Appeal of MIP6 Consensus Call Thomas Narten narten@us.ibm.com Misc - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Feb 14, 2024 •348 likes •401 views

Appeal of MIP6 Consensus Call Thomas Narten narten@us.ibm.com Misc Points Consensus was rough, would be nice if there was clearer agreement We don't formally vote, votes best used to get sense of community and to verify/find areas of

Appeal of MIP6 Consensus Call Thomas Narten narten@us.ibm.com
Misc Points ● Consensus was rough, would be nice if there was clearer agreement ● We don't formally vote, votes best used to get sense of community and to verify/find areas of agreement ● “Packing the room” is something we should watch for, but must also be careful about calling out: – Lurkers can be very informed – Posters can be underinformed – Counting company votes can also be problematical
Original Consensus Call ● Should we standardize the authentication protocol specified in I-D draft-ietf-mip6-auth- protocol-00.txt as an alternative (to the IPSec mechanism specified in RFC3775/6) means to securing the BUs and BAcks between the MN and HA. Note that this solution is an additional mechanism for doing registration with an HA and does not deprecate the currently specified solution.
draft-ietf-mip6-auth-protocol-00.txt ● Choices: – Do not publish at all ● Has consequences for relevance of IETF – Publish on Standards Track ● Sends signal that this is a recommended way forward, has IETF support, etc. – Publish as Informational/Experimental ● Does get IETF review ● Has been done in other situations (e.g, 3GPP)

Recommend

Consensus and Dissent or: Meta - Consensus Consensus about what we have consensus

Consensus and Dissent or: Meta - Consensus Consensus about what we have consensus on Building on Bitcoin Lisboa, Portugal -- 4 July 2018 Paul Sztorc Twitter: @truthcoin paul@tierion.com 16C8 1597 E76E 86E6 C01E F037 AA4B 3330

619 views • 37 slides

Security on demand for (DS)MIP6 I-D:

Security on demand for (DS)MIP6 I-D: dra9-bajko-mext-sod Gabor Bajko, Basavaraj PaCl, Teemu Savolainen Background Securing the traffic or user

683 views • 5 slides

Consensus Building Consensus is Consensus is finding an acceptable proposal that all members

Consensus Building Consensus is Consensus is finding an acceptable proposal that all members can support. Consensus is not A unanimous vote A majority vote Everyone 100% satisfied Consensus requires Time Active

351 views • 7 slides

Distributed Algorithms (PhD course) Consensus SARDAR MUHAMMAD SULAMAN Consensus The

Distributed Algorithms (PhD course) Consensus SARDAR MUHAMMAD SULAMAN Consensus The processes use consensus to agree on a common value out of values they initially propose Reaching consensus is one of the most fundamental problems in

592 views • 38 slides

1 What makes consensus hard? Fischer, Lynch and Patterson Fundamentally, the issue revolves

Consensus a classic problem Consensus, impossibility Consensus abstraction underlies many results and Paxos distributed systems and protocols N processes They start execution with inputs { 0,1} Ken Birman Asynchronous,

255 views • 8 slides

AppealTraining.com Webinar 50 Appeal Letters And How To Use Them Like A Pro Presenter: Tammy

AppealTraining.com Webinar 50 Appeal Letters And How To Use Them Like A Pro Presenter: Tammy Tipton President, Appeal Solutions t.tipton@appealsolutions.com What Goes Wrong With Appeals Untimely appeal submission Medicare appeal

235 views • 21 slides

When Aeron Met Raft Martin Thompson - @mjpt777 What does Consensus mean? consensus

Cluster Consensus When Aeron Met Raft Martin Thompson - @mjpt777 What does Consensus mean? consensus noun \ k n- sen(t)-s s \ : general agreement : unanimity Source: http://www.merriam-webster.com/ consensus noun \ k

1.14k views • 68 slides

CONSENSUS Fall 2012 Ken Birman Consensus a classic problem Consensus abstraction underlies

IMPOSSIBILITY OF CONSENSUS Fall 2012 Ken Birman Consensus a classic problem Consensus abstraction underlies many distributed systems and protocols N processes They start execution with inputs {0,1} Asynchronous,

511 views • 35 slides

Lecture 21: Consensus - 1 1 Consensus is agreement. A question is seen as settled. Sometimes a

HPSC 1001/1901/2101/2901 WHAT IS THIS THING CALLED SCIENCE? Semester 2, 2020 Lecture 21: Consensus - 1 1 Consensus is agreement. A question is seen as settled. Sometimes a topic is no longer discussed, as the evidence is agreed to be

456 views • 33 slides

Appealing to the Court of Appeal Criminal Division The Appeal Solicitors Perspective The Current

Appealing to the Court of Appeal Criminal Division The Appeal Solicitors Perspective The Current Challenges The ever increasing weight of The brick wall in seeking to applicants access original case material and exhibits

714 views • 23 slides

The Overview of The Workers Compensation Appeal Board and The Appeal Process Presentation by:

The Overview of The Workers Compensation Appeal Board and The Appeal Process Presentation by: Alfonso Frioni, Jr., Esq., Chairman Robert A. Krebs, Esq., Commissioner The Pennsylvania Workers Compensation Appeal Board Pennsylvania

843 views • 12 slides

Consensus in Distributed Systems Jeff Chase Duke University Consensus P 1 P 1 v 1 d 1

Consensus in Distributed Systems Jeff Chase Duke University Consensus P 1 P 1 v 1 d 1 Unreliable Consensus multicast algorithm P 2 P 3 P 2 P 3 v 2 d 2 v 3 d 3 Step 1 Step 2 Propose. Decide. Generalizes to N nodes/processes.

334 views • 10 slides

May 2019 PWSRCAC Board Meeting VMT Administrative Appeal What was appealed? Parties to

May 2019 PWSRCAC Board Meeting VMT Administrative Appeal What was appealed? Parties to appeal Appeal process Outcome Valdez Duck s e Flats l i m 4 Valdez Marine Terminal Solomon Gulch Hatchery s e m i l 2 VMT

219 views • 10 slides

Distributed Algorithms (PhD course) Consensus SARDAR MUHAMMAD SULAMAN Consensus (Recapitulation)

Distributed Algorithms (PhD course) Consensus SARDAR MUHAMMAD SULAMAN Consensus (Recapitulation) A consensus abstraction is specified in terms of two events: 1. Propose ( propose | v ) Each process has an initial value v that it proposes

636 views • 45 slides

Consensus: Paxos Haobin Ni Oct 22, 2018 What is consensus? A group of people go to the same

Consensus: Paxos Haobin Ni Oct 22, 2018 What is consensus? A group of people go to the same place for the same meal. A set of nodes have the same value for the same variable. X=7 X=7 X=7 Why is it important? In state machine replication

1.1k views • 46 slides

TORONTO LOCAL APPEAL BODY Orientation for Members of the Toronto Local Appeal Body (TLAB) Brian

TORONTO LOCAL APPEAL BODY Orientation for Members of the Toronto Local Appeal Body (TLAB) Brian Duxbury & T. David Marshall Local Appeal Body 1 What we will Cover Today 1. Legislative authority for the establishment of the TLAB - City of

355 views • 13 slides

FLP Impossibility & Weakest Failure Detector Consensus Protocols in Theory Philip Daian -

FLP Impossibility & Weakest Failure Detector Consensus Protocols in Theory Philip Daian - 10/25 slides influenced by Birman FA12 slides Consensus! Courtesy of https://rethinkdb.com Consensus Example Clients Storage Leader Consensus

1.53k views • 78 slides

Consensus Variants Usman Mazhar Mirza 6/17/2013 1 Consensus Variants In the variants we

Consensus Variants Usman Mazhar Mirza 6/17/2013 1 Consensus Variants In the variants we consider here, just like in consensus, the processes need to make consistent decisions, such as agreeing on one common value. Most of the

590 views • 35 slides

AppealTraining.com Webinar 25 Appeal Letters And Using PPACA For Today's Appeals Presenter:

AppealTraining.com Webinar 25 Appeal Letters And Using PPACA For Today's Appeals Presenter: Tammy Tipton President, Appeal Solutions t.tipton@appealsolutions.com PPACA Appeal Standards PPACA sought to improve the inconsistent claims

1.23k views • 27 slides

Proof of Luck: an Efficient Blockchain Consensus Protocol Mitar Milutinovic, Warren He, Howard

Proof of Luck: an Efficient Blockchain Consensus Protocol Mitar Milutinovic, Warren He, Howard Wu, Maxinder Kanwal Outline Background: blockchains, consensus, and SGX Existing consensus mechanisms Our paper: 3 basic consensus primitives Proof

527 views • 50 slides

Greenaction for Health and Environmental Justice Appeal of India Basin Mixed-Use Project Summary

Greenaction for Health and Environmental Justice Appeal of India Basin Mixed-Use Project Summary of Appeal Greenaction filed the appeal on behalf of our many members who are low income people of color residents of Bayview Hunters Point.

425 views • 19 slides

CATHOLIC APPEAL local church REPORT ON THE 2014 APPEAL Goal = $2,500,000 Dollars Raised =

2015 ANNUAL Diocese of Toledo to meet the needs of our CATHOLIC APPEAL local church REPORT ON THE 2014 APPEAL Goal = $2,500,000 Dollars Raised = $2,398,228.70 % of Goal = 95.9% Donors 17,775 Participation % = 18.2% Parishes over Goal

543 views • 18 slides

Consensus vanilladb.org Consensus Uses: bebBroadcast PerfectFailureDetection

Consensus vanilladb.org Consensus Uses: bebBroadcast PerfectFailureDetection Properties Termination Every correct process eventually decides some value. Validity If a process decides v , then v was proposed by some

464 views • 21 slides

Hybrid Consensus: Efficient Consensus in the Permissionless Model Rafael Pass and Elaine Shi

Hybrid Consensus: Efficient Consensus in the Permissionless Model Rafael Pass and Elaine Shi IC3 1 Blockchains Satoshi Nakamoto, 2009 Public database Shared & maintained between network participants Blockchain agreement protocol

296 views • 15 slides