audit committee
play

Audit Committee denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Aug 26, 2022 •15 likes •485 views

1 Audit Committee denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor 2 Audit Committee Affordable Housing Audit December 2018 Jared Miller, Audit Supervisor Pat Schafer, Audit Supervisor Shaun Wysong, Senior Auditor Chris Wilson,

  1. 1 Audit Committee denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  2. 2 Audit Committee Affordable Housing Audit December 2018 Jared Miller, Audit Supervisor Pat Schafer, Audit Supervisor Shaun Wysong, Senior Auditor Chris Wilson, Staff Auditor denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  3. 3 Background Affordable Housing: • Occupants pay no more than 30 percent of their gross income for housing costs • Eligibility for affordable housing programs is based on a household’s area median income (AMI)  Denver’s 2018 AMI for a single‐person household is $63,000 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  4. 4 Inclusionary Housing Ordinance • Enacted in 2002 to increase number of low‐ and moderate‐income housing units  10 percent of units in residential developments of 30 or more for‐sale homes must be affordable  Developer may also pay a cash‐in‐lieu fee instead denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  5. 5 • Zones determine the percentage applied to get the appropriate cash‐in‐lieu fee. denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  6. 6 Background, continued • Income Verification – The Office of Economic Development verifies a homebuyer is within the AMI range and housing payments are affordable. • Incentive Payments – Developers may apply for financial incentives for building affordable units based on neighborhood type. denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  7. 7 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  8. 8 Affordable Housing Permanent Fund Ordinance • Approved a dedicated permanent source of funding for affordable housing in September 2016 • Consists of two funding sources:  Property Tax Revenue Fund  Linkage Fee Revenue Fund denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  9. 9 Affordable Housing Fund, continued Department of Community Planning and Development • Responsible for the calculation and collection of linkage fees • Responsible for coordinating approvals for linkage fee exemptions denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  10. Gap‐Financing 10 • Additional tool the Office of Gap Economic Development uses to build affordable units Total Housing Sale • Financing covers the gap Project Costs Developer Proceeds Proceeds between the cost to build to From affordable homes and the Developer Affordable Unit restrictively set low sale Sales prices denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  11. 11 11 Finding 1 The Office of Economic Development’s Lack of Proper Implementation and Enforcement of Regulations Is Not Ensuring Affordability of Housing denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  12. 12 12 Sub‐Finding 1: Initial Sales Prices Inaccurate Initial Sale Prices Resulted in Mispricing of Homes denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  13. The Office of 13 Economic Development: • Calculates maximum sale prices for affordable homes • Publishes maximum sale price tables denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  14. 14 14 Initial Sales Prices, continued denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  15. 15 15 Initial Sales Prices, continued OED failed to calculate max sale price table for 2007 • 51 affordable homes possibly sold for less than they should have Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor denvergov.org/Auditor

  16. 16 Recommendation 1.1: Design Internal Controls to Ensure Correct Maximum Sale Price Table Is Used Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: March 31, 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  17. 17 17 Sub‐Finding 2: Income Eligibility The Office of Economic Development Is Not Properly Determining Income Eligibility for Prospective Homebuyers of Affordable Homes denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  18. 18 18 Income Eligibility, continued Errors in Income Verification Process • The Office of Economic Development did not ensure affordability of housing payments • Seven of 23 for‐sale units had housing payments above 30 percent of owner’s gross income denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  19. 19 Recommendation 1.2: Design Internal Controls for Income Verification Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: Completed denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  20. 20 20 Sub‐Finding 3: Recording Process Errors Exist in the Office of Economic Development’s Recording Process denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  21. 21 21 Recording Process, continued Memorandum of Acceptance Errors • Six improperly categorized • Three recorded under misspelled names • Five incorrect or no reception numbers Secondary Liens Could Improve Controls denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  22. 22 Recommendation 1.3: Design Internal Controls for Recording Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: May 31, 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  23. 23 Recommendation 1.4: Research Use of Secondary Liens Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: May 31, 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  24. 24 24 Sub‐Finding 4: Resale Prices The Office of Economic Development Miscalculated Maximum Resale Prices denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  25. 25 25 Resale Prices, continued • Incorrect and unsupported appraisals • Incorrect and unsupported Case/Shiller Index rates applied • Miscalculations in total days of ownership denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  26. 26 Recommendation 1.5: Design Internal Controls for Reviewing Resale Prices Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: March 1, 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  27. 27 27 Sub‐Finding 5: Cash‐in‐Lieu Payments The Office of Economic Development Mishandled Cash‐in‐Lieu Payments denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  28. 28 28 Cash‐in‐Lieu Payments, continued Two options under Inclusionary Housing Ordinance: 1. Allocate 10 percent of units in development as affordable units and sell at below‐market rates OR 2. Pay fee instead of building, called “cash‐in‐lieu fee” denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  29. How a Cash‐In‐Lieu Fee Is Calculated: 29 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  30. 30 30 Cash‐in‐Lieu Payments, continued • Only two cash‐in‐lieu payments have been made since 2014 • Both payments were problematic 1. OED used wrong table when determining cash‐in‐lieu  Over‐charged developer $35,762 2. This error allowed City to issue building permit AND certificate of occupancy prior to collecting cash‐in‐lieu.  Took City 12 years to collect $1.5 million cash in lieu fee denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  31. 31 Recommendation 1.6: Rectify Overpayment Received in 2014 from Developer Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: January 31, 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  32. 32 32 Sub‐Finding 6: Incomplete Data The Office of Economic Development Lacks an Accurate and Complete Compliance Database of Affordable Units denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  33. 33 33 Incomplete Data, continued Data Inaccuracies Found: • 27 units from two developments missing • Nine reception dates in place of dates of sale • One instance each of:  Owner placed in incorrect field,  Duplicate owner with incorrect sales price, and  Missing sales price denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  34. 34 Recommendation 1.7: Design Internal Controls for Data Accuracy Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: Fourth Quarter 2019 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  35. 35 35 Sub‐Finding 7: Incentive Payments The Office of Economic Development Exceeded Incentive Payment Annual Maximum denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  36. 36 36 Incentive Payments, Continued • Incentive to developers for building affordable units under the Inclusionary Housing Ordinance  Sunsetted December 2016 • $250,000 max can be paid out to any ONE developer per year • The Office of Economic Development violated cap and paid out $318,500 to one developer in 2018 denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  37. 37 Recommendation 1.8: Design Internal Controls for Processing of Incentive Payments Agency Response: Agree Implementation Date: Completed denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  38. 38 38 Sub‐Finding 8: Rental Monitoring The Office of Economic Development Is Not Monitoring Federally Funded Rental Projects in a Timely Manner denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

  39. 39 39 Rental Monitoring, continued Code of Federal Regulations: “The participating jurisdiction must review rents for compliance and approve or disapprove them every year.” Section 92.252(f)(2) of Code of Federal Regulations states that “[t]he participating jurisdiction must review rents for compliance and approve or disapprove them every year.” denvergov.org/Auditor Timothy M. O'Brien, CPA, Auditor

Recommend

Audit Sub-Committee Workshop Members of the Regions Audit Sub Committee & Halton

Audit Sub-Committee Workshop Members of the Regions Audit Sub Committee & Halton

Audit Sub-Committee Workshop Members of the Regions Audit Sub Committee & Halton Community Housing Corporations (HCHC) Audit Committee April 10, 2019 Presented by: Cyndy Winslow, Director, Financial Services & Payroll Karen

547 views • 54 slides
Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee Members: Thank you for your continued engagement of Moss Adams LLP, the provider of choice for state and local governments. Were pleased to present

294 views • 16 slides
Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee Members: Thank you for your continued engagement of Moss Adams LLP, the provider of choice for state and local governments. Were pleased to present

574 views • 18 slides
BRAND USA BOARD OF DIRECTORS AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING June 22, 2017 Brand USA Audit Committee

BRAND USA BOARD OF DIRECTORS AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING June 22, 2017 Brand USA Audit Committee

BRAND USA BOARD OF DIRECTORS AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING June 22, 2017 Brand USA Audit Committee Kyle Edmiston Chair Andrew Greenfield Tom Klein Thomas OToole Alice Norsworthy 2 Kyle Edmiston Chair, Audit Committee Audit Committee

416 views • 14 slides
IMPACTFUL COMMUNICATION BETWEEN IA AND THE AUDIT COMMITTEE GOJ AUDIT COMMISSION CONFERENCE

IMPACTFUL COMMUNICATION BETWEEN IA AND THE AUDIT COMMITTEE GOJ AUDIT COMMISSION CONFERENCE

IMPACTFUL COMMUNICATION BETWEEN IA AND THE AUDIT COMMITTEE GOJ AUDIT COMMISSION CONFERENCE Oct-17 OBJECTIVES OF THIS PRESENTATION To clarify governance To discuss setting the right tone at the top. To identify the roles of Audit

641 views • 26 slides
COMMENTS TO THE 2018 ELECTION AUDIT COMMITTEE FOR TML I would like to thank the committee for

COMMENTS TO THE 2018 ELECTION AUDIT COMMITTEE FOR TML I would like to thank the committee for

COMMENTS TO THE 2018 ELECTION AUDIT COMMITTEE FOR TML I would like to thank the committee for giving me the opportunity to address you today and to request a review and audit of election expenses for one candidate and two registered third party

426 views • 14 slides
Auditor Presentation of Programmatic Audit Results to the Audit Committee Presented By Bill

Auditor Presentation of Programmatic Audit Results to the Audit Committee Presented By Bill

Auditor Presentation of Programmatic Audit Results to the Audit Committee Presented By Bill Brown, CPA, CFE, MAFF Yoko McCarthy, MBA, CISA, CFE, CGFM April 19, 2018 Agenda Programmatic Audit Overview Three Year Programmatic Audit

222 views • 10 slides
PRE-AUDIT REPORT TO THE AUDIT & COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE MAY 2, 2017 BKD, LLP MARY MCKINLEY,

PRE-AUDIT REPORT TO THE AUDIT & COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE MAY 2, 2017 BKD, LLP MARY MCKINLEY,

PRE-AUDIT REPORT TO THE AUDIT & COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE MAY 2, 2017 BKD, LLP MARY MCKINLEY, PARTNER JOANIE DUCKWORTH, DIRECTOR 1 // experience access PRE-AUDIT REPORT SUMMARY Auditors Responsibility Obtain reasonable, but not absolute,

177 views • 7 slides
Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee members: Thank you for your continued engagement of Better Together: Moss Adam s & Metro Metro Moss Adams LLP, the provider of choice for

550 views • 23 slides
Briefing on Scop e of 20 12 Fina ncia l Aud it Audit Committee of the ISO Board of Governors

Briefing on Scop e of 20 12 Fina ncia l Aud it Audit Committee of the ISO Board of Governors

www.pwc.com Briefing on Scop e of 20 12 Fina ncia l Aud it Audit Committee of the ISO Board of Governors General Session December 13-14, 2012 Agend a Our Audit Objectives Overall Audit Strategy Key Audit Areas Perspectives on Fraud Risk

295 views • 13 slides
Intro to KPMG & the Audit Committee Institute Andy Cardoza Markus Korner 1. Audit

Intro to KPMG & the Audit Committee Institute Andy Cardoza Markus Korner 1. Audit

Intro to KPMG & the Audit Committee Institute Andy Cardoza Markus Korner 1. Audit appointments 2. Introduction to KPMG 3. Q&A 4. Audit Committee Institute 5. Q&A The Audit Commission Act 1998 sets out the statutory

372 views • 23 slides
Demystifying the Finance Audit Committee DEMYSTIFYING THE FINANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE

Demystifying the Finance Audit Committee DEMYSTIFYING THE FINANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE

DEMYSTIFYING THE FINANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE Demystifying the Finance Audit Committee DEMYSTIFYING THE FINANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE Agenda 1. How to set-up the Finance and Audit Committee 2. Terms of Reference 3. Recruitment 4.

503 views • 33 slides
Briefing on Scope of Operations Audit Nancy Traweek Director, System Operations Audit Committee

Briefing on Scope of Operations Audit Nancy Traweek Director, System Operations Audit Committee

Briefing on Scope of Operations Audit Nancy Traweek Director, System Operations Audit Committee Meeting General Session May 15, 2013 Operations Audit Background Independent audit review required by tariff Second year conducting full

415 views • 5 slides
Internal Audit Division Update & Review of Internal Audit Plan Finance and Audit Committee

Internal Audit Division Update & Review of Internal Audit Plan Finance and Audit Committee

Internal Audit Division Update & Review of Internal Audit Plan Finance and Audit Committee 12/19/19 Why we are here Today we are here to Provide information on 2019 Internal Audit activities Request a review of 2020 Internal

391 views • 16 slides
Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee

Audit Entrance Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Audit Committee Dear Audit Committee members: Thank you for your continued engagement of Better Together: Moss Adams & Metro Metro Moss Adams LLP, the provider of choice for

245 views • 22 slides
CHAMBER OF TAX CONSULTANTS STUDENT COMMITTEE Presentation on AUDIT AROUND THE COMPUTER

CHAMBER OF TAX CONSULTANTS STUDENT COMMITTEE Presentation on AUDIT AROUND THE COMPUTER

CHAMBER OF TAX CONSULTANTS STUDENT COMMITTEE Presentation on AUDIT AROUND THE COMPUTER INCLUDING AUDIT DOCUMENTATION by CA MEHUL R. SHETH 08 TH JUNE 2018 1 An audit is a systematic and independent examination of books, accounts,

864 views • 58 slides
Audit and Compliance Committee Internal Audit Proposed Internal Audit Charter March 15, 2019

Audit and Compliance Committee Internal Audit Proposed Internal Audit Charter March 15, 2019

Audit and Compliance Committee Internal Audit Proposed Internal Audit Charter March 15, 2019 Internal Audit Open Meeting Internal Audit Charter Internal Audit Charter (The following 3 slides are excerpts from the Institute of Internal

205 views • 6 slides
Information Technology Update Audit Committee June 5, 2019 1 Audit Committee PRESENTATION

Information Technology Update Audit Committee June 5, 2019 1 Audit Committee PRESENTATION

Audit Committee PRESENTATION REVISED Information Technology Update Audit Committee June 5, 2019 1 Audit Committee PRESENTATION REVISED Agenda 01 02 03 04 Agenda Agenda Agenda Agenda AMI Audit Discussion of Data Security 2.0

559 views • 24 slides
TfN Audit & Governance Committee Item 6b TfN Draft Statement of Accounts 2019/20 Audit

TfN Audit & Governance Committee Item 6b TfN Draft Statement of Accounts 2019/20 Audit

TfN Audit & Governance Committee Item 6b TfN Draft Statement of Accounts 2019/20 Audit & Governance Committee Contents Public Inspection Period Basis of Preparation Key Items in this Years Accounts Structure of

455 views • 26 slides
Audit Results for FY2018 Financial Statements Presentation to the Audit Committee December 11,

Audit Results for FY2018 Financial Statements Presentation to the Audit Committee December 11,

The Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County OFFICE of of MAYOR DAVID ID B BRILE ILEY Audit Results for FY2018 Financial Statements Presentation to the Audit Committee December 11, 2018 www.crosslinpc.com Agenda

746 views • 18 slides
Clinical and Laboratory Test Result Notifications Audit Audit Review Committee Update July 11,

Clinical and Laboratory Test Result Notifications Audit Audit Review Committee Update July 11,

Department of Internal Audit Clinical and Laboratory Test Result Notifications Audit Audit Review Committee Update July 11, 2017 1 Internal Audit is evaluating the design and effectiveness of the patient notification process for clinical

546 views • 19 slides
Internal Audit Division Update Finance and Audit Committee | 10/24/19 Why we are here Today

Internal Audit Division Update Finance and Audit Committee | 10/24/19 Why we are here Today

Internal Audit Division Update Finance and Audit Committee | 10/24/19 Why we are here Today we are here to provide information on Internal Audit activities. Internal Audit Activity Update Internal Audits Completed Internal

257 views • 12 slides
Hugh L. Carey Battery Park City Authority Annual Post-Audit Report to the Audit Committee (Under

Hugh L. Carey Battery Park City Authority Annual Post-Audit Report to the Audit Committee (Under

Hugh L. Carey Battery Park City Authority Annual Post-Audit Report to the Audit Committee (Under AICPA AU-C Section 260) For the Audit Year Ended October 31, 2018 Marks Paneth LLP 685 Third Avenue New York, NY 10017 P 212.503.8800 F

103 views • 8 slides
Final Accounts 2018/19 Audit & Standards Committee 11 th July 2019 AGENDA 1. Role of Audit

Final Accounts 2018/19 Audit & Standards Committee 11 th July 2019 AGENDA 1. Role of Audit

Final Accounts 2018/19 Audit & Standards Committee 11 th July 2019 AGENDA 1. Role of Audit & Standards Committee in scrutinising statement of accounts 2. Key financial highlights 3. Audit adjustments ROLE OF AUDIT & STANDARDS

428 views • 18 slides

More recommend