Evaluation Summary Criteria Option Cost Regional Chico Environmental Impact Regional Chico Secondary Benefit Options Local Plant w/ Reuse Interagency Agreements Local Plant w/ Surface Discharge Public Impacts Regional Chico Operational Issues Regional Chico Right of way Local Plant w/ Surface Discharge
Scoring Outcome Option A (Local Plant & Land Application) = 48 Option B (Local Plant & Surface Discharge) = 57 Option C (Regional Chico WPCP Connection) = 67 Option D (Local Plant with Beneficial Reuse) = 50.5
Regional Chico Option - C Pros Cons Lowest Life-cycle Cost High Capital Cost Permitting for Crossings (Creek, Lower Public Impact Highway, Railroad) Lower Operational Cost and ROW Negotiations for Pipeline Legacy Lower Staffing Requirement
Local Plant w/Surface Discharge Option - B Pros Cons Lowest Capital Cost Higher Life-cycle Cost High Quality Discharge High Operational Cost Lower ROW Cost Higher Public Impact Long Term Discharge Permit Reuse Opportunities Legacy and Renewal Modular/Expandable Small Footprint
Recommend
More recommend