Communicating uncertainty about mig igration statistics David - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Oct 16, 2022 •175 likes •339 views

Communicating uncertainty about mig igration statistics David Spiegelhalter Chairman of the Winton Centre for Risk & Evidence Communication, University of Cambridge President, Royal Statistical Society Migration Statistics User Forum 2018

Communicating uncertainty about mig igration statistics David Spiegelhalter Chairman of the Winton Centre for Risk & Evidence Communication, University of Cambridge President, Royal Statistical Society Migration Statistics User Forum 2018
with Alex Freeman Anne Martha van der Bles Sarah Dryhurst
Baroness Onora O’Neill.. • Organisations should not be aiming to ‘increase trust’ • Rather, aim to demonstrate trustworthiness • Information should be • accessible • intelligible • useable • assessable
Epistemic uncertainty Can we communicate uncertainty about facts, numbers and science, in a trustworthy way?
Uncertainty about statistics
Uncertainty about statistics
Uncertainty about statistics
Uncertainty about statistics
Uncertainty about statistics
February 2018 Inflation report • ONS do not provide ‘error’ on GDP
Randomised trial of communicating epistemic uncertainty • Topics: • Number unemployed, • Tigers in India, • Global temperature change • Format : • Estimate • Range • Verbal qualifier, • Trust/credibility : in number and source • Design: Online panel, between-person, 1126 participants
August 2018 report Only visualises sampling error Quality issues as verbal caveats
Plans for Winton Centre • Continue collaboration with ONS on communicating uncertainty • Conducting interviews for user requirements • Evaluate alternative formats

Recommend

Uncertainty Session 6 PMAP 8921: Data Visualization with R Andrew Young School of Policy Studies

Uncertainty Session 6 PMAP 8921: Data Visualization with R Andrew Young School of Policy Studies May 2020 1 / 38 Plan for today Communicating uncertainty Visualizing uncertainty 2 / 38 Communicating uncertainty 3 / 38 The Bay of Pigs

656 views • 38 slides

Uncertain Information Simon French simon.french@warwick.ac.uk Outline Uncertainty Count

Presenting and Communicating Uncertain Information Simon French simon.french@warwick.ac.uk Outline Uncertainty Count (and confuse!) the meanings Uncertainty in the early phase Results from an ADMLC project Discussion Uncertainty What

614 views • 23 slides

lessons learned in communicating weather and climate uncertainty Jason Samenow, Capital Weather

Challenges and lessons learned in communicating weather and climate uncertainty Jason Samenow, Capital Weather Gang The Washington Post April 15, 2016 About the Capital Weather Gang Washington Posts weather team One full-time

641 views • 25 slides

Uncertainty AIMA Chapter 13 Outline Uncertainty Uncertainty Probability Syntax and

Uncertainty Uncertainty AIMA Chapter 13 Outline Uncertainty Uncertainty Probability Syntax and Semantics Inference Independence and Bayes Rule Uncertainty Uncertainty Let action A t = leave for airport t minutes before

999 views • 46 slides

UNCERTAINTY IN KNOWLEDGE Ch. 9 Uncertainty in Knowledge 1 Sources of Uncertainty

UNCERTAINTY IN KNOWLEDGE Ch. 9 Uncertainty in Knowledge 1 Sources of Uncertainty Uncertainty in problem solving can be attributed to Imperfect domain knowledge Imperfect case data Experts employ inexact methods for two

605 views • 31 slides

Uncertainty and its Representa/on @kordinglab Uncertainty ma7ers

Uncertainty and its Representa/on @kordinglab Uncertainty ma7ers The brain is good with uncertainty Measure world + uncertainty Derive op/mal behavior

240 views • 11 slides

Communicating results with R&Shiny Mika Mkinen Introduction 1. Communicating results (not

PHUSE 2016 DV02 Communicating results with R&Shiny Mika Mkinen Introduction 1. Communicating results (not only producing outputs) 2. Cases from a real study 3. Visualization concept Motivation for interactive & better

740 views • 24 slides

Communicating feedback and assessment Dr Joanna Tai and Dr Naomi Winstone Communicating

Communicating feedback and assessment Dr Joanna Tai and Dr Naomi Winstone Communicating assessment rationales Which two of these assessments are least familiar to you? Essay Research report Presentation MCQ Exam Portfolio

369 views • 19 slides

Communicating Rewards: Where we go wrong and how we can improve Tom Raftery Director

Communicating Rewards: Where we go wrong and how we can improve Tom Raftery Director Compensation & Benefits Forum 19 June 2012 Dubai What are you communicating about your reward system? Problem of communicating rewards

208 views • 16 slides

Communicating Critical Events: Communicating Critical Events: CEO Transitions and Risk to

Communicating Critical Events: Communicating Critical Events: CEO Transitions and Risk to Enterprise Value FTI Consulting | Strategic Communications Practice October 2011 1 Global leadership transitions Research objective & methodology

838 views • 26 slides

Uncertainty 10 AI Slides (5e) c Lin Zuoquan@PKU 2003-2019 10 1 10 Uncertainty 10.1

Uncertainty 10 AI Slides (5e) c Lin Zuoquan@PKU 2003-2019 10 1 10 Uncertainty 10.1 Uncertainty 10.2 Probability Syntax and semantics Inference Independence Bayes rule 10.3 Bayesian networks 10.4 Probabilistic reasoning

1.38k views • 102 slides

Developing & Communicating Your Employee Benefit Program Developing & Communicating Your

Developing & Communicating Your Employee Benefit Program Developing & Communicating Your Employee Benefit Program Scott Smith : Executive Vice President- National Practice Leader/Employee Benefits at SS Nesbitt and Company

607 views • 34 slides

Economic and technology uncertainty and implications for policy advise Fr ed eric Babonneau

Methods and models Uncertainty and role of CCS in abatement strategies Uncertainty on other drivers New methods to tackle uncertainty analysis for energy/climate policy Publications Economic and technology uncertainty and implications for

847 views • 27 slides

Decision Making Privacy-Motivated . . . under Uncertainty: Uncertainty Leads to . . .

Quantitative . . . The Notion of Utility Traditional Approach: . . . Need for Distributed . . . Decision Making Privacy-Motivated . . . under Uncertainty: Uncertainty Leads to . . . Uncertainty in . . . Algorithmic Approach Uncertainty in

668 views • 62 slides

Reasoning with Uncertainty C h a p t e r 13 1 Outline Uncertainty Probability

Reasoning with Uncertainty C h a p t e r 13 1 Outline Uncertainty Probability Syntax and Semantics Inference Independence and Bayes Rule 2 The real world is an uncertain place... Example: I need a plan that will get

744 views • 38 slides

Can you trust your models uncertainty? Evaluating Predictive Uncertainty Under Dataset Shift

Can you trust your models uncertainty? Evaluating Predictive Uncertainty Under Dataset Shift Yaniv Ovadia*, Emily Feruig*, Jie Ren, Zachary Nado, D Sculley, Sebastian Nowozin, Joshua Dillon, Balaji Lakshminarayanan, Jasper Snoek Uncertainty?

677 views • 19 slides

Uncertainty Chapter 13 Chapter 13 1 Outline Uncertainty Probability Syntax and

Uncertainty Chapter 13 Chapter 13 1 Outline Uncertainty Probability Syntax and Semantics Inference Independence and Bayes Rule Chapter 13 2 Uncertainty Let action A t = leave for airport t minutes before flight Will A t

689 views • 34 slides

Hi Hierarchical Models for hi l M d l f Quantifying Uncertainty in Quantifying Uncertainty in

Hi Hierarchical Models for hi l M d l f Quantifying Uncertainty in Quantifying Uncertainty in Human Health Risk/Safety Assessment Ralph L. Kodell, Ph.D. Department of Biostatistics University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences Little Rock,

600 views • 33 slides

VISUALIZING UNCERTAINTY Fall 2017 Mac Hill VISUALIZING UNCERTAINTY 2 DEVELOPING A VISUAL

Thesis Proposal VISUALIZING UNCERTAINTY Fall 2017 Mac Hill VISUALIZING UNCERTAINTY 2 DEVELOPING A VISUAL VOCABULARY FOR UNCERTAINTY How can the design of information visualizations commonly found in news media coverage incorporate

591 views • 20 slides

Decision Making Under Uncertainty Making Decisions Under Uncertainty AI C LASS 10 (C H .

Todays Class Decision Making Under Uncertainty Making Decisions Under Uncertainty AI C LASS 10 (C H . 15.1-15.2.1, 16.1-16.3) Tracking Uncertainty over Time Decision Making under Uncertainty sensors Decision Theory ?

229 views • 8 slides

The Uncertainty Principle in Einstein Gravity Gaetano Vilasi Universit degli Studi di Salerno,

Quantum Mechanics and Einstein Gravity The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle The Uncertainty Principle in Newton Gravity, (DA) The Uncertainty Principle in Einstein Gravity, (DA) The Uncertainty Principle and Einstein Gravity The photon

772 views • 58 slides

Measurement Uncertainty - Error & Uncertainty Measurement errors are impossible to avoid

Instrumentation (and Error & Process Control) Uncertainty Fall 1393 Bonab University Error Measurement Uncertainty - Error & Uncertainty Measurement errors are impossible to avoid We can minimize their magnitude by Good

307 views • 26 slides

Using Social Science Research to Overcome Challenges Communicating HTE FDA and JHU-CERSI:

Using Social Science Research to Overcome Challenges Communicating HTE FDA and JHU-CERSI: Assessing and Communicating Heterogeneity of Treatment Effects (HTE) for Patient Subpopulations: Challenges and Opportunities November 28, 2018 Paula

267 views • 8 slides

The Role of Expert Knowledge in Uncertainty Quantification (Are We Adding More Uncertainty (Are

Army Conference on Applied Statistics Santa Fe, NM October 25, 2001 The Role of Expert Knowledge in Uncertainty Quantification (Are We Adding More Uncertainty (Are We Adding More Uncertainty or More Understanding?) or More Understanding?)

374 views • 21 slides