterogenous Firms Phemelo Tamasiga 1 Gerald Willmann 2 1 Bielefeld Graduate School of Economics and Management, Germany 2 Bielefeld University, Germany June 30, 2015 Gains from Openness Overview

562 views • 28 slides
The paradox of openness, accountability and trust in legislatures Meg Russell The Constitution

The paradox of openness, accountability and trust in legislatures Meg Russell The Constitution

The paradox of openness, accountability and trust in legislatures Meg Russell The Constitution Unit, University College London Wroxton workshop, 27-28 July 2019 Overview Openness: a foundational principle for legislatures The

330 views • 10 slides
IRTI Working Paper Series WP# 1435-09 Enhancing Intra-Trade in OIC Member Countries Through

IRTI Working Paper Series WP# 1435-09 Enhancing Intra-Trade in OIC Member Countries Through

IRTI Working Paper Series WP# 1435-09 Enhancing Intra-Trade in OIC Member Countries Through T-SDRs Mahmoud Sami Nabi, Rami Abdelkafi, Imed Drine, Sami Ibrahim Al-Suwailem 22 Jumada2 1435H | April 22, 2014 Islamic Economics and Finance

552 views • 19 slides
Enhancing Seed Trade Lessons from the Access to Seeds Index 2019 Bangalore, 19 October 2019 UN

Enhancing Seed Trade Lessons from the Access to Seeds Index 2019 Bangalore, 19 October 2019 UN

Enhancing Seed Trade Lessons from the Access to Seeds Index 2019 Bangalore, 19 October 2019 UN Agencies (2018): We are losing the fight against hunger and malnutrition, because of climate change Number of undernourished people 2005-2017

712 views • 17 slides
The Labor Market ADB-ILO-OECD Joint Conference: Trade and Employment in a Globalized World 10-11

The Labor Market ADB-ILO-OECD Joint Conference: Trade and Employment in a Globalized World 10-11

Market Openness & The Labor Market ADB-ILO-OECD Joint Conference: Trade and Employment in a Globalized World 10-11 December 2012 International Collaborative Initiative on Trade and Employment Douglas Lippoldt, Niny Khor, OECD Directorate

462 views • 17 slides

More recommend