Linkages between debt sustainability and debt management strategies. Fiscal and Debt Policies in Ghana Sovereign Debt Management Forum 2016 The World Bank 19 th -20 th October Samuel Danquah Arkhurst (Director – Debt Mgt Division) Ministry of Finance - Republic of Ghana October 2016
Country Context - Ghana
Recent History of the Republic of Ghana 238,537 sq. Km; Accra Territory & Capital Population (2013) 27 million Nominal GDP (2015) US$ 37.0 bn 3.9% GDP Growth (2015) GDP Per Capita US$ 1,339 Moody’s: B3 / Fitch: B / S&P: B- Sovereign Credit Ratings At 3.6 up from 3.4 CPIA Vibrant democracy with an impending to Democracy be heavily contested December Election 3
Evolution of Fiscal Policy and Debt Management 1992 -2000 2001 - 2008 2009 - 2012 2013 to Date SSSS related arrears, rising • 4th Republic begins in Ghana subscribes to (HIPC) Set back with twin deficits (Budget & subsidy expenditure, higher 1992 with significant BoG0 Beginning of PRSPs as initiatives for interest payments, a shortfall in fiscal requirement the utilization of HIPC Ghana produces a ‘Home Grown Policy’ taxes and grants puts pressure on • Fiscal Deficit increases as to deal with twin deficit Increasing Social Intervention the budget; resulting in large a result of unbudgeted deficit overshoots For credibility, Ghana signs 3-Year US$ Programmes to meet the MDGs by outlays (ie for 2015 918mn ECF Programme with IMF with Economic management further Peacekeeping operations in two (3) positive reviews so far Fiscal Space from HIPC, MDRI, and compounded by the onset of West Africa and District Domestic Revenue and Dev’t external pressures Twin deficits brought under control in Level elections) Partners. 2015 Crude oil export commences with • Program and project aid Ghana Implements Single Spine Oil price crash in addition to traditional exports falling short of expectations from external sources in 2012 Salary Structure (SSSS) review exports (Cocoa and Gold) shrank remarkably GDP rebasing and transition to Trades Union unrest and increases country (LMIC) status in Wages Sharp increase in domestic Debt levels starts to accumulate to 2013,2014,2015,2016 Eurobond debt (from 3% of GDP in 1990 accommodate the increasing fiscal HIPC completion point in 2006 with Establishment of Sinking Fund to 25% of GDP in 2000) to deficits debt to GDP ratio reaching 25% Development of Domestic Market cater for fiscal excesses The First post-HIPC country to New Debt Ceilings from IMF programme Public Debt almost hitting access International Capital Markets 181% of GDP by 2000 LMIC status and cost of financing with a benchmark issue of US$750m DMD becomes a Establishment of the in 2007, 10yr tenure loan, at a Gross financing needs peaked at 23.6% “ stand - alone” Division coupon rate of 8.5% of GDP in 2015 External Debt ADMU elevated to become with the aid New PFM law Repeals the 1970 Loans Secretariat (EDS) Act the Aid & Debt component ceded to New PFM law Management Division External Mobilisations (ADMD) in 2004 establishes a Public Division Debt Management Office 4
Historical Link between Fiscal Deficit and Debt 5
DSA and MTDS
Ghana Indicators of Public Debt Under Alternative Scenarios – 2016-36 • 2 Indicators Breaching Thresholds under the Baseline • PV of Debt-to GDP ratio • Debt Service to Revenue Ratio 7
MTDS Results • Exchange Cost/Risk Indicators External debt Domestic debt Total debt Rate Risk • Interest Interest payment as % GDP 1.6 5.9 7.5 Cost of debt Rate Risk Weighted Av. IR (%) 3.9 19.5 10.5 • Financing 1.1 6.9 ATM (years) 10.0 Risks Debt maturing in 1yr (% of Refinancing total) 5.3 46.9 22.8 risk Debt maturing in 1yr (% of GDP) 2.2 14.1 16.3 ATR (years) 9.1 1.1 6.4 Debt refixing in 1yr (% of Interest rate total) 23.2 46.9 33.1 risk Fixed rate debt (% of total) 79.3 100.0 88.0 FX debt (% of total debt) 58.0 FX risk ST FX debt (% of reserves) 15.2
Managing the Intra and inter linkages
Current Reform Agenda Conduct of Fiscal Policy and Debt Policies an integral part of current policy drive Governance Issues MTFF and MTDS MTDS no more a residual policy from 20105 DMD leads MTDS and DSA MTDS now to be presented and approved by PFM law establishes Public Debt Management Cabinet Office and codifies these links. Recognition as an integral part of the budget process Cash Management now targeting financing as exogenous, thus cash outfows to adjust to shocks MTFF / MTDS Operations Governance Policy Fiscal Policy Debt Management Policies Under the Home Grown Policy and IMF ECF Strict handle on contingent Liabilities programme, fiscal consolidation for the medium Refinancing / Buyback term. Escrow / On-Lending PFM law prescribes numerical rules for fiscal stance Interest rate hedge Bank of Ghana amendment reduces Central Bank Sinking fund to buffer roll-over /maturity risks Financing to 5% of previous yeaer’s revenue with Development of Risk Management framework other safety guards 10
Ghana’s Eurobond Story A tale for two Cities – MTDS and DSA Use of Proceeds Face Value Coupon Tenor in New Debt Policies for bullet Year in Mn USD Rate Years CAPEX Liquidity Mgt loans shits into buy-back 2007 750.00 8.50% 10 750.00 mechanism. 2013 1,000.00 7.88% 10 780.58 219.42 Sinking Fund accumulated funds 12 with 3 Yr from Oil Revenue. Utilised Soft US$130 mn in Aug 2016 for 2014 1,000.00 8.13% 1,000.00 Amortizatio buyback of 2017 Bond Maturity. n Total Buyback of US$549 mn 15 with 3 Yr out of US$750 mn already done. Soft About US$800 mn already used 2015 1,000.00 10.75% 1,000.00 Amortizatio to retire domestic S.T. Bills in n 2015 & 2016 6 with 3 Yr Excess of US$500mn available Soft 2016 750.00 9.25% 150 600.00 to take off US$200 mn balance Amortizatio of 2017 maturity and further buy- n back of remaining bonds 1 st Domestic Dollar Bond hugely TOTAL 4,500.00 2,680.58 1,819.42 successful last week at about DOMESTIC US Dollar Bond US$94 mn for 6% for a 2 year 2016 94.00 6.00% 2 year 94.00 period to also add to a further Oct liquidity mgt. 11
Results of all this …………………. Historical Measures Implemented Overall Achievements Issues • Refinance short-dated, high cost GHS debt with long • Rising • Public Debt to GDP ratio term, IDA guaranteed USD debt Public Debt responding to debt • Sinking fund established to manage repayments to GDP management policies. • Commercial funding only for commercially viable and since 2006. Tapering downwards for • Rapid priority high-impact projects the first time since 2006 • Comprehensive increase in debt sustainability plan being 2012-14 developed with IMF 12
Thank you
Recommend
More recommend