arXiv:1107.5012v2 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 4 Jan 2012 a Department of - PDF document

Effective field theory and tunneling currents in the fractional quantum Hall effect Samuel Bieri a,b , J¨ ohlich b urg Fr¨ arXiv:1107.5012v2 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 4 Jan 2012 a Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA b Institute for Theoretical Physics, ETH Z¨ urich, 8093 Z¨ urich, Switzerland Abstract We review the construction of a low-energy effective field theory and its state space for “abelian” quantum Hall fluids. The scaling limit of the incompressible fluid is described by a Chern-Simons theory in 2+1 dimensions on a manifold with boundary. In such a field theory, gauge invariance implies the presence of anomalous chiral modes localized on the edge of the sample. We assume a simple boundary structure, i.e., the absence of a reconstructed edge. For the bulk, we consider a multiply connected planar geometry. We study tunneling processes be- tween two boundary components of the fluid and calculate the tunneling current to lowest order in perturbation theory as a function of dc bias voltage. Particu- lar attention is paid to the special cases when the edge modes propagate at the same speed, and when they exhibit two significantly distinct propagation speeds. We distinguish between two “geometries” of interference contours corresponding to the (electronic) Fabry-Perot and Mach-Zehnder interferometers, respectively. We find that the interference term in the current is absent when exactly one hole in the fluid corresponding to one of the two edge components involved in the tunneling processes lies inside the interference contour (i.e., in the case of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer). We analyze the dependence of the tunneling current on the state of the quantum Hall fluid and on the external magnetic flux through the sample. Keywords: fractional quantum Hall effect, edge current interferometry, dissipationless charge transport, Chern-Simons action, topological field theory, chiral anomaly Email addresses: sbieri@mit.edu (Samuel Bieri), juerg@itp.phys.ethz.ch (J¨ urg Fr¨ ohlich) Preprint submitted to Elsevier July 25, 2011

1. Introduction The theory of the integral and fractional quantum Hall effect (QHE) has quite a long history; see, e.g., [1]. In [2] and in [3, 4], certain topological Chern-Simons theories in 2+1 dimensions have been introduced that are shown to describe the (long-distance and low-energy) scaling limit of the bulk of an incompressible Hall fluid. The proposals in [2–4] have led to the idea of “topological order” and of “universality classes” describing the scaling limits of different incompressible Hall fluids; see, e.g., [5]. More recently, ideas adapted from the theory of the quantum Hall effect have led to a fascinating branch of condensed matter theory that concerns topological order and topological phases of matter exhibiting universal properties in a broader context; [6]. On the experimental side, after the initial discovery of the quantum Hall effect by von Klitzing et al. [7], the next major breakthrough was the discovery of the fractional effect by Tsui, St¨ ormer, and Gossard in 1982, [8]. However, only in recent years, experiments testing mesoscopic aspects of incompressible Hall fluids related, e.g., to the famous edge currents and tunneling properties have become possible; see [9–14]. Recent experiments probe fractional quantum Hall states by performing transport measurements involving (the tunneling of) edge currents and interference effects. It appears to be prohibitively difficult to rigorously identify the appropriate universality class describing a quantum Hall state realized in the laboratory from microscopic quantum many-body theory. For this reason, recent experimental ac- tivities are crucially important in that they yield evidence for the correct choice of an effective field theory describing a concrete incompressible state correspond- ing to some plateau of the Hall conductance. In order to interpret experimental data and come up with the correct choice, it is important to work out detailed properties of the topological field theories describing the bulk of incompressible Hall fluids and of the effective field theories [15–18] describing the degrees of free- dom located on the edges of incompressible fluids and, in particular, of the chiral currents circulating along the edges of such fluids. Thus, the aim of our paper is, on one hand, to present a detailed account of the construction of effective field theories and their state spaces describing abelian incompressible quantum Hall fluids in the scaling limit. This part of the paper is partly a review of results that have been established in previous work; (see [15] and refs. given there). A fairly broad description of the underlying physical principles, which we will rely upon in the following, has been given in [15]. The present paper extends previous ones by the emphasis it places on the role of gauge invariance and on the structure of superselection sectors encountered in the effective theories of Hall edges in the presence of slowly varying external electromagnetic fields and of essentially static, localized quasi-particles in the bulk of a sample. On the other hand, using these results, we present a general 2

analysis of certain charge transport properties related to the degrees of freedom at the edge of an incompressible Hall fluid. Our explicit formulae may be useful to interpret experimental data. Our results are general enough to be applicable to a description of an arbitrary incompressible Hall fluid supporting quasi-particles with abelian fractional (or braid) statistics. Actually, many of our general ideas easily extend to fluids supporting quasi-particles with non-abelian braid statistics, too. 1.1. Structure of the paper This paper is organized in the following way. In Sect. 2, we review the general construction of an effective field theory in 2+1 dimensions describing the low- energy and long-distance physics of an abelian quantum Hall fluid. In this section, we profit from an introduction to the subject contained in the review paper [15]; (readers not familiar with the subject are encouraged to consult that paper or some of the refs. given there). 1 We then discuss the constraints on the physical state space of topological field theories describing electron fluids exhibiting the quantum Hall effect. In Section 3, we discuss the boundary terms in the effective action describing an incompressible Hall fluid. The gauge anomaly of the Chern-Simons theory calls for massless (non-topological) field theories in 1+1 dimensions localized on the edge of the sample. We construct vertex operators creating gapless quasi- particles propagating along the edge of an incompressible fluid and we discuss the superselection sectors of the edge theory. Section 4 is devoted to charge transport through tunneling constrictions be- tween disjoint boundary components within the framework of the previous two sections. We construct gauge invariant tunneling operators and calculate explic- itly the inter-edge tunneling current to lowest order in perturbation theory. We argue that the appropriate initial state for perturbation theory is a superposition of states in different charge superselection sectors for the two boundary compo- nents involved in the transport. This averaging, due to the fractional electric charge of the tunneling quasi-particle, leads to the absence of an interference term in the tunneling current for some geometries of interference contours. We also discuss the effect of time-dependent modifications of the sample caused by external agents on charge transport through the sample. We find that an adia- batic increase of the flux of the external magnetic field through the interference contour does not lead to any measurable signature (“Aharonov-Bohm phase”) in the tunneling current. However, changing the magnetic flux through the in- terference contour by deforming the edges or dragging bulk quasi-particles out 1 Many references to the original literature are omitted in the present paper but can be found in [15]. 3