The Science And Economics Of Sustainability: Managing the Competing Uses of Land, Water, and Forests Under a Changing Climate John P. Holdren Teresa & John Heinz Professor of Environmental Policy and Professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences Harvard University Director, The Woods Hole Research Center Keynote Address Global Katoomba Meeting “Developing an Infrastructure Fund for the Planet” Washington DC • 9 -10 June 2008
Environment, well-being, & sustainability Human well-being rests on three pillars: • economic conditions and processes – such as jobs, income, wealth, markets, trade • sociopolitical conditions and processes – such as law & order, national & homeland security, democracy, justice, education, a social safety net, culture & the arts, freedom of religion… • environmental conditions and processes – such as air, water, soils, mineral resources, the biota, nutrient cycles, climatic processes…
Environment…& sustainability (continued) Arguments about which one of the three pillars is “most important” are pointless, because... • Each is indispensable: failure in any one can undermine the human enterprise. • The three are interconnected: – the economy needs environmental inputs & sociopolitical stability – sociopolitical stability cannot survive economic or environmental disaster.
Some definitions • Development: improving the human condition in all its aspects, not only economic but also sociopolitical and environmental. • Sustainable development: doing so by means and to end points consistent with maintaining the improved conditions indefinitely.
Getting to sustainability entails… • Not only achieving well- being where it’s now absent with sustainable development • But also putting the maintenance & expansion of well- being where it’s now present onto a sustainable basis. We are far from doing either…and moving much too slowly on both.
Getting to sustainability: the 4 biggest challenges • Eradicating poverty & preventable disease • Maintaining the integrity of the oceans under increased demands & impacts • Managing the intensifying competition for land, water, and terrestrial biota while preserving essential biodiversity • Providing the energy needed to create & sustain prosperity everywhere without wrecking global climate
These challenges are interconnected • Poverty & local environmental degradation are linked in a vicious circle of cause & effect. – deforestation for fuelwood, subsistence farming; desertification & erosion from overgrazing • Preventable disease is linked to environment & poverty. – lack of sanitation & clean water, acute air pollution in rural dwellings from traditional fuels, malnutrition & low birth weight from inadequate diets
Interconnections (continued) • The oceans suffer particularly when people get richer: – improved diets overfishing – pollution from aquaculture – dead zones from fertilizer runoff – oil spills from tankers & drilling rigs – coral reefs being destroyed by construction runoff, cruise ships, live-fish trade, and heating & acidification from the build-up of atmospheric CO 2 .
Interconnections (continued) • Economic progress also intensifies the compe- tition for land, water, & terrestrial biota, as well as the energy/economy/climate dilemma: – improved diets increase demand for grain (for animal feed), grazing land, soybeans… – use of water & energy soar with income – climate change, driven mainly by CO 2 from fossil fuels, imperils food production & water supply, as well as increasing demand for biofuels (to replace fossil fuels) and standing forests (to keep CO 2 out of atmosphere).
The energy-economy- climate challenge… …is paramount in the senses that • Without energy there is no economy • Without climate there is no environment
The science of climate-change in summary • “Global warming” is a misnomer because it implies gradual, uniform, mainly about temperature, & quite possibly benign. – But what’s happening is rapid, nonuniform, affecting everything about climate, & almost entirely harmful. – A more accurate term is “global climatic disruption”. • The disruption is… – real without doubt; – mainly human-caused; – already producing significant harm; and – growing more rapidly than expected.
The Earth is getting hotter. Green bars show 95% confidence intervals 2005 was the hottest year on record; 2007 tied with 1998 for 2 nd hottest; 14 hottest all occurred since 1990, http://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/graphs/
And we know why Top panel shows best estimates of human & natural climate forcings 1880-2005. Bottom panel shows that state-of-the-art climate model, fed these forcings, reproduces the temperatures observed. Source: Hansen et al., Science 308 , 1431, 2005.
But temperature is only part of the story Climate is the pattern of weather, meaning averages, extremes, timing, spatial distribution of… • hot & cold • cloudy & clear • humid & dry • drizzles & downpours • snowfall, snowpack, & snowmelt • zephyrs, blizzards, tornadoes, & typhoons When climate changes, the patterns change. Global average temperature is just an index of the state of the global climate as expressed in these patterns. Small changes in the index big changes in the patterns.
The heating is not uniform geographically (Biggest ΔTs are in far North & Antarctic peninsula) Surface T in 2001-2005 vs 1951-80, averaging 0.53ºC increase J. Hansen et al., PNAS 103 : 14288-293 ( 2006)
Sea ice is shrinking in both Arctic and Antarctic September 2005 September 2007 US National Snow & Ice Data Center, 2007
Melting at the edges of the Greenland & Antarctic land ice sheets is accelerating 1992 2002 2005 And in 2005, it accelerated In 1992 scientists measured this Ten years later, in 2002, the dramatically yet again amount of melting in Greenland as melting was much worse indicated by red areas on the map Source: ACIA, 2004 and CIRES, 2005
Melting land ice and thermal expansion of ocean water are raising sea level mm ACIA, 2004 1993- 2003 ≈ 30 mm = 3.0 mm/yr; compare 1910 -1990 = 1.5 ± 0.5 mm/yr.
Uneven heating also changes the winds
…which changes moisture transport Weakening monsoon means less moisture flow South to North, producing increased flooding in South, drought in North S # S # B S Precipitation trend S S S S # S S # # (mm/decade) # S S # # # S S # S S # # S # # # # S # # # S # S S S # S # S S # # # S S # # S # S # S S S # # # S # S S S ## # S S S S S S # # # S S # # # S # S S # # # S S # S # S # S S # # S # S # <-60 # S # # S S S # # # # # # S S S # S # # # # S S # S -60 S S # # # # # S # # S # # # # # # S # S # # # -40 # S # # # S # # # # # S # S S # # S S S S S -20 # S S # S S S # S S # S S S # S S S S S S S # S S S S S S S S # S S S 0 S S S # # # S S # S S S S S S S # S # S S S S S S S S 20 S S S S # S S S # S S S S S S S S # 40 S # # # S S # S S S S China # # # S S S S # S S # # S S 60 S # S# # # # # # # # # S # S S >60 S S S # # S Qi Ye, Tsinghua University, May 2006
Major floods are up on every continent Major floods per decade, 1950-2000 The trend is most pronounced in Asia
Regions prone to wildfires are getting more so Wildfires in the Western USA have increased 4-fold in the last 30 years. Western US area burned Source: Westerling et al. 2006
WHO estimated that climate change was already causing ≥150,000 premature deaths/yr in 2000
Under BAU much bigger disruption is coming Last time T was 2ºC above 1900 level was 130,000 yr BP, with sea level 4-6 m higher than today. Last time T was 3ºC IPCC (2007) above 1900 level was scenarios ~30 million yr BP, with sea level 20-30 m EU target ∆T ≤ 2ºC higher than today. Note: Shaded bands denote 1 standard deviation from mean in ensembles of model runs IPCC 2007
What more is in store: droughts Drought projections for IPCC„s A1B scenario Percentage change in average duration of longest dry period, 30-year average for 2071-2100 compared to that for 1961-1990.
What‟s in store for sea level? Melting the Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets would raise sea level up to 70 meters. This would probably +7 m take 1000s of years, but rates of 2-5 m per century are possible. GIS = Greenland Ice Sheet WAIS = West Antarctic Ice Sheet EAIS = East +12 m +70 m Antarctic Ice Sheet Dr. Richard Alley, 2005
Facing these dangers… …we have only three options: • Mitigation, meaning measures to reduce the pace & magnitude of the changes in global climate being caused by human activities. • Adaptation, meaning measures to reduce the adverse impacts on human well-being resulting from the changes in climate that do occur. • Suffering the adverse impacts that are not avoided by either mitigation or adaptation.
Recommend
More recommend
