The Internet as a Field of War Anne Plouy Claerwen OHara Louis Lonet - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 03, 2023 •36 likes •186 views

The Internet as a Field of War Anne Plouy Claerwen OHara Louis Lonet Lucy Turner Leiden University, The Netherlands Leiden University, 16/11/2015 Why? Military spending Increase in attacks Heightened vulnerability Increase in

The Internet as a Field of War Anne Plouy Claerwen O’Hara Louis Léonet Lucy Turner Leiden University, The Netherlands Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Why? • Military spending • Increase in attacks • Heightened vulnerability • Increase in number of vigilantes • International Humanitarian Law is old 2 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Stuxnet: first 60th of Stuxnet binary http://julianoliver.com/output/log_2012-11-12_19-56 3 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
International Humanitarian Law (IHL) 1. Applicability 2. Distinction 3. Proportionality 4. Precaution 4 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 1: Applicability of IHL • International humanitarian law= law of armed conflict • Governs cyber warfare warfare http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/ 185125-how-to-watch-hacking-and- cyberwarfare-between-the-usa-and- china-in-real-time 5 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 1: Applicability of IHL Armed conflict: • 1) Armed force • Non-physical consequences • 2) International or non-international armed conflict • Anonymity • Defies national boundaries 6 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 2: Distinction Key Points: • Military/civilian objects • No indiscriminate attacks • Identification MSF Hospital in Kunduz, Afghanistan www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/03/kunduz-charity-hospital-bombing-violates-international-law#img-2 7 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 2: Distinction Problems for Cyber Warfare: • Internet as “Dual-purpose” • Viruses and Worms • Stuxnet – did it distinguish? • DDoS Attacks • IP addresses • Hackers as combatants? Natanz Nuclear Facility Hamed Saber http://www.flickr.com/photos/hamed/237790717 8 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 3: Proportionality Civilians Lawful Objective Civilians Objects 9 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 3: Proportionality EXPECTED ANTICIPATED MILIT MILITAR ARY Y COLLA COLLATERAL TERAL ADV ADVANT ANTAGE AGE DAMAGE DAMAGE 10 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 3: Proportionality Challenges Regarding Cyber Warfare: Challenges Regarding Cyber Warfare: • Physical Damage VS VS Loss of Functionality • Unexpected & Indirect Consequences è Reasonableness Reasonableness � “ A Posteriori Evaluation ” • Dual-Use Objects è Usability Ratio? 11 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 4: Precaution Legal Key Points Legal Key Points: • Definition • Two parts obligation • Precaution in attack • Precaution against the effects of an attack 12 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Issue 4: Precaution The The “ Perfect Weapon Perfect Weapon ” : - ‘ Turn it off ’ - Information needed to create a weapon BUT • Testing • Suspend & Cancel the attack • Segregation & Protection 13 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Suggestions for the future? • Modernizing the law • Limiters for worms and viruses • Internet as a global commons? WarGames (1983) 14 Leiden University, 16/11/2015
Questions?

Recommend

1 Type of Service Version Header Total Length length TOS Why the protocol field? Why the

Internet Protocol (IP) Internet Protocol (IP) RFC 791 (1981) RFC 791 (1981) Lecture 11. Lecture 11. Connectionless datagram delivery service The Internet Layer The Internet Layer best-effort Unreliable no guarantees of

438 views • 9 slides

No Yes Do you use the Internet to do homework? Do you use the Internet to follow your

No Yes Do you use the Internet to do homework? Do you use the Internet to follow your favourite team? Do you use the internet to watch music videos? Do you use the Internet to read the news? Do you use the Internet to play games? Shared

997 views • 51 slides

Search Engines for the Web An Overview Norvig: Internet Searching . In: Computer Science:

Search Engines for the Web An Overview Norvig: Internet Searching . In: Computer Science: Reflections on the Field, Reflections from the Field. National Academies Press, 2004. Brin and Page: The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web

285 views • 17 slides

EMFCAMP 2012 Internet to a field Nat Morris and Will

EMFCAMP 2012 Internet to a field Nat Morris and Will Hargrave UKNOF23 9 th October 2012 What was EMFCamp 2012? 3 day fes)val Fri 31

893 views • 54 slides

Communication security over the Internet The big picture Me Internet Resource Internet

Communication security over the Internet The big picture Me Internet Resource Internet Server Client Attack vectors MAN DNS LAN Client Internet Back Bone Router Networking WWW overview MITM (Man In The Middle) 3 2 4 5 LAN

244 views • 23 slides

How do you Improve on the Internet? The eXpressive Internet Architecture: The Internet has been

5/15/2012 How do you Improve on the Internet? The eXpressive Internet Architecture: The Internet has been tremendously successful From Architecture to Network Has sustained tremendous growth g Supports very diverse set of applications

484 views • 10 slides

Title of the Invention Medical Diagnostic Slide with Sensors and Internet of Things (IOT)

Title of the Invention Medical Diagnostic Slide with Sensors and Internet of Things (IOT) Inventor: Swarna Kumari Adari Technical Field of the invention Technically advanced microscope slide having embedded sensors(Bio/Nano) and Internet of

723 views • 15 slides

IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet

IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet of Composites IOC: Internet of Composites Robert Bjekovic, University of applied sciences Ravensburg Weingarten, Weingarten, Germany Michael Elwert, University of applied

351 views • 32 slides

Enabling the Internet of Everything with 3G The Internet of Everything The Next Era of

Enabling the Internet of Everything with 3G The Internet of Everything The Next Era of Networking and Computing, Where Everything Is Intelligently Connected Family device layout. Think weve done in past. Add in printer, electric meter,

397 views • 22 slides

Good morning! Internet, Web, Intranets, and Extranets Use and Functioning of the Internet

Good morning! Internet, Web, Intranets, and Extranets Use and Functioning of the Internet Internet is international scope with users on every continent Asians make up 40% of Internet population Europeans about 20% North America

1.01k views • 56 slides

Internet Atlas: A Geographical Database of the Physical Internet Active Internet Measurement

Internet Atlas: A Geographical Database of the Physical Internet Active Internet Measurement Systems Workshop (AIMS) February 6-8, 2013 Ram Durairajan Computer Sciences University of Wisconsin Motivation rkrish@cs.wisc.edu 2

505 views • 33 slides

IT350: Web & Internet Programming Set 7: Website Design 1 Principles: Web sites should be

Your Comments from Reading IT350: Web & Internet Programming Set 7: Website Design 1 Principles: Web sites should be How do you know if your site is good? User Testing and Evaluation A huge part of the HCI field.

510 views • 14 slides

History of the Internet Pat Morin COMP 2405 Outline Origins of the Internet Internet

History of the Internet Pat Morin COMP 2405 Outline Origins of the Internet Internet timeline from 1970s until today The Internet today 2 Origins of the Internet J.C.R. Licklider of MIT in August 1962 wrote about the

562 views • 13 slides

Internet routing is based on routing protocols that collect the input data No off-line route

Introduction to Routing in Internet Internet basics IPv4 and ICMP Internet Addressing ARP - Address Resolution Protocol Routing Information (Distance Vector ) Protocol Principles 3-1 S-38.121 S-02 Rka, NB Internet routing is based on

214 views • 18 slides

1 Internet Email Internet Commercialization SMTP is Internet Email protocol Rapid and

Background of Chapter Software Infrastructure of the Commercializing Internet Not finished Mostly journalistic Recounting of basic events from secondary sources Focus on interplay between technology and business models Thomas

463 views • 3 slides

CS 457 Networking and the Internet Fall 2016 The Global Internet (Then) The tree structure of

10/4/16 CS 457 Networking and the Internet Fall 2016 The Global Internet (Then) The tree structure of the Internet in 1990 The Global Internet (And Now) A simple multi-provider Internet 1 10/4/16 The Global Internet Some large

307 views • 12 slides

The Internet of Things Afloat by Digital Yacht What is the Internet of Things ? The

The Internet of Things Afloat by Digital Yacht What is the Internet of Things ? The Internet of Things (IoT ). A proposed development of the Internet in which everyday objects have network connectivity, allowing them to send

575 views • 24 slides

Track & Field Parent Meeting BT Track & Field Mission Bartram Trail Track & Field

Track & Field Parent Meeting BT Track & Field Mission Bartram Trail Track & Field will create an athlete centered environment that serves as a center for track & field excellence and supports the foundation of life-long

280 views • 12 slides

The History of the Internet Presented by the St. Martins Episcopal Technology Department

The History of the Internet Presented by the St. Martins Episcopal Technology Department Agenda Internet History Internet Evolution Internet Pioneers Internet Growth The Future of the Internet Conclusion

540 views • 24 slides

Welcome to the Indian Prairie Librarys Internet Class I What Is the Internet? The Internet

Welcome to the Indian Prairie Librarys Internet Class I What Is the Internet? The Internet is the largest computer network in the world, connecting millions of computers. A network can also be a group of two or more computer systems linked

371 views • 13 slides

The Problem IP Spoofing CS 239 Existing Internet protocols and Advanced Topics in Network

The Problem IP Spoofing CS 239 Existing Internet protocols and Advanced Topics in Network infrastructure allow forgery of some IP Security packet header fields Peter Reiher In particular, the source address field can often be

400 views • 3 slides

Networking 101.101.101.101 The Internet The Internet is governed by a series of protocols

Networking 101.101.101.101 The Internet The Internet is governed by a series of protocols that form the rules for how communications should happen The Internet is a network of networks. There is no centralized point. There are no

763 views • 34 slides

Introduction to Global Internet Governance Internet Week Guyana 9/13 October 2017

Introduction to Global Internet Governance Internet Week Guyana 9/13 October 2017 kevon@lacnic.net What is the Internet? How does it work? Source: ICANN Historical Facts about the Internet 1975: TCP/IP test between two networks (Stanford

634 views • 25 slides

Internet of things: Next evolution of the Internet Cisco blog quotes: The number of devices

6PANview : A Network Monitoring System for the Internet of Things 23-August-2011 Lohith Y S, Brinda M C, Anand SVR, Malati Hegde Department of ECE Indian Institute of Science Bangalore Funded by DIT, Government of India Internet of

520 views • 20 slides