financial sector reform after the crisis has anything
play

Financial Sector Reform after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jul 12, 2023 •47 likes •297 views

Motivation 1 Financial Sector Reform after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened? Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 Alexander Schaefer - Isabel Schnabel - Beatrice Weder di Mauro Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6

  1. Motivation 1 Financial Sector Reform after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened? Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 Alexander Schaefer - Isabel Schnabel - Beatrice Weder di Mauro Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion EBA Workshop | London | 15th November 2013 1 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  2. Event Study Analysis Motivation Motivation 1 1 Related Literature Preliminary Work & 2 2 Literature Hypotheses Hypotheses 3 3 Event Study Methodology Event Study 4 4 Methodology Findings Findings 5 5 Conclusion 6 6 Conclusion 2 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  3. 1. Motivation Motivation Motivation 1 1 Motivation Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 3 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  4. 1. Motivation Aim of this Paper Motivation Motivation 1 1  Have announcements of structural reforms been registered by the markets? Preliminary Work & 2 Literature  How have equity prices and cds spreads changed?  Do these reactions differ across different types of banks? Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology Findings :  Financial markets reacted to national reforms Findings 5  Increase in cds spreads and (slight) decrease in stock returns 6 Conclusion  Stronger results for investment and systemic banks (in particular U.S. and U.K.) 4 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  5. 2. Preliminary Work & Literature Motivation 1 Related Literature 2 Preliminary Work & Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Literature Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 5 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  6. 2. Preliminary Work and Literature Related Literature Motivation 1  Impact of the Announcement of being Too-Big-Too-Fail 2 Preliminary Work & Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Literature  O’Hara & Shaw (1990)  Effect of the Paulson Plan on banks relative to non-financial fims Hypotheses 3  Veronesi & Zingales (2010) Event Study 4 Methodology  Public guarantees as TBTF subsidies on debt  Ueda & Weder di Mauro (2013) Findings 5  The Value of Being Systemically Important Financial Institutions 6 Conclusion  Bongini, Nieri, and Pelagatti (2013) 6 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  7. 3. Hypotheses Motivation 1 Hypotheses Preliminary Work & 2 Literature 3 Hypotheses Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 7 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  8. 3. Hypotheses Expected Effects of Regulatory Reforms Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature 3 Hypotheses Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 8 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  9. 4. Event Study Methodology Motivation 1 Event Study Methodology Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 4 Event Study Event Study 4 Methodology Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 9 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  10. 4. Event Study Methodology Identification of Events Motivation 1  Reforms take place in several steps Preliminary Work & 2 Literature  Initial announcement, sign of intention, outcome of meetings Hypotheses 3  Identification of sub-events (Lamdin 2001)  Investigating all front pages of a reputable national newspaper within a broadly 4 Event Study Event Study 4 defined period Methodology Methodology  US: FT | US Edition Findings 5  UK: FT | UK Edition  Germany: FTD, Börsenzeitung 6 Conclusion  Switzerland: Neue Zürcher Zeitung 10 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  11. 4. Event Study Methodology Identification of Events Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 4 Event Study Event Study 4 Methodology Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion 11 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  12. 4. Event Study Methodology The Data Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature  10 biggest banks (market capitalization) of US, UK, Germany and Switzerland  Equity: Daily returns of stocks and benchmark indices, based on closing auction Hypotheses 3  CDS: Differences in mid-prices of 5-year senior credit default swap spreads, end 4 Event Study Event Study of day 4 Methodology Methodology  Sources: Datastream (Thomson Reuters), Bankscope Findings 5 6 Conclusion 12 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  13. 4. Event Study Methodology Regression Analysis Motivation 1  Use of dummy variables for one-step estimation, Karafiath (1988) Preliminary Work & 2 Literature  Seemingly unrelated regressions procedure (SUR), Zellner (1962) Hypotheses 3 4 Event Study Event Study 4 Methodology Methodology Findings 5 6 Conclusion - Best way to deal with clustering of events across banks 13 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  14. 5. Findings Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Findings Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology 5 Findings Findings 5 6 Conclusion 14 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  15. 5. Findings Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature United States Hypotheses 3 The Dodd-Frank Act Event Study 4 Methodology 5 Findings Findings 5 6 Conclusion 15 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  16. 5. Findings Dodd Frank Act | Equity Motivation 1 Estimation Window 80 140 80 80 Average Average Investment Systemic vs. Average Abnormal Abnormal vs. Non- Preliminary Work & 2 Dodd-Frank Act Date Return Return Return Commercial Systemic Literature Obama set to target banks with new fees 12-Jan-10 -1.624 -0.536 -0.661 -1.551* -2.525** [0.673] [0.617] [0.056] [0.012] Obama urges banks to take part in crisis costs 15-Jan-10 -2.187 -0.386 -0.517 -0.481 -0.837 Hypotheses 3 [0.761] [0.695] [0.554] [0.407] Announcement of the Volcker Rule 21-Jan-10 -3.060 -0.074 -0.177 -3.357*** -2.944*** [0.953] [0.982] [0.000] [0.004] - Enlarged event window [0-1] -7.223 -2.012 -2.161 -3.875*** -0.916 Event Study 4 Methodology [0.261] [0.250] [0.001] [0.530] Obama promoted reform plans in New York City 22-Apr-10 0.259 0.466 0.762 -0.136 0.216 [0.669] [0.520] [0.874] [0.764] - Enlarged event window [0-1] 0.141 -0.333 -0.064 -0.377 -1.428 5 Findings Findings 5 [0.829] [0.969] [0.767] [0.163] Democrats are willing to dilute rules for swap desks 16-May-10 -0.206 0.371 0.653 0.206 -0.800 [0.736] [0.590] [0.825] [0.328] 6 Conclusion Reform bill passes the senate 20-May-10 -4.432 -1.188 -0.691 0.317 -0.135 [0.293] [0.578] [0.742] [0.874] US Banks set to lose lobby fight on swaps 13-Jun-10 -0.121 -2.208** -2.186* -0.330 -0.825 [0.037] [0.064] [0.719] [0.345] Consensuns between parties - the dilution - 25-Jun-10 2.825 2.74*** 2.796** 0.890 -0.105 [0.009] [0.014] [0.325] [0.895] Summation -12.825 -3.552 -2.832 -5.201 -7.572 16 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  17. 5. Findings Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology 5 Findings Findings 5 6 Conclusion 17 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  18. 5. Findings Dodd Frank Act | CDS Spreads Estimation Window 80 140 80 80 Motivation 1 Average Average Investment Systemic vs. Average Abnormal Abnormal vs. Non- Preliminary Work & 2 Dodd-Frank Act Date Return Return Return Commercial Systemic Literature Obama set to target banks with new fees 12-Jan-10 -0.285 0.170 0.666 0.068 -0.074 [0.967] [0.904] [0.981] [0.984] Obama urges banks to take part in crisis costs 15-Jan-10 3.725 7.131* 7.660 -1.306 1.249 Hypotheses 3 [0.080] [0.163] [0.651] [0.736] Announcement of the Volcker Rule 21-Jan-10 7.773 8.242** 8.754 7.863*** 7.82** [0.036] [0.107] [0.006] [0.033] - Enlarged event window [0-1] 15.970 16.908*** 17.932** 5.289 4.022 Event Study 4 [0.003] [0.020] [0.169] [0.496] Methodology Obama promoted reform plans in New York City 22-Apr-10 5.103 5.421 5.526 -0.676 0.275 [0.115] [0.168] [0.749] [0.930] - Enlarged event window [0-1] 3.866 8.368* 8.578 2.727 3.526 5 Findings Findings 5 [0.087] [0.131] [0.413] [0.426] Democrats are willing to dilute rules for swap desks 16-May-10 4.436 0.624 0.573 -5.83** -5.155 [0.913] [0.910] [0.021] [0.154] 6 Conclusion Reform bill passes the senate 20-May-10 10.353 10.382** 10.394** 1.962 3.109 [0.067] [0.037] [0.491] [0.429] US Banks set to lose lobby fight on swaps 13-Jun-10 -8.985 -5.797 -5.607 0.805 3.534 [0.362] [0.299] [0.771] [0.312] Consensuns between parties - the dilution - 25-Jun-10 -4.307 -4.514 -4.532 -2.674 -2.628 [0.489] [0.404] [0.714] [0.571] Summation 24.772 38.694 35.664 1.041 7.582 18 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

  19. 5. Findings Motivation 1 Preliminary Work & 2 Literature Hypotheses 3 Event Study 4 Methodology 5 Findings Findings 5 6 Conclusion 19 Financial Sector Reforms after the Crisis: Has Anything Happened?

Recommend

Reflections on Financial Sector Reform Andrew Sheng Chairman Securities and Futures Commission,

Reflections on Financial Sector Reform Andrew Sheng Chairman Securities and Futures Commission,

Lecture for Staff of Central Bank of Sri Lanka 8 April 2005 Colombo, Sri Lanka Reflections on Financial Sector Reform Andrew Sheng Chairman Securities and Futures Commission, Hong Kong 1 Contents of Lecture Lessons of Financial Crisis

1.08k views • 54 slides
Tripartite workshop on the impact of the financial crisis on finance sector workers in selected

Tripartite workshop on the impact of the financial crisis on finance sector workers in selected

Tripartite workshop on the impact of the financial crisis on finance sector workers in selected African countries Presentation on the ILO Global Dialogue Forum on the Impact of the Financial Crisis on Finance Sector Workers, ILO Geneva,

484 views • 11 slides
FINANCE IN THE TIME OF COVID-19 THORSTEN BECK GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS VS. GREAT LOCKDOWN

FINANCE IN THE TIME OF COVID-19 THORSTEN BECK GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS VS. GREAT LOCKDOWN

FINANCE IN THE TIME OF COVID-19 THORSTEN BECK GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS VS. GREAT LOCKDOWN This crisis did NOT start in the financial sector, but financial sector will be affected negatively as many/most other sectors Financial sector can

441 views • 9 slides
Impact of global financial & economic crisis on financial services workers in select African

Impact of global financial & economic crisis on financial services workers in select African

Impact of global financial & economic crisis on financial services workers in select African countries By Aidan Eyakuze Serengeti Advisers Ltd Outline 1. Study Objectives 2. Structure of financial sector 3. Financial sector employment

119 views • 10 slides
Homelessness Sector Reform Sector Briefing 17 April 2020 Sector Reform - Overview Over the

Homelessness Sector Reform Sector Briefing 17 April 2020 Sector Reform - Overview Over the

Homelessness Sector Reform Sector Briefing 17 April 2020 Sector Reform - Overview Over the next 12 months the Government will consult and work with the specialist homelessness sector to design a new system that will better meet the needs of

299 views • 17 slides
PRESENTATION TELECOMMUNICATIONS IN CRISIS: PERSPECTIVES OF THE FINANCIAL SECTOR ON REGULATORY

PRESENTATION TELECOMMUNICATIONS IN CRISIS: PERSPECTIVES OF THE FINANCIAL SECTOR ON REGULATORY

INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATION UNION TELECOMMUNICATION DEVELOPMENT BUREAU Document: 21 GLOBAL SYMPOSIUM FOR REGULATORS Hong Kong, China, 7 -8 December 2002 PRESENTATION TELECOMMUNICATIONS IN CRISIS: PERSPECTIVES OF THE FINANCIAL SECTOR ON

295 views • 10 slides
the Financial Sector Regulation Bill Jan-Feb 2015 Twin Peaks reform process to date Budget

the Financial Sector Regulation Bill Jan-Feb 2015 Twin Peaks reform process to date Budget

Stakeholder consultation workshop: Second draft of the Financial Sector Regulation Bill Jan-Feb 2015 Twin Peaks reform process to date Budget 2011 Policy paper A safer financial sector to serve South Africa better July

512 views • 27 slides
Financial supervisory architecture: what has changed after the crisis? OSCAR PASCUAL GUTIRREZ

Financial supervisory architecture: what has changed after the crisis? OSCAR PASCUAL GUTIRREZ

Financial supervisory architecture: what has changed after the crisis? OSCAR PASCUAL GUTIRREZ ndice I. International Financial Crisis II. Financial sector supervisory models concepts and evolution III. Post-crisis financial supervisory

640 views • 32 slides
Implications for the EEA of EU post-crisis reform Brit Helle Pollet Officer Financial

Implications for the EEA of EU post-crisis reform Brit Helle Pollet Officer Financial

Implications for the EEA of EU post-crisis reform Brit Helle Pollet Officer Financial Services EFTA Secretariat EEA Seminar 11 December 2009 Outline Current structure of EU decision making within Financial Services and EEA

718 views • 15 slides
THE GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS: HOW DID WE GET HERE AND HOW DO WE MOVE FORWARD By Dr. Maurice Odle

THE GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS: HOW DID WE GET HERE AND HOW DO WE MOVE FORWARD By Dr. Maurice Odle

THE GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS: HOW DID WE GET HERE AND HOW DO WE MOVE FORWARD By Dr. Maurice Odle 1 Economic Adviser to the Secretary-General Caribbean Community INTRODUCTION: The financial sector of the developed countries and emerging market

938 views • 29 slides
The business models of large interconnected banks and the lessons from the financial crisis

The business models of large interconnected banks and the lessons from the financial crisis

The business models of large interconnected banks and the lessons from the financial crisis Adrian Blundell-Wignall, Paul Atkinson and Caroline Roulet (OECD) ESRC/NIESR conference Financial Structure: Fine Tuning or Radical Reform?

612 views • 28 slides
PAPUA NEW GUINEA S FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM PRESENTATION TO CAPI WORKSHOP 4 February 2016

PAPUA NEW GUINEA S FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM PRESENTATION TO CAPI WORKSHOP 4 February 2016

BANK OF PAPUA NEW GUINEA PAPUA NEW GUINEA S FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM PRESENTATION TO CAPI WORKSHOP 4 February 2016 1 BANK OF PAPUA NEW GUINEA Outline of Presentation 1. Financial Sector Reforms in PNG 2. Other Financial Sector Reforms

1.24k views • 26 slides
Impact of the Financial Crisis on LDCs LDCs Impact of the Financial Crisis on by Mr. Kavazeua

Impact of the Financial Crisis on LDCs LDCs Impact of the Financial Crisis on by Mr. Kavazeua

Impact of the Financial Crisis on LDCs LDCs Impact of the Financial Crisis on by Mr. Kavazeua Katjomuise Programme Officer UN-OHRLLS United Nations Office of the High Representative for the Least Developed Countries, Landlocked Developing

371 views • 15 slides
Restructuring Prudential Regulation in Light of the Global Financial Crisis Charles W. Calomiris

Restructuring Prudential Regulation in Light of the Global Financial Crisis Charles W. Calomiris

Restructuring Prudential Regulation in Light of the Global Financial Crisis Charles W. Calomiris Brookings Institution December 4, 2012 Financial Repression or Real Reform? That really is the choice. Large global universal banks do play

550 views • 28 slides
Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Would macroprudential regulation have

Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Would macroprudential regulation have

Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Global Financial Crisis @ 10 Would macroprudential regulation have Would macroprudential regulation have prevented the last crisis? prevented the last crisis? David Aikman, Jonathan Bridges, Anil Kashyap and Caspar

340 views • 19 slides
Prone to Fail The Pre-Crisis Financial System Darrell Duffie GSB Stanford The Financial Crisis

Prone to Fail The Pre-Crisis Financial System Darrell Duffie GSB Stanford The Financial Crisis

Prone to Fail The Pre-Crisis Financial System Darrell Duffie GSB Stanford The Financial Crisis at 10 NBER Summer Institute Cambridge, July 2018 Drawing from joint work with Antje Berndt and Yichao Zhu Average leverage of systemic banks and

456 views • 16 slides
Reforming the US Financial System: Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act

Reforming the US Financial System: Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act

Reforming the US Financial System: Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act Joseph A. McCahery Tilburg University Presentation Outline Overview of Policy Issues Anatomy of Crisis and Limitation in Financial Regulation

668 views • 23 slides
Fourth Annual Financial Regulatory Reform Symposium Navigating Dodd-Frank: Are We Avoiding

Fourth Annual Financial Regulatory Reform Symposium Navigating Dodd-Frank: Are We Avoiding

The George Washington University Law School Center for Law, Economics & Finance Fourth Annual Financial Regulatory Reform Symposium Navigating Dodd-Frank: Are We Avoiding Another Financial Crisis? AGENDA Thursday, October 25, 2012

71 views • 3 slides
Member States to Cope with the Global Financial Crisis Tripartite Workshop on the Impact of the

Member States to Cope with the Global Financial Crisis Tripartite Workshop on the Impact of the

AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK The Role of the African Development Bank in Assisting Member States to Cope with the Global Financial Crisis Tripartite Workshop on the Impact of the Financial Crisis on Finance Sector Workers in Selected African

385 views • 19 slides
The Global Financial Crisis and Developing countries: Case of Zambia The Global Financial Crisis

The Global Financial Crisis and Developing countries: Case of Zambia The Global Financial Crisis

The Global Financial Crisis and Developing countries: Case of Zambia The Global Financial Crisis Workshop ODI , London UK 11 th February 2009 By Manenga Ndulo, Dale Mudenda, Lutangu Ingombe and Lilian Muchimba- University of Zambia

470 views • 16 slides
Public Sector Financial Reports Preparation of Financial Statements Public Sector Seminar

Public Sector Financial Reports Preparation of Financial Statements Public Sector Seminar

Public Sector Financial Reports Preparation of Financial Statements Public Sector Seminar February 2019 Compiled by: Prof. Jade Jansen,Y aeesh Y asseen & Rashied Small Public Sector Financial Reports 2 Financial Reporting Public

746 views • 47 slides
Biodiversity conservation activities of Japanese financial sector Naohisa Okuda Director, Global

Biodiversity conservation activities of Japanese financial sector Naohisa Okuda Director, Global

Biodiversity conservation activities of Japanese financial sector Naohisa Okuda Director, Global Biodiversity Strategy Office, Ministry of the Environment, Japan Financial sector and Biodiversity Conservation Other Inputs Global Warming Crisis

552 views • 15 slides
Ten years after the crisis: lessons learnt and forward risks for the Belgian economy and the

Ten years after the crisis: lessons learnt and forward risks for the Belgian economy and the

Ten years after the crisis: lessons learnt and forward risks for the Belgian economy and the financial sector Jean Hilgers Directeur Authors: De Prest, E. Deroose, M. Dresse, L. Schepens, Th. DS.18.09.374 Overview I. Flashback: A crisis

473 views • 43 slides
The reform of public sector accounting - The role of the accountant - Andr Maralo,

The reform of public sector accounting - The role of the accountant - Andr Maralo,

CIGAR Conference and PhD Seminar 2017 Oporto, 8 June 2017 The reform of public sector accounting - The role of the accountant - Andr Maralo, Coordinator Agenda 1. Initial remarks 2. PFM Reform players 3. Institutions and PFM Reform 4.

1.27k views • 13 slides

More recommend