The Political Economy of Federal-State Relations How the centre - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 28, 2022 •17 likes •207 views

The Political Economy of Federal-State Relations How the centre influences resource distribution to the periphery Tricia Yeoh Fellow, IDEAS 20 May 2020 Perikatan Nasional (8 + 1) Pakatan Harapan (3 + 1) Going back in time Wave 1 from

The Political Economy of Federal-State Relations How the centre influences resource distribution to the periphery Tricia Yeoh Fellow, IDEAS 20 May 2020
Perikatan Nasional (8 + 1) Pakatan Harapan (3 + 1)
Going back in time… Wave 1 from 1959 Wave II from 1971 Carving out of KL & Wave III from Labuan as Federal 1980s-1990s: T erritories Federal oversight into DPM Tun Dr. Ismail state bodies “every govt policy is Privatisation determined by party”; GLCs PM Tun Abdul Razak EPU “ kerajaan berparti” New Economic Policy
Downward Resource Distribution Grants and Loans Federal Ministries Politico-Bureaucratic Complex
Grants National Finance Council General Grants Special Grants Tax-Sharing Grants Only some are formula-based. Others are discretionary.
Loans RM million Net federal loans to all states 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 Net federal loans 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Source: Economic Report 2014
Can State GLCs raise their own funds? The case of the Penang Statutory bodies, like state Federal government loan Transport Master Plan. governments, require federal approval. guarantees can be provided But not all state so explicitly. And many are formed as Companies. (Johor, Sarawak, Pahang)
Federal Ministries Public Schools Public Hospitals District Education Health Clinics State Police Contingents State Department Offices Community Clinics State Immigration Offices of Environment State Edu Depts District Health Offices
Politico-Bureaucratic Complex
Federal ministries and agencies that disburse funds downwards
Duplication of Village Committees
Why do constituency development funds even exist?
Policy Recommendations Greater fundraising flexibility for state and local governments CDF allocations given regardless of political affiliation CDF Bill in Parliament Abolish duplicate MPKKPs across all states
Greater fundraising flexibility for state and local governments • Greater flexibility for state and local governments to raise bonds and loans. • Strict financial and regulatory controls. • Collaterals based on cash flow, state assets • Joint determination of economic need.
CDF allocations given regardless of political affiliation
CDF Bill in Parliament • CDFs to be coordinated jointly between state govt and FDOs. • State governments to be consulted on CDFs. • Formal committee chaired by MP on development funds – state govt involved. • Bipartisan parliamentary select committee . • Review CDF system in urban areas.
Abolish duplicate MPKKPs across all states
Thank You! tricia@ideas.org.my www.ideas.org.my

Recommend

Towards a Cultural Political Economy: Engaging with the Cultural Turn in Political Economy II

Towards a Cultural Political Economy: Engaging with the Cultural Turn in Political Economy II Ngai-Ling Sum Cultural Political Economy Research Centre Department of Politics Philosophy and Religion Lancaster University Outline: 5 Parts

336 views • 32 slides

Federal and State Law Updates Shawn Wolbert, CIA, NCCO Director of CU System Relations Glory

Federal and State Law Updates Shawn Wolbert, CIA, NCCO Director of CU System Relations Glory LeDu, BSACS, CUCE Legislative and Regulatory Affairs Specialist State Law Update Advocacy 101 What is Advocacy? Political Involvement

1.42k views • 103 slides

Comparative Political Economy David Soskice Nuffield College Comparative Political Economy (i)

Comparative Political Economy David Soskice Nuffield College Comparative Political Economy (i) Focus on nation states (ii) Complementarities between 3 systems: Variety of Capitalism (Hall & Soskice) Political System (Lijphart) Welfare

337 views • 16 slides

Operationalizing Operationalizing Political Economy: Political Economy: Urban Bus Operations in

Operationalizing Operationalizing Political Economy: Political Economy: Urban Bus Operations in Dhaka Urban Bus Operations in Dhaka Sameer Akbar & Jose Edgardo Campos g p The World Bank GPE in Sectors, London, 5th & 6th Nov 2009 Structure

422 views • 18 slides

Political Economy of State Building Daron Acemoglu (based on joint research with James Robinson)

Political Economy of State Building Daron Acemoglu (based on joint research with James Robinson) MIT World Bank, April 4, 2016. 1 Political Economy of State Building Introduction Huge Differences in Prosperity Huge differences in prosperity

481 views • 45 slides

Welcome to the IR Department! MSc International Political Economy (IPE) / MSc IPE Research

Welcome to the IR Department! MSc International Political Economy (IPE) / MSc IPE Research Orientation Week 2018 lse.ac.uk/internationalRelations facebook.com/LSEIR @LSEIRDept Economics is pro-cyclical. Political economy is

946 views • 19 slides

Uganda roads: A A problem-focused political bl f d liti l economy exercise using a economy

Uganda roads: A A problem-focused political bl f d liti l economy exercise using a economy exercise using a layered approach Presentation to Joint Donor Workshop, Analysing Governance and Political Economy in Sectors, London, 5-6

1k views • 5 slides

The Political Economy of Bad Data: Evidence from African Survey & Administrative Statistics

The Political Economy of Bad Data: Evidence from African Survey & Administrative Statistics Justin Sandefur Amanda Glassman Center for Global Development Outline Seeing like a donor, seeing like a state Fooled by the state Immunization

846 views • 49 slides

Fostering the transition to the new climate economy: policies, political economy, innovation and

Fostering the transition to the new climate economy: policies, political economy, innovation and growth Nicholas Stern IG Patel Professor of Economics & Government London School of Economics and Political Science President of the British

619 views • 36 slides

POLITICAL ECONOMY OF OIL AND FORMATION OF AN OIL STATE IN AZERBAIJAN PhD PROJECT Hafiz Aliyev

POLITICAL ECONOMY OF OIL AND FORMATION OF AN OIL STATE IN AZERBAIJAN PhD PROJECT Hafiz Aliyev OIL STATE Economically RENTIER Politically AUTHORITARIAN OR SEMI-AUTHORITARIAN OIL STATE RENTIER: Economic gains

662 views • 12 slides

State and Federal Political, Economic & Budgetary Overview John Phillimore Executive

State and Federal Political, Economic & Budgetary Overview John Phillimore Executive Director John Curtin Institute of Public Policy Curtin University 1 Federal & WA Politics: similarities 1. Liberal-National governments 2. More

550 views • 37 slides

THE VALUE ADDED OF POLITICAL ECONOMY! ASWAN, MAY 2013 SDC F2F DLGN-NETWORK STEFAN HOCHHUTH THE

Stefan Hochhuth - Mind the Political Economy PRESENTATION THE VALUE ADDED OF POLITICAL ECONOMY! ASWAN, MAY 2013 SDC F2F DLGN-NETWORK STEFAN HOCHHUTH THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF REFORM INTRODUCTION OF CONCEPT KEY MESSAGE: KEEP THE

624 views • 27 slides

as innovation agents in Russia Ivan V. Danilin PhD in Political Sciences Head of Section for

State-Owned Enterprises as innovation agents in Russia Ivan V. Danilin PhD in Political Sciences Head of Section for Innovation policies Institute of World Economy and International Relations (IMEMO), Russian Academy of Sciences E-mail:

330 views • 15 slides

Classical Theories of Political Economy Introduction Introductions, etc. Beverly Crawford,

Classical Theories of Political Economy Introduction Introductions, etc. Beverly Crawford, Stephanie Ballanger, Beth Rabinowitz The syllabus is at: http://bev.berkeley.edu Facebook Group: Political Economy Books: Karl

660 views • 17 slides

Political Economy/Challenging Environments How can political institutions and government

Policy Session on Political Economy/Challenging Environments How can political institutions and government policies be used to reduce conflict, help with post-conflict reconstruction and avoid a fall back into conflict? The Case of South

486 views • 16 slides

Political Economy of Monitoring and Enforcement in the Coal Mining Industry R.J. Briggs,

Political Economy of Monitoring and Enforcement in the Coal Mining Industry R.J. Briggs, Anastasia Shcherbakova, Suman Gautum Pennsylvania State University 30 August 2012 Motivation Upper Big Branch Mine (Massey Energy) West Virginia

407 views • 30 slides

Origins and development of Political Economy in the US. 1 Thanet Aphornsuvan Pridi Banomyong

Origins and development of Political Economy in the US. 1 Thanet Aphornsuvan Pridi Banomyong International College, Thammasat University Nineteenth-century American political economy has earned a reputation as "distinctive," chiefly

443 views • 17 slides

Tribal Gaming and the Political Contribution Strategies of Native American Tribes By: Thomas

Tribal Gaming and the Political Contribution Strategies of Native American Tribes By: Thomas Sorenson Abstract The Indian Gaming Regulatory Act has made a big impact on tribal-state relations since it was enacted in 1988 by the federal

295 views • 15 slides

COMMENTS ON PAUL TUCKERS REMARKS THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF CENTRAL BANK BALANCE SHEET

COMMENTS ON PAUL TUCKERS REMARKS THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF CENTRAL BANK BALANCE SHEET MANAGEMENT Masaaki Shirakawa Aoyama Gakuin University May 4, 2016 At the workshop organized by Columbia University SIPA and the Federal

446 views • 16 slides

Federal and State Energy and Tax Policies: Implications for the Alaskan Economy Prepared for:

Federal and State Energy and Tax Policies: Implications for the Alaskan Economy Prepared for: Alaska World Affairs Council Anchorage, Alaska October 26, 2012 By: Margo Thorning, Ph.D. Senior Vice President and Chief Economist

321 views • 18 slides

Programme Induction MSc The Global Political Economy of China and Europe Paul De Grauwe

Programme Induction MSc The Global Political Economy of China and Europe Paul De Grauwe (Programme Director) John Paulson Chair in European Political Economy London, 22 September 2020 Welco come to the program ramme! What we will cover

294 views • 13 slides

The political economy of inequality Frank Stilwell Emeritus Professor, Department of Political

Sydney Ideas The political economy of inequality Frank Stilwell Emeritus Professor, Department of Political Economy University of Sydney A University of Sydney, Sydney Ideas event Key themes Patterns Processes Problems Politics Prospects

449 views • 18 slides

The Political Economy of Italys Decline LSE Department of Government public lecture Andrea

The Political Economy of Italys Decline LSE Department of Government public lecture Andrea Lorenzo Capussela Chair: Valentino Larcinese Author of State-Building in Kosovo: Democracy, Corruption, and the EU in the Professor in Public Policy in

546 views • 20 slides

The Political Economy The Political Economy of Forgiveness: of Forgiveness: The Necessity of

The Political Economy The Political Economy of Forgiveness: of Forgiveness: The Necessity of Post- -Atrocity Reconciliation Atrocity Reconciliation The Necessity of Post Peter J. Boettke Peter J. Boettke Department of Economics, George

380 views • 12 slides